Sandbar

55 Main St, Cold Spring Harbor
(631) 498-6188

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Opentable Diner

We walked in. Had a reservation. Nobody was at the hostess stand to greet us. We waited about 5-7 minutes. Water service not good. We had to ask for water 2 times. Bartender was new and my drink came out later than expected. Server apologized and said coffee is on me. After the meal. He never offered coffee. Also my husband ordered a beer and it came after entree was served.

Naomi G

Fantastic dining experience at Sandbar. Our food was incredibly fresh and delicious, good portions and presentation, and the restaurant had a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Our server Brandon was fantastic, providing personalized recommendations and just being very attentive overall. Very positive experience and would highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Elizabeth Seiden

Excellent restaurant. A little noisy.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

robert stephanek

Treat yourself to the Duck Taco Appetizer! It was amazing!! Not something I would have ordered, but I cannot wait to have them again! Delicious!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mark

this place is a gem. A very pretty restaurant with a great menu. The fact that it is located on the beautiful Cold Spring Harbor Main Street is a bonus.

Dawn

One of my favorite spots on Long Island. The food is great, the decor beautiful and the staff is always fantastic.

Ed

Is our favorite restaurant in cole spring harbor. Five star all around.However, our last visit for brunch.It was incredibly noisy, not the restaurant's fault. They were packed, otherwise, everything would have been a perfect ten rating.

Margaret Rusch

Everything we had was delicious! The drinks were good, all meat cooked perfectly, good size portions. Staff is very pleasant.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

KDNY POS

Octopus was good, Salmon is ok.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Kevin F

Nice atmosphere and friendly staff. Great spot for a nicer than casual lunch

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Matthew Silpe

Short staffed. Bar wait was unbearable. That said, the food and ambiance was terrific.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

Donnie Karns

Absolutely incredible food. The spicy tuna crispy rice and chickpea fries blew us away, as did the premium oysters. We were even given spicy tuna on the house which we were very grateful for. Great friendly service too.

We were skeptical based on proximity to the main road, but once seated, the road and foot traffic just blended into the overall beautiful ambience of the lively bustle of the harbor area.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Debbie

Disappointing experience Service was not great salad crab and shrimp stack ( SEAFOOD WAS INVISIBLE) MOSTLY EGG AND TOMATOES

Susan

The food was delicious, & service was good, but I wish the serving staff would understand that there was no reason to deliver entrees before we were even finished with our appetizer. It was a quiet Thursday afternoon with lots of empty tables, not a busy Saturday night. Timing is everything.

Reggie

Absolutely amazing food. My wife and I love the chefs creations. It's our new favorite place on Long Island. We cant get enough and the service is always on par!

Loading...