Sandbar

55 Main St, Cold Spring Harbor
(631) 498-6188

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Lauren

This place is a hidden gem, the staff is very friendly and accommodating. The food of course is the star of the show. Our reservation was for four people and each one of us was raving about our meals, appetizers AND desserts. I think we have found a new regular spot!

Laura

I grew up on CSH and was back for a significant high school reunion. I was so glad to see that the beautiful church was utilized in such a wonderful way. The restaurant exceeded my expectations and will be my go to from now on.

David

The help was outstanding! Food was great and filling. The bar drinks were perfect as always. Thank You!

Robin

We love Sandbar. The bar staff are incredible, James and Bonnie are professional and friendly. The servers and bussers are friendly and thorough. All the hostesses are great at making everyone feel comfortable. Service and food are terrific.

Russell

Always a great experience since opening 10 years ago. James and the entire staff are the best. High quality and great value.

Charlie

We visited Sandbar for Restaurant Week and couldn't have been more impressed! The special menu was an incredible deal with very generous portions. I had the cod dish with coconut broth — hands down the best cod I've ever had in my life. It's an absolute must-try. My wife had the salmon with cilantro couscous and kept saying how amazing and thoughtful the flavors were. For dessert, we shared the chocolate lava cake and the crème brûlée, and both were the perfect sweet finish to an unforgettable evening. A huge shoutout to our server, Carlos, who was super informative about the menu and had an awesome attitude the whole night. Thanks to the amazing food, beautiful atmosphere, and outstanding service, we're already booking our next reservation. Can't wait to come back!

Olivia

We had an incredible experience at Sandbar! The restaurant itself is absolutely beautiful — from the relaxed coastal vibe to the elegant details, it's the perfect spot for a special night out. The highlight of our meal was definitely the crispy rice tuna — it was perfectly balanced, with just the right amount of texture and flavor. Our server, Janessa, made the evening even more memorable with her warm, attentive service and great recommendations. Everything from start to finish exceeded our expectations. We can't wait to come back!

Seth

We have been coming to Sandbar for years and have never been disappointed until last night. The big thing was the food. The tuna tartare was tasteless and my salmon was over cooked.

Joanne

Amazing food and we were not rushed to eat and leave quickly. Our waiter Carlos was very helpful and knowledgeable about the food selections.

charlie

My entree was cold and that was a big turnoff. Been there before, probably won't go back for a while

Lili

Food would be 4 star, if it was served hotter. Every visit the dishes come out “warm”, next visit we will ask that they be “hot”. Overall, nice dining experience.

Christopher

Mom's 87th birthday. Parking was a breeze. Hostess Carli had a great personality and made us feel at home. Our waiter, Paris, was very attentive and did an excellent job of making sure we all were satisfied. I've been here many times it keeps getting better!

Jordan G

Great food, atmosphere, and service. Definitely check this restaurant out.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joli

First, shout out to Kenneth our server! He took such good care of the 6 of us as we had lots of questions (first time at restaurant). 5 of the 6 of us live on the West Coast, so always have a lobster roll when we can. It was one of the best I've ever had. One person had the fish tacos and said they were excellent. I believe him because he wolfed them down. I chose this restaurant not knowing anything about it or the area, and luck was on my side. If I lived nearby I'd be a regular.

Alex Romanov

Stop by for a lunch. The ambience and atmosphere is really good here. Food is good as well by the coffee is horrible. We ordered latte but it seems they got regular brewed coffee and added milk. Would not recommend to order coffee here

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 4

Loading...