Leo's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria Cornwall

23 Quaker Ave, Cornwall
(845) 534-3446

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jadin Vega

Mannn, I ordered Leo’s the other night… BUSSIN! Flavor was great and I enjoyed the crust texture. Very good! Server was extremely kind when I came to pick up my Za (Short for Pizza, LOL!). Love Leo’s!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Keri Watts

Use to go here every Saturday night for years always a great, friendly place. Last night however the service was awful! Waitress acted lost and confused. Their manager was horrible and very unprofessional. Ordered a pizza it was under cooked, told them the issue and asked it be taken off the bill as we do not want another one. Manager brings another pizza anyway it was way over cooked this time and tried to make us pay for the pizza we never ate. After refusing she took it off the bill along with another dinner dish that was awful. It’s a shame how down hill this place has gone.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Lauren Watts

Last night my family and I tried to celebrate my aunt's 75th birthday .The waitress only took half of our tables drink orders. She barely came over to check on us. I had to go and ask for napkins and silverware. I went and grabbed straws myself.We had to repeatedly ask if we could place the rest of the drink orders. A random stranger ended up making me a drink behind the bar and it was not an employee. They sent out an undercooked pizza and we let them know not to make another one. They brought one out anyway and it was burnt. The fettuccine was awful the sauce tasted as if they took powder and mixed it with water. The supervisor was very rude and was questioning why the pasta wasn't good. She started an argument with my sister. She said Im one person I have only 2 hands and I don't work on this side. She said Im here to entertain you guys with a nasty attitude. The poor bus boy had no help so three of us helped him clear the table. The cake that was brought earlier that day was left in the freezer. When they brought it out it was cold as ice. The supervisor was fighting with us on takin off the pizza and pasta from the bill. Both items were not ate. I never will recommend this place to anyone. Just know if you come here get ready to get uncooked food,poor service and a nasty supervisor. Also you will probably have to serve yourself.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Pia Romy

Went here earlier today and the blonde with short hair who was having a dragged out conversation with other guests did not acknowledge our party handed us the menu after over 10 minutes and then took an extra allotment of time to even take our order( restaurant was not busy). Our party decided to leave and we straight up walked out. Customer service was terrible today, hopefully no one else has to experience this because this was our first and last time going ✌🏼

Robert Brady

Leo's has two dining rooms. Both are nice but our party of four had dinner in the more upscale room decorated with artwork. i had the salmon which was excellent, my wife had the mushroom ravioli. There are plenty of delectable, mouth watering dishes and hopefully something to appease any appetite. Great menu. I noticed the place does an amazing amount of takeout, at least on the Sunday evening we were there. I need to try the pizza. Highly recommended for good food, a pleasant dining experience and a good value

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Phyllis Dumond

Food was really good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

William Olsen

Good pizza and atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Mike D

1 rude cashier. Cares more about conversation with staff non business related than talking to ordering customer. 1 very nice cashier. Owner was also there just standing in the way of all traffic talking about marriage with some dude. This place is too comfortable with its business status that it will continue to fall short.

As for the food. It was tasty but horribly put together. Had to eat a hero with a fork because it crumbles as you grabbed it.

jennifersU6289CV

Amazing, humongous menu! We ordered online to pick up and eat at our B&B in Cornwall, NY. Husband enjoyed buffalo chicken pizza. My chicken Princepesa was delicious and lemony, with broccoli and potatoes. It also came with a salad AND garlic bread. It was so much food we had enough to take with us for a picnic lunch hiking Storm King Mountain the next day. Delish!

Shaakirah Contreras

My favorite pizza spot , such great food and super kind staff !!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Howard Buchman

How can you mess up a slice of pizza? The cheese was tasteless, and the sauce tasted spoiled. There was a good crisp to the slice, but it was not worth it.

Brian Wolfe

Lilly is the best. The wine and dine is the best deal around.

Maria Gimena

Food and service is excellent

Micah Judson

Good Italian food

ThomasG725

We invited 2 other couples to join us for dinner. Leo 's is not what it was a year ago. Very disappointed. We made reservations, table was not set up correctly, we had to request f 2 more settings, no knife to cut bread, appetizers served as the second course, appetizer plates never remove as main course was served, waiter and bus boy not trained, desserts served one by one so we could not have deserts all at the same time, ran of decafe coffee. Don't think we will be back anytime soon.

Loading...

Leo's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria Cornwall

23 Quaker Ave, Cornwall, NY 12518
(845) 534-3446