I've been going here every year after hiking up Bull Hill and have never been disappointed. Service is extremely friendly, attentive, and welcoming. The food is great, plating/presentation could be improved but it doesn't stop you from chowing down!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Maria Resetar
While we only get out to this area once or twice a year, Cathryn's is our absolute go to! The food never dissapoints and the staff are all so friendly and courteous.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
SSTIL PvtLtd
Arrived at 1:15 on time for pre reservations, were seated 15 minutes later. Ordered drinks but the drinks arrived after 45 minutes. We totally understand sometimes things get busy but the food came after additional 45 minutes. Pasta was uncooked and cold. Best part of the meal was bread with olive oil.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Karina Turgut
The service was truly amazing — everyone was so friendly and attentive. You can tell the staff really cares, even though they seemed a bit overwhelmed with the full foliage rush.
That said, I think the food could be improved. The dishes sound more sophisticated than they actually are, and the prices don’t quite match the quality. My pasta (fusilli with mushrooms) was pretty basic, though the burger meat was very good.
The outdoor area feels pretty standard, while the inside has an upscale vibe but confusing décor — the paintings don’t really fit the theme. The wine prices are also on the higher side, even compared to Manhattan.
Overall, wonderful service and kind staff, but the menu and ambiance could use some adjustments to match what the place seems to aim for.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Piotr Sowa
Cold Spring needs a good food. This place is ok but nothing to rage about.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
victoria
The food was good but the portion size does not align with the price point.
janice delacruz
Went as a walk in. Had Melissa as a server. She was wonderful! It was a very busy night but we got our food and drinks fairly quickly. The whole time Melissa was attentive and so friendly. Will definitely eat there again to sit in her section
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Angela Ghiozzi
Wonderful dinner, as always! The food is exquisite. Such a pleasure dining here.
Julian Cornwell
Excellent food and service. Any complaints you may read about inattention or slowness in my opinion are from patrons not acknowledging that this a small town restaurant adapting to tourism influx.
Tony Bvo
Was sat immediately. Server poured us water and he disappeared for 20min. We left never getting bread or a menu.
Lovely, attentive service and delicious pasta! What more could you ask for?
Angelina Schiffres
Really good food and great service. Very accommodating with my 11 month old baby too!
Donna Heckmann
Every time I've come here I've always had a great experience. Staff members really go out of their way to make you feel welcome. The waitress Emma specifically is so sweet and helpful!
Jeff P
Many of these reviews talk about how rude the host/owner is. Well, I experienced it myself on a recent visit. Treated like a second class citizen by the host when waiting for a table with a very demanding tone where to wait, etc. He didn't really seem to care whether you ate there or not. Never seen that before in a restaurant. Won't be going back.
Rebecca Hochlowski
Fantastic house made pasta. Highly recommend! Staff knew their menu and recommended great options.
I've been going here every year after hiking up Bull Hill and have never been disappointed. Service is extremely friendly, attentive, and welcoming. The food is great, plating/presentation could be improved but it doesn't stop you from chowing down!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
While we only get out to this area once or twice a year, Cathryn's is our absolute go to! The food never dissapoints and the staff are all so friendly and courteous.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Arrived at 1:15 on time for pre reservations, were seated 15 minutes later. Ordered drinks but the drinks arrived after 45 minutes. We totally understand sometimes things get busy but the food came after additional 45 minutes. Pasta was uncooked and cold. Best part of the meal was bread with olive oil.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
The service was truly amazing — everyone was so friendly and attentive. You can tell the staff really cares, even though they seemed a bit overwhelmed with the full foliage rush.
That said, I think the food could be improved. The dishes sound more sophisticated than they actually are, and the prices don’t quite match the quality. My pasta (fusilli with mushrooms) was pretty basic, though the burger meat was very good.
The outdoor area feels pretty standard, while the inside has an upscale vibe but confusing décor — the paintings don’t really fit the theme. The wine prices are also on the higher side, even compared to Manhattan.
Overall, wonderful service and kind staff, but the menu and ambiance could use some adjustments to match what the place seems to aim for.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Cold Spring needs a good food. This place is ok but nothing to rage about.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
The food was good but the portion size does not align with the price point.
Went as a walk in. Had Melissa as a server. She was wonderful! It was a very busy night but we got our food and drinks fairly quickly. The whole time Melissa was attentive and so friendly. Will definitely eat there again to sit in her section
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wonderful dinner, as always! The food is exquisite. Such a pleasure dining here.
Excellent food and service. Any complaints you may read about inattention or slowness in my opinion are from patrons not acknowledging that this a small town restaurant adapting to tourism influx.
Was sat immediately. Server poured us water and he disappeared for 20min. We left never getting bread or a menu.
Restaurantji Recommends
Lovely, attentive service and delicious pasta! What more could you ask for?
Really good food and great service. Very accommodating with my 11 month old baby too!
Every time I've come here I've always had a great experience. Staff members really go out of their way to make you feel welcome. The waitress Emma specifically is so sweet and helpful!
Many of these reviews talk about how rude the host/owner is. Well, I experienced it myself on a recent visit. Treated like a second class citizen by the host when waiting for a table with a very demanding tone where to wait, etc. He didn't really seem to care whether you ate there or not. Never seen that before in a restaurant. Won't be going back.
Fantastic house made pasta. Highly recommend! Staff knew their menu and recommended great options.
Loading...