Colquhoun’s Ice Cream

5543 US-62, Conewango Valley
(716) 338-3617

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kaylee La Spisa

Lovely folks with a lovely operation. Wraps, sandwhiches, ice cream, cheese curds, cookies they know how to make your day a great one!

Matthew Schutt

My sub was awesome! I didn't know you got so much for the price! I'll be back for sure next time I'm around.

Tara Gifford

Subs and ice cream was awesome and the owners r very friendly

Jon Kamholtz

Best subs , sandwiches and ice cream in the area. They have two locations , the new one in the village of Lakewood New York and the Original in Conawango New York

Diana Cheney

Won't be going back. The first time we ordered from there it was good. Today we we went and ordered subs. We asked for them to be toasted. We drove straight home and opened the bags and found very cold and slimy subs. Also when we were waiting for the subs, we witnessed a very rude worker working in the kitchen area. Once again won't be back.

Robert Peck

Food and ice cream were amazing!

Bob Rogers

If you are looking for a deli where the food just isn't fair, Colquhoun's is it. Have been there four times (so far) with the same experience every time: the sandwiches are delicious and too darn big! I'm not usually a big eater but I keep stuffing it in because I can't stop, that good. Prices aren't bad either and the owner makes you feel welcome. Give it a try.

Jennifer Davis

We just stopped in and grabbed some ice cream. It was delicious.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

patrick gorman

Amazing soft serve ice cream.
Best we've ever had!

Food: 5

Recommended dishes: Vanilla Ice Cream Cone

HELLRAISEHR

We stopped on a whim to get some ice cream cones. It's a little place, Friendly owners, plenty of seating.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Vanilla Ice Cream Cone

Levi Shetler's

Ice cream is good but needs bigger straws

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tracy Shelanskey

Delicious icecream!! So many hand crafted flavors, and the service couldn't have been any better. My new icecream place!!?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pint of Ice Cream

Jackie Richard Lawrence

Had soft serve ice cream very good

Janet Aldolph

Delicious Scottish Coffee Toffee flavor

Shawn Mitchell

Excellent subs very nice couple that owns it

Loading...