Loved this pizza. I’m from out of town and after a long day of driving we tried Rico’s pizza. Love the fresh ingredients and the heaping amounts. Highly recommend!
Josh b
Cooked a sheet pizza in soap we took it back and they made us a new one that didn’t taste like soap.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Malcolm Harrow
We had takeout. Really nice service, took an interest in us and why we were in Corning. Salad was very fresh.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sara Nissen
The chicken wings were outstanding. We ordered the Buffalo medium.
I was on a quest to find pizza (that wasn't frozen) to out pizza the hut as soon as I saw the pizza I knew it out pizza the hut, the garlic knots are also really I do recommend ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Scott Davis
Very nice restaurant very clean, excellent food, love the pepperoni pizza, and the garlic knots are heavenly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Garlic Knots
Edmund Brush
Amazing pizza for a great price, tastes just like it's from the city and the service is extremely nice, place is well decorated too it's very cozy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Corey V
Best pizza I've had in a very long time, and they don't skimp on the toppings.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Ira Farfel
Loved the food! Everything tasted so good.The pizza was especially amazing! The workers were also very nice! An overall 5 stars.
Pizza is ok, customer service is severely lacking. We are visiting family, from Colorado, I didn't know that customer service in New York was this bad.
Food: 2
Service: 1
Vonny W.
A quick stop in Corning meant we were in need for a quick bite to eat. Because we had yet to have any New York style pizza on this trip, I recommended we hit one up for our last meal while in New York. Sure, there are a lot of spots that come up when you do a Google search but Rico's Pizza looked the most promising out of the area we were in.
We walked in around 3 pm on a Friday. There was only a table of two seated near the window but the place was otherwise empty. Later, two other single parties came in during our stay. As soon as we walked up to the register, we were greeted and offered for them to take our order. Being our first time, we requested some time with their menu. We had a couple questions along the way, and the gentleman was very helpful.
We ended up having our eyes set on their "2 specialty slices and a large drink" combos for just over $10. Ordering two of these ended up being a really good amount of food for the four of us. We tried the following slices (ordered from my most to least favorite): - PULLED PORK BBQ: I was honestly surprised to learn that this ended up being my favorite. There's a good amount of pulled pork present but not enough to make you feel drowned in meat and heavy. I liked that the BBQ flavor was smoky and present, yet somehow, the cheese flavor was so strong. - BACON CHEESEBURGER PIZZA: They really did not skimp on the cheese for this one as it was oozing all over the slice! This was a good rendition of a cheeseburger as a slice. - THE PAGLIACCI: This was essentially a supreme pizza. More of a classic but tasty and had a good amount of toppings on it. - STUFFED PIZZA: We were misled by the name and thought it might be a stuff crust pizza since they already had calzones as a different part of their menu, but this was basically a calzone. The crust/dough was very well made and had a nice chew to it, but there was way too much dough to filling ratio. The filling was also just sauce and cheese, no toppings.
My first impression was the crunch from the under carriage! The slice held together really well without being floppy due to the nice crisp and toast to the crust. I also loved that everything came out fresh and hot! These were not pre-made slices, but instead, made to order.
On another note, the pizza wasn't too salty and I did not feel excessively thirsty after.
Since this place isn't a "sit and be served" type joint, tips aren't really needed but with the service we received, we felt they really did deserve one! When our slices were ready, the staff came to bring out our slices which we did not expect and when we asked for them to be cut, they came to our table with a cutter versus asking us to bring back the slicing.
They also have single stall washrooms for both men and women. They're small but recently clean (and bonus, for having paper towels).
As for parking, there was an ample amount of free parking spaces on the street nearby.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Joseph LoCascio
Just happened to wander in during our race week at Watkins Glen. Definitely making Rico's a must visit anytime we are in town from now on. Great atmosphere, typically cozy without dmfeeling cramped. A great selection of freshly made pies as well as an assortment of sandwiches. We had the good fortune of being served by Hannah. She is amazing and a true artisan in the kitchen. Not only did she work the front of the house but she made our pizzas as well. Great attitude and patience with the 6 of us. Fresh pizza takes time so if you're in a rush, maybe not the place to eat. But if you want fresh, made to order, pizza and sandwiches, this is the spot.
Loved this pizza. I’m from out of town and after a long day of driving we tried Rico’s pizza. Love the fresh ingredients and the heaping amounts. Highly recommend!
Cooked a sheet pizza in soap we took it back and they made us a new one that didn’t taste like soap.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
We had takeout. Really nice service, took an interest in us and why we were in Corning. Salad was very fresh.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The chicken wings were outstanding. We ordered the Buffalo medium.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings
Really good pizza, wings, and service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Cheese Steak Pizza, Chicken Wings
I was on a quest to find pizza (that wasn't frozen) to out pizza the hut as soon as I saw the pizza I knew it out pizza the hut, the garlic knots are also really I do recommend ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Very nice restaurant very clean, excellent food, love the pepperoni pizza, and the garlic knots are heavenly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Garlic Knots
Amazing pizza for a great price, tastes just like it's from the city and the service is extremely nice, place is well decorated too it's very cozy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza I've had in a very long time, and they don't skimp on the toppings.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Loved the food! Everything tasted so good.The pizza was especially amazing! The workers were also very nice! An overall 5 stars.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Not sure when Half Pepperoni Half Cheese on a large pizza means you only get three slices of pepperoni.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Outstanding pizza and wings!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Chicken Wings
Pizza is ok, customer service is severely lacking. We are visiting family, from Colorado, I didn't know that customer service in New York was this bad.
Food: 2
Service: 1
A quick stop in Corning meant we were in need for a quick bite to eat. Because we had yet to have any New York style pizza on this trip, I recommended we hit one up for our last meal while in New York. Sure, there are a lot of spots that come up when you do a Google search but Rico's Pizza looked the most promising out of the area we were in.
We walked in around 3 pm on a Friday. There was only a table of two seated near the window but the place was otherwise empty. Later, two other single parties came in during our stay. As soon as we walked up to the register, we were greeted and offered for them to take our order. Being our first time, we requested some time with their menu. We had a couple questions along the way, and the gentleman was very helpful.
We ended up having our eyes set on their "2 specialty slices and a large drink" combos for just over $10. Ordering two of these ended up being a really good amount of food for the four of us. We tried the following slices (ordered from my most to least favorite):
- PULLED PORK BBQ: I was honestly surprised to learn that this ended up being my favorite. There's a good amount of pulled pork present but not enough to make you feel drowned in meat and heavy. I liked that the BBQ flavor was smoky and present, yet somehow, the cheese flavor was so strong.
- BACON CHEESEBURGER PIZZA: They really did not skimp on the cheese for this one as it was oozing all over the slice! This was a good rendition of a cheeseburger as a slice.
- THE PAGLIACCI: This was essentially a supreme pizza. More of a classic but tasty and had a good amount of toppings on it.
- STUFFED PIZZA: We were misled by the name and thought it might be a stuff crust pizza since they already had calzones as a different part of their menu, but this was basically a calzone. The crust/dough was very well made and had a nice chew to it, but there was way too much dough to filling ratio. The filling was also just sauce and cheese, no toppings.
My first impression was the crunch from the under carriage! The slice held together really well without being floppy due to the nice crisp and toast to the crust. I also loved that everything came out fresh and hot! These were not pre-made slices, but instead, made to order.
On another note, the pizza wasn't too salty and I did not feel excessively thirsty after.
Since this place isn't a "sit and be served" type joint, tips aren't really needed but with the service we received, we felt they really did deserve one! When our slices were ready, the staff came to bring out our slices which we did not expect and when we asked for them to be cut, they came to our table with a cutter versus asking us to bring back the slicing.
They also have single stall washrooms for both men and women. They're small but recently clean (and bonus, for having paper towels).
As for parking, there was an ample amount of free parking spaces on the street nearby.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Just happened to wander in during our race week at Watkins Glen. Definitely making Rico's a must visit anytime we are in town from now on. Great atmosphere, typically cozy without dmfeeling cramped. A great selection of freshly made pies as well as an assortment of sandwiches. We had the good fortune of being served by Hannah. She is amazing and a true artisan in the kitchen. Not only did she work the front of the house but she made our pizzas as well. Great attitude and patience with the 6 of us. Fresh pizza takes time so if you're in a rush, maybe not the place to eat. But if you want fresh, made to order, pizza and sandwiches, this is the spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...