Got the Otsego Latte summer special, I'm not a coffee gal whatsoever but this blew me out of the water
Danielle Albini
We went here every morning while staying in Cooperstown. The BEST variety for breakfast sandwiches. We tried the Lox, the pastrami, the veggie burrito, the bagel with sausage and the croissant with bacon! Can’t go wrong!!
Lonnie Etter
Seems to be no rhyme or reason to how orders come out. Vanilla bean cupcake was dry as a bone. Orders not coming out in order of placed order. Had to chase down the cupcake.
Zená Feagin
Get the tuna salad!!
Michael Alarcon
What a great cafe! The owner Chris is outstanding. His positive vibe and energy permeates to the staff. Coffee is roasted on site and tastes great! Must stop visit while in Cooperstown for great coffee!
Naomi Rizzio
The perfect neighborhood coffee shop post church! Delicious coffees (and matcha!) such friendly staff, cute indoor outdoor seating in adorable historic Coopersville!
Lezley Humphrey
The coffee is wonderful with lots of options, including seasonal offerings. Plentiful selection of breakfast sweets and sandwiches. The egg and cheese on everything bagel was delicious- the bagel itself isn't 'heavy', it's actually quite light and very flavorful!
Sam Spence
It was pretty busy but lots of seating indoor and out. I got a smoothie, coffee, and butter croissant. All were very good.
Ben Eduardo
Love this place, absolute gem. So many options for food and drinks, quality service as well.
Waited almost an hour for an egg and cheese breakfast sandwich. I ordered to go thinking it would be a quick stop on our way out of town. As a half hour approached and I noticed everyone else around me in line had gotten their food I asked a staff member if she could watch for my food to come out as I had to refill my parking meter, she checked and said nothing was ready yet. I refilled the parking meter another half hour. Waited another 15 minutes to ask a different staff member and she checked and the sandwich had been there the whole time. Threw it across the counter with a flat “sorry”. At this point it was cold and soggy. Got back over an hour later with a cold breakfast sandwich in hand. I understand rushes happen and things get missed but some sense of customer service when someone who ordered to go has waited for an hour would have been appreciated. Not worth the $14. Went there for lunch a day earlier and the wait was over a half hour to go. If you’re on a time sensitive schedule, it’s not a quick stop.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
Catch 22
Stagecoach Coffee is an extremely popular place to visit when visiting downtown Cooperstown NY. Known for it's fresh brewed coffee and baked delights, this is a great place to come to get a boost before the miles of hiking around the Baseball Hall of Fame. The Baristas are really friendly and energetic and the dining areas stay pretty clean with a revolving pattern of human movement as people come and go. The usual amount of time people visit is 30 minutes and it can become very crowded during peak times each season. The prices are pretty decent, especially with it being located in a tourist trap, so it will make you feel pretty good knowing that you didn't have to go broke before you go broke.? I have been here several times in the last ten years and I've never had a bad experience and I've always enjoyed the coffee and croissants. ? ? ? ?
Parking: Hard to find parking when it's the busy season but not impossible
Kid-friendliness: Kids will love the drinks and baked goods and there are plenty of non caffeine related products for kids.
Recommended dishes: Bagel with Cream Cheese, White Chocolate, Iced Caramel Macchiato, Coffee Cake, House Panini
Bryar Welton
Everybody is super kind! They have outdoor seating the back. Their food options and beverages are fantastic. It was wonderful to get a healthy breakfast option and sit outside. When I ordered coffee beans, they gave me dark roast by accident but they're still good. I love their medium roast.
Vegetarian options: There are clear options but not an excess
Parking: Free, paid, and times parking within walking distance
Kid-friendliness: Definitely kid friendly food with kid beverages as well
Wheelchair accessibility: The back seated area and inside could definitely be wheelchair accessible
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Bagel with Cream Cheese, Smoked Salmon
pamela schepis
I stop here whenever I’m visiting Cooperstown and I love both the ambience and goods for sale. That said, the iced coffee isn’t my fave. It’s not bad but I prefer my local coffee shop. Just a personal preference. Servers are lovely
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Alex
Weak cold brew, breakfast sandwich took an eternity and was just so-so
Got the Otsego Latte summer special, I'm not a coffee gal whatsoever but this blew me out of the water
We went here every morning while staying in Cooperstown. The BEST variety for breakfast sandwiches. We tried the Lox, the pastrami, the veggie burrito, the bagel with sausage and the croissant with bacon! Can’t go wrong!!
Seems to be no rhyme or reason to how orders come out. Vanilla bean cupcake was dry as a bone. Orders not coming out in order of placed order. Had to chase down the cupcake.
Get the tuna salad!!
What a great cafe! The owner Chris is outstanding. His positive vibe and energy permeates to the staff. Coffee is roasted on site and tastes great! Must stop visit while in Cooperstown for great coffee!
The perfect neighborhood coffee shop post church! Delicious coffees (and matcha!) such friendly staff, cute indoor outdoor seating in adorable historic Coopersville!
The coffee is wonderful with lots of options, including seasonal offerings.
Plentiful selection of breakfast sweets and sandwiches. The egg and cheese on everything bagel was delicious- the bagel itself isn't 'heavy', it's actually quite light and very flavorful!
It was pretty busy but lots of seating indoor and out. I got a smoothie, coffee, and butter croissant. All were very good.
Love this place, absolute gem. So many options for food and drinks, quality service as well.
Always a good stop for coffee and quick bite!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Waited almost an hour for an egg and cheese breakfast sandwich. I ordered to go thinking it would be a quick stop on our way out of town. As a half hour approached and I noticed everyone else around me in line had gotten their food I asked a staff member if she could watch for my food to come out as I had to refill my parking meter, she checked and said nothing was ready yet. I refilled the parking meter another half hour. Waited another 15 minutes to ask a different staff member and she checked and the sandwich had been there the whole time. Threw it across the counter with a flat “sorry”. At this point it was cold and soggy. Got back over an hour later with a cold breakfast sandwich in hand. I understand rushes happen and things get missed but some sense of customer service when someone who ordered to go has waited for an hour would have been appreciated. Not worth the $14. Went there for lunch a day earlier and the wait was over a half hour to go. If you’re on a time sensitive schedule, it’s not a quick stop.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
Stagecoach Coffee is an extremely popular place to visit when visiting downtown Cooperstown NY. Known for it's fresh brewed coffee and baked delights, this is a great place to come to get a boost before the miles of hiking around the Baseball Hall of Fame. The Baristas are really friendly and energetic and the dining areas stay pretty clean with a revolving pattern of human movement as people come and go. The usual amount of time people visit is 30 minutes and it can become very crowded during peak times each season. The prices are pretty decent, especially with it being located in a tourist trap, so it will make you feel pretty good knowing that you didn't have to go broke before you go broke.? I have been here several times in the last ten years and I've never had a bad experience and I've always enjoyed the coffee and croissants. ? ? ? ?
Parking: Hard to find parking when it's the busy season but not impossible
Kid-friendliness: Kids will love the drinks and baked goods and there are plenty of non caffeine related products for kids.
Recommended dishes: Bagel with Cream Cheese, White Chocolate, Iced Caramel Macchiato, Coffee Cake, House Panini
Everybody is super kind! They have outdoor seating the back. Their food options and beverages are fantastic. It was wonderful to get a healthy breakfast option and sit outside. When I ordered coffee beans, they gave me dark roast by accident but they're still good. I love their medium roast.
Vegetarian options: There are clear options but not an excess
Parking: Free, paid, and times parking within walking distance
Kid-friendliness: Definitely kid friendly food with kid beverages as well
Wheelchair accessibility: The back seated area and inside could definitely be wheelchair accessible
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Bagel with Cream Cheese, Smoked Salmon
I stop here whenever I’m visiting Cooperstown and I love both the ambience and goods for sale. That said, the iced coffee isn’t my fave. It’s not bad but I prefer my local coffee shop. Just a personal preference. Servers are lovely
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Weak cold brew, breakfast sandwich took an eternity and was just so-so
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Loading...