Went there last night for dinner and I have to say the food was completely disappointing. First off my wife ordered the Shrimp and Grits and I ordered the Steak and Mushroom Risotto. She received a bowl that had overcooked shrimp, rice and some pickled shredded white vegetable and other veggies and raisins. Was nowhere near Shrimp with Chipolte Grits and Gouda. My steak was flavorless and dry, even though it was rare and in fact tasted like it had been in the freezer too long, not a good quality strip steak. The Risotto however was really good. So after I got the bill, I noticed that they didn't get the order right, it was in fact something like Crispy Shrimp and Rice Bowl. I don't normally complain and didn't want to make a scene, so we didn't say anything, we paid and left. We were both hungry, but this meal was a means to an end. Don't know if they had an off night but I would be reluctant to return again. I hate leaving bad reviews but this meal was nowhere near the quality it should've been for the $66 we paid before tip. That only included 2 diet sodas, no expensive drinks or any apps. The server was very nice, I'd give her a 4-5 stars, service was pretty fast, again 4-5 stars, but food would be a 1 star due to the quality, the wrong order and the price.
R.
We just went for the day . My kids played in the sand and got in the water which was great. We sat under the tent which was a plus because it was hot. Only the grill and bar was open, but it was so good. We had 0 complaints. My son said it was the best shrimp and chicken wings he's ever had. Their fries were my fav. On Mondays they had half off margaritas . They were the best ones I've ever had. Especially the peach! We will be back for sure
Dillon Reynolds
Food and drinks: The food was absolutely amazing! The view is stunning. The staff is so friendly. Highly recommend this place to anyone around or traveling to the area. One of the best spots around!
Service: 5
Jocelyn Young
This was a great place! Nice atmosphere! Clean! The owner was very personable and kind. The food is great at the restaurant and the staff is efficient and friendly! I'd stay here again!
Service: 5
Dave Dolan
Good food.
tina lesher
This place is so cute! Located right in the water. There's great food, great drinks, and plenty of spots to hang out
Food and drinks: There are several spots for food and drinks. There is a restaurant, cabana and walk up grill area. The night we stayed, there was league volleyball going on and it was fun to watch
Service: 5
Tony Mcninch
Water front dive bar at its best
Service: 5
Susan McFarlane
The Beachcomber is a lakeside resort! My husband and I have stayed in the rooms however, recently we stayed in the Sunrise Suite and we will definitely return! The suite was spotless, the bed was super comfortable and the balcony deck overlooking the water was fantastic. Add great food in both the cabana and dining room, some fun music…what’s not to like!
Rooms: Spacious, large bathroom, great shower/tub….the king size bed in the Sunrise Suite is perfect!
Nearby activities: Nearby winery definitely worth visiting! We always enjoy Vitale Park at the north end of the Lake. AND…it’s a short drive to Lake Ontario Charlotte Beach and Sea Breeze Amusement Park! Love Conesus Lake and the Beachcomber.
Food and drinks: The lunch food at the Cabana is what you would expect…burgers, hot dogs, sweet potato fries…but the dinners in the restaurant are better than average! Our family enjoyed the Lobster seafood dish, the pasta shrimp dish, the double burgers and the kids loved their Mac & cheese! Cocktails and wine pretty good too! Excellent service with great people!
Service: 5
James Garcia
What a great place. The Beachcomber has everything. Full restaurant with great food. Cool bar with pool and darts. Bar/ grill menu if want something more casual, and even ice cream. They have live music on the weekends and volleyball leagues during the week. We loved watching the games from our balcony. Not to mention the beautiful views of the lake and they even had doc space for our rental boat. We could not have been happier spending the week there. Mary Alice and her staff were fantastic and more than happy to help us with anything we needed.
Nearby activities: When we weren’t cruising the lake on our boat we played 2 great golf courses less than 15 minutes away and got to check out the incredible waterfalls at Letchworth State park. Only a 40 minute drive.
Service: 5
Mike Lupi
Incredibly slow service. Drinks took 1 hour, apps 1.5 hours. Then finally got entree 2 hours after sitting down. Never coming back to this trash establishment don't waste your time
Verrrryyyyy slow service. Didn’t get drinks until an hour after sitting down and ordering, then apps about 15 mins later. Entrees came 2 hours after sitting down. Don’t recommend wasting your time here.
Not the waiters fault I think they are severely understaffed.
Service: 1
Amy Southcott
We went to listen to North 43 play so we made a night of it. We stayed in the Sunrise Suite , it was heavenly. Mary Alice who is the owner, was so fun and made sure we had a good time and that we had everything for a comfortable night sleep! I can’t wait to go back. I would def recommend 10/10 for atmosphere, cleanliness, comfort, and hospitality!! Go try it for yourself:)
Service: 5
Albert Vitale
Great experience. Good music. Good food. Good people
Service: 5
Andrea Rene
Super cute little lakefront bar. Friendly staff and amazing drinks.
Steve Hoskins
Don’t know about the rooms, but great food and atmosphere. Great place to enjoy some outdoor music and views of the lake!
Went there last night for dinner and I have to say the food was completely disappointing. First off my wife ordered the Shrimp and Grits and I ordered the Steak and Mushroom Risotto. She received a bowl that had overcooked shrimp, rice and some pickled shredded white vegetable and other veggies and raisins. Was nowhere near Shrimp with Chipolte Grits and Gouda. My steak was flavorless and dry, even though it was rare and in fact tasted like it had been in the freezer too long, not a good quality strip steak. The Risotto however was really good. So after I got the bill, I noticed that they didn't get the order right, it was in fact something like Crispy Shrimp and Rice Bowl. I don't normally complain and didn't want to make a scene, so we didn't say anything, we paid and left. We were both hungry, but this meal was a means to an end. Don't know if they had an off night but I would be reluctant to return again. I hate leaving bad reviews but this meal was nowhere near the quality it should've been for the $66 we paid before tip. That only included 2 diet sodas, no expensive drinks or any apps. The server was very nice, I'd give her a 4-5 stars, service was pretty fast, again 4-5 stars, but food would be a 1 star due to the quality, the wrong order and the price.
We just went for the day . My kids played in the sand and got in the water which was great. We sat under the tent which was a plus because it was hot. Only the grill and bar was open, but it was so good. We had 0 complaints. My son said it was the best shrimp and chicken wings he's ever had. Their fries were my fav. On Mondays they had half off margaritas . They were the best ones I've ever had. Especially the peach! We will be back for sure
Food and drinks: The food was absolutely amazing! The view is stunning. The staff is so friendly. Highly recommend this place to anyone around or traveling to the area. One of the best spots around!
Service: 5
This was a great place! Nice atmosphere! Clean! The owner was very personable and kind. The food is great at the restaurant and the staff is efficient and friendly! I'd stay here again!
Service: 5
Good food.
This place is so cute! Located right in the water. There's great food, great drinks, and plenty of spots to hang out
Food and drinks: There are several spots for food and drinks. There is a restaurant, cabana and walk up grill area. The night we stayed, there was league volleyball going on and it was fun to watch
Service: 5
Water front dive bar at its best
Service: 5
The Beachcomber is a lakeside resort! My husband and I have stayed in the rooms however, recently we stayed in the Sunrise Suite and we will definitely return! The suite was spotless, the bed was super comfortable and the balcony deck overlooking the water was fantastic. Add great food in both the cabana and dining room, some fun music…what’s not to like!
Rooms: Spacious, large bathroom, great shower/tub….the king size bed in the Sunrise Suite is perfect!
Nearby activities: Nearby winery definitely worth visiting! We always enjoy Vitale Park at the north end of the Lake. AND…it’s a short drive to Lake Ontario Charlotte Beach and Sea Breeze Amusement Park! Love Conesus Lake and the Beachcomber.
Food and drinks: The lunch food at the Cabana is what you would expect…burgers, hot dogs, sweet potato fries…but the dinners in the restaurant are better than average! Our family enjoyed the Lobster seafood dish, the pasta shrimp dish, the double burgers and the kids loved their Mac & cheese! Cocktails and wine pretty good too! Excellent service with great people!
Service: 5
What a great place. The Beachcomber has everything. Full restaurant with great food. Cool bar with pool and darts. Bar/ grill menu if want something more casual, and even ice cream.
They have live music on the weekends and volleyball leagues during the week. We loved watching the games from our balcony. Not to mention the beautiful views of the lake and they even had doc space for our rental boat. We could not have been happier spending the week there. Mary Alice and her staff were fantastic and more than happy to help us with anything we needed.
Nearby activities: When we weren’t cruising the lake on our boat we played 2 great golf courses less than 15 minutes away and got to check out the incredible waterfalls at Letchworth State park. Only a 40 minute drive.
Service: 5
Incredibly slow service. Drinks took 1 hour, apps 1.5 hours. Then finally got entree 2 hours after sitting down. Never coming back to this trash establishment don't waste your time
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Verrrryyyyy slow service. Didn’t get drinks until an hour after sitting down and ordering, then apps about 15 mins later. Entrees came 2 hours after sitting down. Don’t recommend wasting your time here.
Not the waiters fault I think they are severely understaffed.
Service: 1
We went to listen to North 43 play so we made a night of it. We stayed in the Sunrise Suite , it was heavenly. Mary Alice who is the owner, was so fun and made sure we had a good time and that we had everything for a comfortable night sleep! I can’t wait to go back. I would def recommend 10/10 for atmosphere, cleanliness, comfort, and hospitality!! Go try it for yourself:)
Service: 5
Great experience. Good music. Good food. Good people
Service: 5
Super cute little lakefront bar. Friendly staff and amazing drinks.
Don’t know about the rooms, but great food and atmosphere. Great place to enjoy some outdoor music and views of the lake!
Loading...