Cooperstown Distillery Beverage Exchange

73 Main St, Cooperstown
(607) 282-4374

Recent Reviews

Joel Frank

Had a great tasting experience and my wife enjoyed a fantastic cocktail before purchasing a bottle of bourbon.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Michele Ford

Small drink menu, but good variety. My husband liked the Bourbon mule.Relaxed and intimate settingNikki was great, helpful and very informative.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Adam Horowitz

We came planning on having a single drink after dinner. We ended up staying for five sounds and nearly 4 hours. Jason was a pleasure to talk to and mixed fantastic cocktails. Both on the menu and off his drinks were amazing. If you have one cocktail in Cooperstown, make sure it’s here and mixed by Jason.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Vee kay

Happy new year ! We need more Jason’s around Cooperstown thank w so much

Alec Feducia

Stopped in for a quick drink, Jayson (bartender) more than made it a memorable experience. Great drinks, would absolutely go back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Christina Cobb

Learned tonight the name of the drink with cranberry juice and vodka is called a sea breeze lol. The bar tender Jason was

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 4

IrochkaD D.

We first stopped here in March 2017 while doing admitted students tours with our elder son. Back then, the drinks were 8 bucks, so cheap, and quality! Fast forward to 2023, the prices have gone up, but not overtly so, it's 10-12 bucks now, and you are getting a craft beverage with a top-shelf liquor, expertly made by friendly staff. For food, they have charcuterie board, pretzel and sliders, all priced fairly. I love the cozy seating area in the back. The place was packed to the tilt last Sat after Savannah Bananas game, but the crowd dispersed towards the evening, and we had a great time.

Robert Bradley

Great staff. Very knowledgeable. Extremely helpful and friendly. Awesome place in a neat little town.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Greg Avakian

First of all, Nikki was just terrific at introducing us to their gin and Bourbons.Now, I am not a cocktail guy, and I have limited experience, but I can say without doubt that the quality of libations is undeniable.I have friends who call me a supertaster, so when I can taste a variety of flavors rolling from my lips, tongue, to my throat -each of which is used for different aspects of tasting- I know whether or not what's in my mouth is special.Grateful for the experience of tasting, and yes, I bought stuff. :-)

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Cori Frede

Such a sweet woman was working when I walked in. I ended up buying some Bourbon but was able to test a few other items.I really enjoyed the atmosphere but since I was going elsewhere for dinner I didn't want to just buy a cocktail to sit there and drink.They do have some open bottles for sampling (they pour) so you can taste before you buy.

Arrielle S.

What an unexpected gem! This place doubles as a shop and bar with fancy cocktails. It's the perfect place to start your night with a drink or cap it off!We went here before dinner and it was easy to get a sat at the bar at that time. We also went here also after going to the Cooperstown Distillery earlier in the day so we were well versed on the spirits. I got a Fenimore flyer which was delicious and very boozy. I was definitely ready to party afterwards. My husband got the Manhattan and it was also delicious. The bartenders were also so nice and were chatting with us the whole time telling us about the town and hall of fame induction weekend. You can't go wrong if you stop into this place especially if your from out of town and want a more upscale cocktail experience.

David W.

This is a gem of a place on Main Street in Cooperstown, most known for the National Baseball Hall of Fame. The location is amazingly convenient for the tourists who are going to the local museum or other local dining and shopping spots. While there are other places to get drinks, it's nice to have a place that focuses on a more bar like atmosphere.This is a combo drink service and shopping opportunity for souvenirs, so come here to drink and find gifts to bring to your loved ones (that may not want baseball themed items from the rest of the street). It has a large selection of drinks from the Cooperstown Distillery a few blocks away as well as other souvenirs like shirts, bottles, etc. The drinks, there is a specialty menu crafted for their stock and sometimes baseball themed. When I've visited, the staff is really interactive and will make something not on the menu if you tell them the type of drink you like (e.g. sweet, bitter, something with orange juice, etc.).They mix in locally brewed beer including some of their own. My experience there has been afternoon, not night life. So, it's more of a conversational environment as people come in and naturally are open to sharing their experiences on their trip, in the museum, etc.Only thing keeping it from 5 stars is the somewhat limited tap beer selection, I mean it's great but not perfect.They will have local beers, craft, themed mixed drinks, with knowledgeable staff that can accommodate special requests.

Nathan Chandler

This distillery makes spirits packed with flavor and punch. All of their in-house stuff was really good, and the single-malt whiskey was unique. It's pretty fancy inside and there are couches so you can sit and enjoy a drink and catch part of game or chat.

Josh Sulham

Great service, relaxing atmosphere

Erin Thorp

Fun & delicious Fall cocktail menu! ?: The Great Pumpkin ? (coffee/pumpkin/toasted marshmallow) ?Ambiance: 10, Baseball on TV: 10, Gift shop (baseball-shaped booze, beer, shrubs, merch, etc): 10!

Load More

Cooperstown Distillery Beverage Exchange

73 Main St, Cooperstown, NY 13326
(607) 282-4374