Traditional pizza restaurant. Lots of locals eating in and carrying out. I had a personal gluten free pizza. It was a thin crispy crust loaded with cheese. Yum. My group devoured a large cheese. I wish I wasn't gluten sensitive.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
NeL R
It tastes fresh, the best thing about the pizza here is the crust and the dough, it's PERFECT! Flavor on the other hand...it matches their service, bland. Which is a shame because the ingredients are all there, just no flavor, but does have a flesh taste.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
TJ Askren
Delicious. Best slice while visiting NY. People working there were really friendly and even shared a few secrets about their pizza. Lovely town. Enjoyed sitting outside with our food. Would definitely return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nanette Wallace
Love, love their eggplant anything! And the shrimp pharm was amazing. I have to mention that it was cooked perfectly and not fishy . Just wonderful.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Guy Saar
Great pizza. Really loved it
Louis Crespo
Very busy pizza shop food was good and the prices were reasonable.We'll go back 🤗👌👍
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Yolanda Poh
Ordered take-out fried calamari from Cold Spring Pizza and found green mold on the calamari itself under the breading. Very concerning and unsafe — had to throw it out. Won’t be ordering again.
Food: 1
Max NoName
We absolutely loved this place! After a long 6-hour hike from Beacon to Cold Spring, we came here a bit late and the classic pies were already gone, so we tried a slice of Grandma Margherita Pizza and one Eggplant pizza. The Grandma Margherita was simply amazing – wow! The Eggplant slice is more for those who enjoy that flavor, but still interesting to try.
The atmosphere was warm and welcoming, and the staff were super friendly. This spot always feels like the right choice when we come to Cold Spring. After such a tough hike, that pizza was exactly what we needed. Highly recommended to everyone!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lea
Hmm they conveniently don't have prices listed on the big menu board, which I suspect is so that they can try to overcharge you and say oh sorry I meant x price if the price they give you seems excessive and you say something, which is what happened to me. asked for cheese with onions on personal size, said it was $15, so I just got it w/ no toppings for $9. also kinda crazy they said 1 slice was $6, which is why I just went with personal. frankly felt like they weren't happy w/ me after I questioned the price.. Mostly, the pizza was just overcooked; you could barely fold it! (but considering it was only $9, it wasn't bad)
They have credit card fee 3.5% without posting a sign.
Section 518 of the General Business Law, which, in no uncertain terms, makes it illegal for merchants to charge extra if a customer wants to use a credit card. New York enacted section 518 in 1984, and although it was modeled on a federal law, it was just vague enough to pose problems, especially when it came to interpreting certain terms it contained.
The transaction occurred before the regulation changed. Even if it is true, you are still in violation anyway.
According to your response, I feel uncomfortable with your response. What’s a Shame
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
A L
After another massive hike I was desperate for a cold beer and some hearty Italian food. To my surprise they stocked a good selection of beers as well as fizzy drinks.
Their prices are decent and their portions are huge! I believe they are also connected to the ice cream shop next door.
We’ll be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A M
Awesome find me. One of the best pizza I ever had. Specially the sisilian pie.
Traditional pizza restaurant. Lots of locals eating in and carrying out. I had a personal gluten free pizza. It was a thin crispy crust loaded with cheese. Yum. My group devoured a large cheese. I wish I wasn't gluten sensitive.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
It tastes fresh, the best thing about the pizza here is the crust and the dough, it's PERFECT! Flavor on the other hand...it matches their service, bland. Which is a shame because the ingredients are all there, just no flavor, but does have a flesh taste.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Delicious. Best slice while visiting NY. People working there were really friendly and even shared a few secrets about their pizza. Lovely town. Enjoyed sitting outside with our food. Would definitely return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love, love their eggplant anything! And the shrimp pharm was amazing. I have to mention that it was cooked perfectly and not fishy . Just wonderful.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Great pizza. Really loved it
Very busy pizza shop food was good and the prices were reasonable.We'll go back 🤗👌👍
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Ordered take-out fried calamari from Cold Spring Pizza and found green mold on the calamari itself under the breading. Very concerning and unsafe — had to throw it out. Won’t be ordering again.
Food: 1
We absolutely loved this place! After a long 6-hour hike from Beacon to Cold Spring, we came here a bit late and the classic pies were already gone, so we tried a slice of Grandma Margherita Pizza and one Eggplant pizza. The Grandma Margherita was simply amazing – wow! The Eggplant slice is more for those who enjoy that flavor, but still interesting to try.
The atmosphere was warm and welcoming, and the staff were super friendly. This spot always feels like the right choice when we come to Cold Spring. After such a tough hike, that pizza was exactly what we needed. Highly recommended to everyone!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hmm they conveniently don't have prices listed on the big menu board, which I suspect is so that they can try to overcharge you and say oh sorry I meant x price if the price they give you seems excessive and you say something, which is what happened to me. asked for cheese with onions on personal size, said it was $15, so I just got it w/ no toppings for $9. also kinda crazy they said 1 slice was $6, which is why I just went with personal. frankly felt like they weren't happy w/ me after I questioned the price..
Mostly, the pizza was just overcooked; you could barely fold it! (but considering it was only $9, it wasn't bad)
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 2
Great food!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Super tasty pies here! And the staff is great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best 🍕 in have had in a long time. Friendly 🐈.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They have credit card fee 3.5% without posting a sign.
Section 518 of the General Business Law, which, in no uncertain terms, makes it illegal for merchants to charge extra if a customer wants to use a credit card. New York enacted section 518 in 1984, and although it was modeled on a federal law, it was just vague enough to pose problems, especially when it came to interpreting certain terms it contained.
The transaction occurred before the regulation changed. Even if it is true, you are still in violation anyway.
According to your response, I feel uncomfortable with your response. What’s a Shame
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
After another massive hike I was desperate for a cold beer and some hearty Italian food. To my surprise they stocked a good selection of beers as well as fizzy drinks.
Their prices are decent and their portions are huge! I believe they are also connected to the ice cream shop next door.
We’ll be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Awesome find me. One of the best pizza I ever had. Specially the sisilian pie.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...