Community Restaurant

10 Main St, Cortland
(607) 756-5441

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Dave Grusenmeyer

Food was very good. Service was outstanding. Layout typical of older downtown restaurants with a bar, tables, and booths. There's lots of space between tables so back room area is great for conversation.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joan Stuart

The food was really good and it wasn't so noisy that you couldn't talk - the waitress was very friendly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tee B

I had the Mozzarella Appetizer and OMG - SO DELISH
For dinner I ordered the Eggplant/Chicken Parmesan w/ Angel Hair - YES IT WAS SO GOOD.
The little squares of Ficcoca Bread with that dipping oil. Umm yes please!!
My friend and I sat at the bar to eat and Frank the bartender was awesome. Very personable and very much attentive to detail.
The atmosphere here is very nice. The ambience is that of fine dining and the food doesn't disappoint.
Note - this was my first time at this restaurant and I will most definitely be returning again and again.
Top notch for Cortland on my list!! 😁😁

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rebeca D. Caceres

I ordered the lamb rib chops in Greek herbs served with Greek green beans and lemon roasted potatoes. It’s $36 dollars, so I ordered it med rare. It came well done and the green beans were undercooked. The ā€œroastedā€ potatoes were sour from the lemon and soggy. We had salads as starters and my husband had a NA beer. We visited Friday night. The place was a ghost town. The restaurant is beautiful, but the kitchen is a wreck. I would have gone to the BOH and given them a hand no problem. Glad we had a gift card! Will not be returning any time soon.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 3

John Trunnell

Rachel was great. Good food. Good service. Will be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dario Trunnell

Excellent food, ice cold beer, and excellent service from Rachel. Thank you for a great meal!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

William OGorman

Another excellent meal. My usual go to is the crab stuffed Scroggins.

Tonight they offered a special Greek version with calamata olives and a very memorable Mediterranean flavor... not stuffed... but so, so good!

Always recommend the food, the atmosphere, and the people.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ann Mogavero

Had an amazing dinner here. The Greek food was some of the best we have ever had…apps all amazing, pork chop was phenomenal, staff was so welcoming and friendly. Definitely go eat here!

Alexis Riccardo

This was our first time here, and it was not what we expected from the street view. The inside is classy yet vintage. It's such a beautiful place inside. The food was absolutely delicious. Although there was no kids' menu, my son was able to create a meal for himself with falafel and lamb. We had the lamb gyro, and it did not disappoint. There was plenty of food and we left very full. The service was excellent. Our waiter was very attentive and friendly. He made light conversation without being awkward. We will definitely be returning. This place is a gem.

Danielle Joan

My husband and I went last night for dinner. It was absolutely phenomenal. The fish fry and french fries were perfection. The chicken Parm and clam chowder were delicious. Also, the wings were amazing. We truly enjoyed our meal. The waitress was lovely and super helpful in recommending menu items, since we've never eaten there before. We enjoyed our experience so much that we stopped by the bar for a drink before we left. The bartender was wonderful too. Thank you for an absolutely delicious meal and nice dining experience!

Jim Kelly

Enjoyed this restaurant. Staff was most helpful and the food was great. Enjoyed their hummus trio. Very good. The Steak was also cooked very well and seasoned great. Potato's were excellent. Will return.

Theresa St. John

Went here last night and was very pleased with my meal. I had a side Greek salad, homemade mozzarella sticks, and their specialty pork chop. There's also a photo here of their chicken Kabobs (came to the bar at the same time for another patron) and I enjoyed a blood orange margarita. YUMMMMM. I asked to see two of their bourbon bottles - the restaurant has a strong following of bourbon lovers. Staff was super friendly, Frank was an amazing bartender who made me feel very welcome. The bar area got busy quickly and he handled everyone without missing a beat. Would go again, for sure!

Michele Workman

I can't review the food as we never actually got to it the couple times we tried. 1st time we were asked if we had a reservation, we didn't and were told we wouldn't be able to get a table. This time, I made a reservation for my husband's birthday. Arrived at time of reservation, stood in the bar area and was ignored until we finally got the bartender's attention. Told him we had a reservation and he said "Go sit in a booth and someone will be there". We had no menus and it was 20 mins before anyone even acknowledged us. At that point we asked if we finally did place an order how long it would take for food and was told it "might" be 20-45mins. No thanks, we left and found someplace to eat. Looked like they had just 2 servers for the entire restaurant as they were running everywhere. Seriously under-staffed for the number of people they were trying to serve.

Jonathan Stern

We always enjoy a trip to Community. As one of Cortland's more upscale restaurants, it is a nice option for a date night or celebration, and the food is delicious. Whether ordering Greek or Italian dishes, it's hard to go wrong.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Taleem Khan Kalash

Very Greek

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...