Rusty Bison

4938 NY-28, Cooperstown
(607) 282-4347

Recent Reviews

Sort by
david brannen

Loved the patio and the brisket sandwich!

Sarah

Great food and service!

Charlie Lou

Food was fresh and crispy, staff was very accommodating, and restaurant was clean and ready. Quick refills and condiments were served. Hardworking staff.

Jillian Lutz

Exceeded expectations

Romeo Bazinet

This place is so goood 👍👍👍👍👍

David Lutz

Place is great!

Tech deck Version

I love it it’s daddy meal

Shawn Beaver

Came in between baseball games, service was prompt and food came out fast and quick.

Autumn Escoe

Stopped at the Rusty Bison after checking in our son At Dreams village and it was a great choice! Quick in with no wait even being close to the park, and the homemade bbq sauce on their brisket sandwhich was sooo good! The service was great with quick drinks and food, and very friendly attentive workers!

Titan

Great food and service!

Brian Larimer

The staff is fairly rude. They say that families are welcome but they don’t have a children’s menu. They had a whole dining room open but said we had to split our group between a high top and a low top. Half of the televisions don’t work. We were here at 12:30 and were told they don’t have ribs yet because it’s too early in the morning. That’s tough for a BBQ restaurant. You can’t customize meals even for an up charge. There are too many options in Cooperstown to visit this place.

Gage Smith

I don't eat somewhere they don't keep the facilities clean. As much care as they put in to that restroom being clean, they will put half that into the kitchen being clean. Food tasted blah, service was slow to get to anything. Which was odd because no one was there except three tables of people. Which was even more odd for a Saturday at 6:30pm. Point is, this place sucks and Cooperstown deserves better....

Linda Watkins

Over priced steak. $36 for a chewy piece of no flavored steak. Waitress never checked back to see how our meals were. Never go back!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 2

amanda H

don't get wine here 14 bucks for one quarter glass got mozz for 10.99 for 6 food was great though

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Dutchman Outdoors

I have no idea how people are giving this place good reviews. I had the 1/4 ribs which were honestly top 3 worst ribs ever. The McDonald’s McRib scores higher than what I got here. They were tough and tasteless, the fat was hard a grizzly. No grill marks on them and slathered in the cheapest “bbq” sauce.

My son had the brisket sandwich which was dripping grease. The meat was tender but entirely tasteless. Even the cheap “homemade bbq” sauce was awful!

My wife’s chicken was decent, she had no complaints. The bathroom floors were sticky and the men’s room smelled like a dirty diaper. The water from the faucet had such a strong sulfur smell I nearly gagged
 no paper towels to dry and the blower didn’t work.

The only good thing about this visit was the waitress was pleasant and on her game with drink refills.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 5

Loading...