Cornwall Sweets

297 Main St, Cornwall
(845) 372-2822

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jessica McGowan

2 for 2 for bad experiences. I went here durning the summer and got a slice of cheesecake, got it home and there was mold on the bottom. I called and the guy who answered the phone made it seem like I inconvenienced him. Then I gave another try 2 days ago my husband got the driest cake possible he had to dip it in milk to even tolerate it, even the cupcakes were so dry and tasted like they were sitting there for a while. Be careful about what you buy, you don’t know how long it’s been sitting on the self seems like others have this issue too I see it in the reviews.

VINCENT ROY

This is the best sweet shop and has the best treats mostly ice cream and the cakes but definitely the best place ever

Eric Chatfield

Small place but they do custom orders have a few shelves of assorted candy and probably 12ish ice cream flavors. Been a few times with the little for a sweet treat. Worth a stop.

Madison Cattaneo

I absolutely love this place and go get ice cream there a lot. There is a worker there and her name is Maureen and she is very, very, very, nice and helpful. I think you guys should give her a promotion/raise. Overall, I really, really, really, recommend this place and I will, of course, be returning.

James Michael

The cake bombs tasted like it was a week old.
Everything i had was stale and hard.
Sorry but not returning again.

Emmy a

Love this little cozy place! The Ice cream
Is fantastic!

Zach E.

Yummy ice cream and a friendly staff! We all got different flavors / topping combos but have to say the mint chip was the best.

M M

Update: I can’t respond to the owner so I have to place an update. I have included a picture description of what is says on the website for the brownie which is why I expected it warm but further than that the brownie was almost non existent… it was ice cream w brownie crumbs… as for the cupcake I did not receive a call/text/ or even voicemail regarding it and we don’t like filling so it was not eaten… a plain vanilla cupcake is all we wanted and that’s what was shown on the website. Thanks for responding though… just giving an honest review and will update if we try again.

Ordered a plain vanilla cupcake with vanilla frosting got a vanilla cupcake with filling and it looks nothing like the picture and has crumbs and weird cream that’s looks like a spider web on top… also ordered a brownie Sundae and I got pretty much a bunch of ice cream with brownie bits a cherry and hot fudge….it was supposed to be a warm brownie with ice cream on it …. I got ice cream with a few brownie bits Here are the pics … just wish I got what I ordered…

Bianka Koka Stuit

Stopped by late on a Friday night when nothing else seemed to be open. Sure, I went because it was open til 9:30 but this place ended up being soooo much better than just a random sweet fix! Their salted caramel cake and Boston Cream bomb are so so good! The cake especially, it was exceptional. The girl behind the counter was also super nice and helpful. Best dessert spot in the area!

Eduardo Perez-Tobon

I'm all about supporting local businesses so I brought a big group of friends and family for hot cocoa and ice cream to walk around downtown. While the cones were ok, the hot chocolate was one of the worst we've ever had... the milk heated in a busted microwave, do I have to say more? I can't recommend this place to anyone.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Shelby Veazey

Omg just found this place randomly and it was such a delight. You walk in and smell the sweet smell of sugar. Grace was helpful and knew everything about the shop and the ingredients we got ice cream which was deliciousl. Thanks Grace!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Galway Girl

Stale mini pastry tasting like the old building that houses it ?Overpriced too!

Al Alberto

Nice little sweet shop from cupcakes to ice cream. Friendly staff and price is comparable to other places. Also serve tipsy shakes.n

Cynthia Lapham

Very lovely people and I enjoyed the ice cream! I will definitely becoming back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sparkle Mahn

Uber Eats sent me a message about Cornwall Sweets so I said "why not" and placed a small order. The pecan pie is outrageously good with a very well made crust. I never liked a single, gluten free item until I tried their mini-donuts! Also got the cane sugar sodas (Fanta, Sprite, Coke) I like. I will be ordering again from Cornwall Sweets.

Vegetarian options: They have no meat!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...