Maskot's Pizza and Grill

4551 NY-28, Cooperstown
(607) 547-2200

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Joe Golden

Very busy place being it is across from Dreams park. Pizza is decent, pretty average. Lots of room inside and the outside seating is nice. Service was just a young boy walking outside yelling names holding food. I could raise my hand and take anything, if I was that type of person. The other issue was the price. A family of 4 a pizza, 2 fries, and 3 drinks almost $60 is insane. Then my son asked for a 16oz bottle of chocolate milk and I almost passed out when the lady said $5, I pay that for a gallon at home.
Nice place, cool spot next to the axe throwing, waffle ball field ect. But for the actual food way too over priced, one one of my top recommendations while in town unless you are next store at the axe throwing/batting cages or at DreamPark.

Cindy St.pierre

Chicken clubs should not be served on a hamburger roll said it comes with lettuce tomatoes bacon got no bacon and no fries a bag of chips 1 cheese burger and a Pepsi 50.00

Donnie Briley

Service was great. Prices are bit high. Pizza not good especially being $30.00 for a medium. A cup of water $2.00. Fountain drink only allows one refill.

Mike Buck

A quick bite to eat right across from Cooperstown Dreams Park. I get everyone has different tastes and opinions of pizza but this pizza was just average at best. Very expensive, but when you're just about the only pizza place for 10 minutes or so and right in a prime spot I guess you can get away with it. The chicken club was literally a grilled chicken sandwich with LTM and bacon, nothing special at all, didnt even come with fries. Amazing collection of pins all over their walls. Service was somewhat on the slower side, but they were pretty busy and could probably use some more help. Convenient overall I guess.

Shadlee Moyneur

Maskots is the place to go when in Cooperstown. Their customer service is second to none, the food is delicious and the a/c is cold!

Seth Johnson Team

Came from Virginia Beach, Va. this place was amazing- from the staff, cleanliness, food, and service. We ate here 4 different times and it was same experience each time even when it got packed. Sal was great with all his customers and the kids. Make sure you bring pins for the day they do the trading. They can accommodate teams as well!

Brian Hannan

The staff is friendly, and the chicken wings are amazing! If you need a meal and a chance to relax and decompress while your child(ren) “dream” across the street, here’s the place. Lots of classic pins to see and new ones to view and possibly trade. Maskots is the souvenir you wish you could bring home with you!

Somer Lea

Excellent eggplant parm sub. Excellent service! Highly recommend!! Stopped in between ball Blue Sox baseball games.

Todd Sabat

Eat here every day
Awesome people and wonderful food
Go Talkin baseball blue soxs

Ken Bennett

Good food, good drinks and close to Dreams Park.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Charles Miranda

Had a decent meal there. Too crowded

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

John Lim

Over priced pizza ($5 per a slice). Others are low quality. Service is poor. If you don’t have time to eat it would be ok to go but if you have time please stay away.

Marily Rajpolt

We put in a very large order for a team dinner. Everything was ready on time and several people remarked on how great the pizza tasted. The restaurant is clean and spacious and the walls are lined with trading pins. My son traded one of our team’s pins for a chance to pick one from a bucket. Maskots was a home run for our team dinner!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Randy Miller (Ozzie)

The pepperoni pizza is excellent!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

D J

It’s a pizza place ??‍♂️

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Loading...