Cornwall Sweets
297 Main St, Cornwall
(845) 372-2822
Customers' Favorites
Classic Cupcake
Featured items
Blue Velvet Cupcake
Red Velvet Cupcake
Jumbo Chocolate Chip Cookie
Brownie
Cream Filled Churro
Chocolate Outrage Cake 7"
Cheesecake by the Slice
Cannoli Taco
Red Velvet Cake 7"
Cakes
Chocolate Outrage Cake 7"
Red Velvet Cake 7"
Blue Velvet
Red Velvet
Mousse Supreme
Cheesecake
Strawberry Shortcake 7"
Chip Chocolate Cake 7"
NY Cheesecake 7"
Yiang Yang Cake 7"
Coconut Snowball Cake 7"
Napolean Cake 7"
Cannoli Cake 7"
Cookie Dough Cake 7"
Chocolate Truffle cake serves 12-18
Rocky Road Cake 7"
Oreo Cookies & Cream Cake 7"
Carrot Cake 7"
Apple Berry Crisp Cake
Great alternative to traditional apple pie. This cake is filled with luscious berries and apples. Guaranteed to bring a tasteful twist to any dessert table.
Pies by Carousel
Key Lime
Pecan Pie
Pumpkin Cheese Pie
Seasonal, absolutely delicious blend of flavors that only compliments a Pumpkin Pie.
Candy & Chocolate
1/2# Assorted Chocolate
1/2# Assorted Gummies
Mini Peanut Butter Cups (6)
creamy delicious peanut butter dipped in luscious milk chocolate
Chocolate Dipped Pretzel with M & M's
1/2# Sour Patch Kids
Chocolate Dipped Strawberries (6)
White Chocolate Dipped Pretzel with Nonpareils
1/2# Assorted SUGAR FREE Chocolates
Chocolate Dipped Pretzel with Snickers
Dipped Pretzel Rods 2 Pack
1/2# Gum Drops
1/2# Assorted Jelly Beans
1/2# Jelly Belly AUTUMN Mix Jelly Beans
Seasonal blend of fall flavors- scrumptious and delicious!
Gluten Free
Chocolate Dipped Strawberries (6)
Glazed Mini Donuts (5)
Small batch and scrumptious GF Donuts.5 per order.
Cupcake by Carousel
Zoe's Crush GF Cookie
Balance of sweet and savory! Delicious and satisfyingly!
Rice Cakes by Sweet Street
Chocolate Truffle cake serves 12-18
Individual Cakes & Pastry
Meltaway Slice Dessert Bar
Cannoli (3)
Scrumptious filled to order mini Cannoli- lightly dusted with powdered sugar
Cheesecake by the Slice
Granny Apple Carmel Cake Slice
Scrumptious cross between apple crisp and apple pie drizzled with caramel
Banana Cream Cake by the Slice
Banana Cream Pie in a cake! Scrumptious and delicious true Banana Cream flavor!
Pumpkin Spice Ind Cake
Seasonal- scrumptious blend of flavors make this individual sliced cake melt in your mouth- a true Pumpkin Lovers dream!
Salted Caramel Ind Cake
Perfect blend of Sea Salt and Caramel- delicious
Individual Chocolate Moulton Cake
Tiramisu Cake by the Slice
Tiramisu cake at its finest- smooth and creamy blend of flavors has made our list of favorites
Chocolate Chip Cream Cheese Ind Cake
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Chunks on top of cake with a layer of cream cheese.
Banana Loaf Slice 3.5oz
Cannoli (3)
Drinks
Coke Mexico
Smart Water Strawberry Raspberry blend
Yup Milk Strawberry
Tea
Fanta Orange Mexico
Sprite Mexico
Dr Pepper
Vitamin Water
Acai blueberry pomegranate.
Yup Milk Chocolate
Dr Pepper Mini
Diet Coke Mini
Smart Water Cucumber Lime Blend
Cookies, Cupcakes, Brownies & Churros
Cream Filled Churro
Red Velvet Cupcake
Brownie
Jumbo Chocolate Chip Cookie
Classic Cupcake
Blue Velvet Cupcake
Chocolate Dipped Oreo Cookies (6)
Cheesecake by the Slice
Peanut Butter Cookie
1/2 Dozen Assorted Cupcakes
Chocolate Dipped Nutter Butter Cookies (6)
Cannoli Taco
Cookie Dough Taco
1/2 Assorted Butter Cookies
Janes Ice Cream
Pint Size
Required - Choose a minimum of 1 and a maximum of 2 flavors.
Banana Split by Cornwall Sweets
your choice of up to 3 flavors of ice cream with fresh sweet bananas, chocolate & strawberry syrup topped with m&m's, crushed oreos and 3 cherries. Upgrade to hot fudge instead of chocolate syrup.
Brownie Sundae
Delicious fudge brownie with your choice of 2 scoops of ice cream, whipped cream, Hersheys chocolate sauce and sprinkles.
Milkshake
Janes Ice Cream Vegan Pint
Delicious creamy Jane's Ice Cream- Oat base flavor of the month. Small batch- made in Kingston NY
Mercer's Ice Cream
Pint Size
Vegan
Janes Ice Cream Vegan Pint
Delicious creamy Jane's Ice Cream- Oat base flavor of the month. Small batch- made in Kingston NY
Photos
+51 photos
+50 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I absolutely love this place and go get ice cream there a lot. There is a worker there and her name is Maureen and she is very, very, very, nice and helpful. I think you guys should give her a promotion/raise. Overall, I really, really, really, recommend this place and I will, of course, be returning.
October 2025
Stopped by late on a Friday night when nothing else seemed to be open. Sure, I went because it was open til 9:30 but this place ended up being soooo much better than just a random sweet fix! Their salted caramel cake and Boston Cream bomb are so so good! The cake especially, it was exceptional. The girl behind the counter was also super nice and helpful. Best dessert spot in the area!
April 2025
Omg just found this place randomly and it was such a delight. You walk in and smell the sweet smell of sugar. Grace was helpful and knew everything about the shop and the ingredients we got ice cream which was deliciousl. Thanks Grace!
May 2024
You May Also Like
Kanda House thai kitchen - 304 Main St
![]()
Thai, Asian
Cornwall Coffee Co. & Mercantile - 310 Main St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee
The Farmhouse Food Truck - 277 Main St
![]()
Food Trucks, Caterers, Burgers