Around the corner from the HOF. So many good specialty sandwiches. Quick service. Good sized portions.
Adem Arifaj
Damn good sandwiches.
Tori L.
A must stop! The sandwiches were delicious and huge with fresh slices of meat packed on fresh bread and veggies. The man working (I imagine he's the owner) was very friendly and talkative. We ordered the stroker and the train wreck with macaroni salad. While the sandwiches were seriously delicious let me tell you about the macaroni salad. Oh my gosh! Definitely so much more than you'd expect from a macaroni salad. We ordered to go and accidentally left the bag of macaroni salad sides in the deli and the owner walked out of the shop and down the road to make sure we got them. Thank goodness he did! If you're looking for a big sandwich with a delicious side you definitely need to go here!
Mary Sheedy-Davis
Awesome (and huge) wraps and interesting sandwiches. All ingredients were high quality and delicious. Highly recommend!
Joe Genovesi
Philly cheese steak was best I've had. Good sized portion too!
Jeffrey Padavan
My wife and I will often do a day trip from Long Island, New York to Cooperstown, then go to Molly’s Deli for the best sandwiches anywhere,. Molly’s sandwiches make it worth the drive!
Veronica L.
Excellent sandwiches. Seems to be a one man operation & he's doing really good work. He's kind & seems to love the business. The each sandwich I've gotten has been amazing. Macaroni salad is homemade- not from 5 gallon bucket!
Melody Shannon-Congdon
Molly's Deli is the ABSOLUTE best place ever to get Rare Roast Beef. When they have their German Potato Salad that is a great choice and don't forget about the Crispy Dill Pickle Spear.
Deb Holmes
The sandwiches are fantastic, great flavor. The sides are home made and delicious, best potato salad I ever had!! Great service.
We came here because, not much was open, and someone driving by, saw us walking aimlessly trying to find something to eat. The sandwiches were absolutely delicious and the portions were very generous. My wife had the pastrami sandwich, which I shared and must admit, was the first time having a pastrami sandwich. Great hidden gem! A must try!
Brian Pokorny
Great service, sandwiches and the abolute best, German Potato Salad!
Rick Reich
Hands down best Deli Cooperstown has ever had and I’ve been here 52 yrs! Prime NY style Hero’s and portions. Bread and rolls are on point! Great service. I hope they didn’t miss their calling with the economy. Place is exceptional. Good Luck.
John R.
Amazing place! I've only been to town once 23 years ago while visiting the Hall Of Fame but all my father was able to find for food was pizza, hotdogs and Italian. (Coming from Albany) A sandwich place is much needed in Cooperstown. This place is now a regular stop for me when I'm in town for work @ Bassett hospital. Highly suggest the roast beef, it's sooooo red
Excellent sandwiches. We will be back!
Around the corner from the HOF. So many good specialty sandwiches. Quick service. Good sized portions.
Damn good sandwiches.
A must stop! The sandwiches were delicious and huge with fresh slices of meat packed on fresh bread and veggies. The man working (I imagine he's the owner) was very friendly and talkative. We ordered the stroker and the train wreck with macaroni salad. While the sandwiches were seriously delicious let me tell you about the macaroni salad. Oh my gosh! Definitely so much more than you'd expect from a macaroni salad. We ordered to go and accidentally left the bag of macaroni salad sides in the deli and the owner walked out of the shop and down the road to make sure we got them. Thank goodness he did! If you're looking for a big sandwich with a delicious side you definitely need to go here!
Awesome (and huge) wraps and interesting sandwiches. All ingredients were high quality and delicious. Highly recommend!
Philly cheese steak was best I've had. Good sized portion too!
My wife and I will often do a day trip from Long Island, New York to Cooperstown, then go to Molly’s Deli for the best sandwiches anywhere,. Molly’s sandwiches make it worth the drive!
Excellent sandwiches. Seems to be a one man operation & he's doing really good work. He's kind & seems to love the business. The each sandwich I've gotten has been amazing. Macaroni salad is homemade- not from 5 gallon bucket!
Molly's Deli is the ABSOLUTE best place ever to get Rare Roast Beef. When they have their German Potato Salad that is a great choice and don't forget about the Crispy Dill Pickle Spear.
The sandwiches are fantastic, great flavor. The sides are home made and delicious, best potato salad I ever had!! Great service.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great lunch! Will definitely go there again.
We came here because, not much was open, and someone driving by, saw us walking aimlessly trying to find something to eat. The sandwiches were absolutely delicious and the portions were very generous. My wife had the pastrami sandwich, which I shared and must admit, was the first time having a pastrami sandwich. Great hidden gem! A must try!
Great service, sandwiches and the abolute best, German Potato Salad!
Hands down best Deli Cooperstown has ever had and I’ve been here 52 yrs! Prime NY style Hero’s and portions. Bread and rolls are on point! Great service. I hope they didn’t miss their calling with the economy. Place is exceptional. Good Luck.
Amazing place! I've only been to town once 23 years ago while visiting the Hall Of Fame but all my father was able to find for food was pizza, hotdogs and Italian. (Coming from Albany) A sandwich place is much needed in Cooperstown. This place is now a regular stop for me when I'm in town for work @ Bassett hospital. Highly suggest the roast beef, it's sooooo red