Always love coming here. It is a great place with terrific service and food. Definitely on my short list of local favorites.
Prima is also on Uber Eats.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mack Keene
Great pizza with some of the best table service I have had in years. Billy went above and beyond and made us feel welcome like family coming home.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Tony Moreno
Had the Chicken Breast, Roasted Peppers and Mootz Panini...very delish! Great Service 👍
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Richardson
I felt at home!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Antonio Cintron
Phoned in an order for pick up. Asked nicely PLEASE 🙏 don't burn the pie, because it happens VERY frequently. Not to my surprise burnt again wasn't even able to eat it. I have finally learned my lesson NEVER again.
Antonio C
I even called and asked for the Pizza to be light and repeated myself several times to please make the Pizza light and again.This is not the first time No the second no the third I have officially given up on this establishment
Peter Williams
excellent pizza, excellent atmosphere, cool vibes and great decor. Definitely has a traditional NY pizza join feel. The owner was very nice and was very hospitable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
13 Eagles PPG
Well, it’s a nice spot. Service is great. Pizza is really bad. Too much sauce, too much cheese, under cooked. I wish I didn’t buy 2 slices before trying one first. Really really bad. If you’re looking for NY style or New Haven style crisp pizza, don’t go here. Portions are large. Sauce was average in taste also the cheese. Just not cooked or prepped correctly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
THE SHADOW
Had a wonderful time with wifey and our husky. Ordered a Queen Margherita pie and a few cold ones on hot day. Vincent is a very nice waiter and made sure everything was ok. Thank you, we'll be back.
william wortmann
Cornwall staple of NY style pizza. I used to go here as a kid with my buddies, get a slice and play video games in the back. They took the games out, but it still has the same feel as back then. We enjoyed the white slice and Margherita, garlic knots and calzone. The place is family owned and very friendly/attentive service. They even deliver nationally, my wife has had it delivered to us in Oklahoma multiple times!
We had a pizza that was half cheese and half pepperoni. It was delicious. We also ordered garlic knots and fried calamari. Everything was wonderful and I highly recommend this place.
Mike Miller
Many choices of pizza by the slice combos as well as other items in a small, well-known local favorite. A must visit in the area.
Sketchy Pam
We stopped here for a couple of slices before going to the Stormking Art Center. Thin crust perfection. I had the margarita pizza - an awesome treat. You can get a pizza deliver anywhere by mail too. Go here.
Greg Lee
I MISS THIS PLACE SO MUCH BEING IN FLORIDA.
John Kolp
Superb as always. I have been going here since 1991 and Prima Pizza is a great local institution!!
Always love coming here. It is a great place with terrific service and food. Definitely on my short list of local favorites.
Prima is also on Uber Eats.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza with some of the best table service I have had in years. Billy went above and beyond and made us feel welcome like family coming home.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Had the Chicken Breast, Roasted Peppers and Mootz Panini...very delish! Great Service 👍
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I felt at home!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Phoned in an order for pick up. Asked nicely PLEASE 🙏 don't burn the pie, because it happens VERY frequently. Not to my surprise burnt again wasn't even able to eat it. I have finally learned my lesson NEVER again.
I even called and asked for the Pizza to be light and repeated myself several times to please make the Pizza light and again.This is not the first time No the second no the third I have officially given up on this establishment
excellent pizza, excellent atmosphere, cool vibes and great decor. Definitely has a traditional NY pizza join feel. The owner was very nice and was very hospitable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Well, it’s a nice spot. Service is great. Pizza is really bad. Too much sauce, too much cheese, under cooked. I wish I didn’t buy 2 slices before trying one first. Really really bad. If you’re looking for NY style or New Haven style crisp pizza, don’t go here. Portions are large. Sauce was average in taste also the cheese. Just not cooked or prepped correctly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Had a wonderful time with wifey and our husky. Ordered a Queen Margherita pie and a few cold ones on hot day. Vincent is a very nice waiter and made sure everything was ok. Thank you, we'll be back.
Cornwall staple of NY style pizza. I used to go here as a kid with my buddies, get a slice and play video games in the back. They took the games out, but it still has the same feel as back then. We enjoyed the white slice and Margherita, garlic knots and calzone. The place is family owned and very friendly/attentive service. They even deliver nationally, my wife has had it delivered to us in Oklahoma multiple times!
Restaurantji Recommends
We had a pizza that was half cheese and half pepperoni. It was delicious. We also ordered garlic knots and fried calamari. Everything was wonderful and I highly recommend this place.
Many choices of pizza by the slice combos as well as other items in a small, well-known local favorite. A must visit in the area.
We stopped here for a couple of slices before going to the Stormking Art Center. Thin crust perfection. I had the margarita pizza - an awesome treat. You can get a pizza deliver anywhere by mail too. Go here.
I MISS THIS PLACE SO MUCH BEING IN FLORIDA.
Superb as always. I have been going here since 1991 and Prima Pizza is a great local institution!!
Loading...