Restaurant X & Bully Boy Bar

117 NY-303, Congers
(845) 268-6555

Recent Reviews

Sort by
BG20

When we arrived, it was obvious that the restaurant was closed! Even though we had a reservation, which we confirmed through this app! It was Easter Sunday, so it was impossible to find last minute reservations elsewhere. Ruined our food plans and we were terribly disappointed. It should be noted that there are signs on the doors of the restaurant that say it is temporarily closed. Do a better job, Open Table!

M Schneider

This place has been slammin for like 20 years....always good.

We made a reservation for dinner for a special occasion this past Saturday night only to find that the restaurant was closed with a sign in the door and no notification. It was pouring rain and we had to find an alternative last minute. I've always enjoyed the food and ambience at Restaurant X and was very disappointed!

Meagen Ryan

Great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Good food, but was unable to accommodate simple food allergy changes to both starter and main course meals. My wife, could not get a glass of soda after several trys with any syrup in it. Good support service. Overcharged for extra drink, I did not have. Was corrected by waiter.

JackL

The food preparation and presentation are still very good. Unfortunately the decor needs an update. At the very least some new paint and flooring would make the place more inviting.

ElenaA

I love Restaurant X I've celebrated multiple events there and have had a wonderful time on slow nights and busy holidays, except this time. It was an absolute disaster from the valet having us waiting in a line of empty cars, waiting 25 minutes even with our reservation, we didn't have one waiter but a mix of whoever was available, I felt so rushed our 4 course meal was rushed out to us and on a night I wanted to drink my wine enjoy Valentine's Day with my partner and they had us in and out in 40 minutes. Also I always order the beef Wellington it's amazing except this time it was so overdone and tasted like hamburger. This experience left a bad taste in my mouth and ruined a once loved restaurant

DianeC

Restaurant X has always been consistently EXCELLENT for decades!! Peter Kelly is the quintessential super chef that ticks every box. He never disappoints so any choice you make will be a successful one! The staff is professional, knowledgeable and friendly. Cozy environment overall but I especially enjoy the fireplace in the bar area. There's a reason Peter bested Bobby Flay!!

Margaret Jones

First time here and the food was fantastic.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Christopher Shaw

You can’t go wrong with this place.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

LARRY

We went for my wife's birthday, and the food was delicious as usual. We ordered shrimp cocktail appetizer and wedge salad to start. Shrimp were large and very meaty. Salad large enough to share. We had the porterhouse for two cooked medium rare. Came out just right with a nice crispy outside and rare inside.

diana zernone

i love the service and the people that work there and the food its so good i would tell my friends to go

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tricia

Decided to dine here to celebrate the birthday of a friend. It was a distance from home but well worth the ride. The food was outstanding, beautifully presented, and timed perfectly. The wait staff was ever present and without a request anticipated our needs. Atmosphere was pleasant, and we were seated near the fireplace which added to the experience. It was truly a delightful afternoon! We felt like royalty!

Eduarda

This will be my favorite restaurant now. I went with my bf for brunch, and we love the restaurant, the staff and the food. Everything was great! This restaurant is cozy, I just love it. I'm planning to go for dinner as well.

I have dined at this restaurant many times in the past and have always had a good experience. However, after not having been there in several years, I was shocked at the deplorable state of deterioration. The bathroom was nothing short of disgusting, the carpets are all worn and torn. the place hasn't been painted and it seems to be over a decade. Regarding our dinner quality, it was OK, but not even close to our previous experience there. And massively overpriced for the quality we received. Sadly, one of the restaurant X sister restaurants was also a disappointment when we returned there around six months ago. I don't know if there was a change in ownership or management, but my wife and I will not be returning to either place.

Loading...

Restaurant X & Bully Boy Bar

117 NY-303, Congers, NY 10920
(845) 268-6555