ZERO STARS!!!! Condoning someone being killed for their political beliefs is insane! You guys should be ashamed to have people working there and owning a place with these beliefs!
Jaylynn
The atmosphere was good, small but very pleasant and comforting. The dish I had gotten wasn’t my favorite and maybe it was just the luck of the draw but I was expecting the lasagna to be hearty but it was dry and the meat was not flavorful at all, although the arch sauce was pleasant.Very disappointed in my dish! My husband on the other hand got the NY strip and man oh man was that good!! The garlic toast was a delight as well! We also got the limoncello mascarpone and it was delicious, bit on the sweater side but good!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
M D
Awesome food and Ms Erika provided great service. A gem if you are passing through. A century of history, including Satchmo.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Robin Antill
Step back in time in this hidden gem! Cocktails were amazing, dinner even more delicious! Service was perfection. Next time we are in town we will be back☺️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gavin O
Moved to cortland from downstate and my search for good Italian food stopped here I love the environment and have never been disappointed with the food, cocktails are also great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
James Williams
Probably one of Cortlands oldest restaurants. The history itself is worth the visit. The service and food are truly amazing. And if you go I highly suggest an Old-fashioned, they are by far the best I have had ever.
Barbie Briggs
Old school Italian restaurant. All the classics and large portions!
John S
Really great place. Very cool and original. Nice bar area and cool dining room. Great food and portions.
Jenette Mistretta
What an amazing little gem in Cortland! A step back in time to a true Italian restaurant. I felt like I was in the Bronx 50 years ago. Delicious food and drinks and don’t skip the cannolis!
Best Pork chop in NY !! Chef “Shanny” knows what she is cooking
Jody
First time visit. 100 bucks for 3 meals. Took 1 bite and instantly disliked it. The spaghetti and meatballs were so bad my kids wouldn't even eat it. They didnt even offer to take it off the bill. Just said would you like a to go box? Tried to give it to my dogs. They didn't eat it either. And when they tell you the meatballs are home made and delicious. Nope, same generic meatballs you find at papa johns, Hollywood in cortland and any other place. Sorry Green Arch but not impressed.
Alan M
You know that the chefs from here are going to heaven, because there is no way that this food isn’t in heaven! We tried here recently and it immediately became our favorite spot. I can’t believe I lived my life without this food in it! Very unassuming place, that seriously delivers classic, real Italian! You won’t regret it!
Samantha Townsend
I haven't been here in a while because they changed the owners. The food is pretty decent but it's still kind of pricey.
Natalie Cross
First visit here. My husband and I enjoyed the calamari appeltizer. The entrees lasagna and chicken parm. The service was excellent. The staff worked as a team with all the tables which was noticeable and shows a great team effort there. We would definitely recommend and come back again. Sorry no pictures this time. We were hungry😆.
Food sucked
Service sucked
Want be back
Food: 1
Service: 1
ZERO STARS!!!! Condoning someone being killed for their political beliefs is insane! You guys should be ashamed to have people working there and owning a place with these beliefs!
The atmosphere was good, small but very pleasant and comforting. The dish I had gotten wasn’t my favorite and maybe it was just the luck of the draw but I was expecting the lasagna to be hearty but it was dry and the meat was not flavorful at all, although the arch sauce was pleasant.Very disappointed in my dish! My husband on the other hand got the NY strip and man oh man was that good!! The garlic toast was a delight as well! We also got the limoncello mascarpone and it was delicious, bit on the sweater side but good!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Awesome food and Ms Erika provided great service. A gem if you are passing through. A century of history, including Satchmo.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Step back in time in this hidden gem! Cocktails were amazing, dinner even more delicious! Service was perfection. Next time we are in town we will be back☺️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Moved to cortland from downstate and my search for good Italian food stopped here I love the environment and have never been disappointed with the food, cocktails are also great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Probably one of Cortlands oldest restaurants. The history itself is worth the visit. The service and food are truly amazing. And if you go I highly suggest an Old-fashioned, they are by far the best I have had ever.
Old school Italian restaurant. All the classics and large portions!
Really great place. Very cool and original. Nice bar area and cool dining room. Great food and portions.
What an amazing little gem in Cortland! A step back in time to a true Italian restaurant. I felt like I was in the Bronx 50 years ago. Delicious food and drinks and don’t skip the cannolis!
Restaurantji Recommends
Best Pork chop in NY !! Chef “Shanny” knows what she is cooking
First time visit. 100 bucks for 3 meals. Took 1 bite and instantly disliked it. The spaghetti and meatballs were so bad my kids wouldn't even eat it. They didnt even offer to take it off the bill. Just said would you like a to go box? Tried to give it to my dogs. They didn't eat it either. And when they tell you the meatballs are home made and delicious. Nope, same generic meatballs you find at papa johns, Hollywood in cortland and any other place. Sorry Green Arch but not impressed.
You know that the chefs from here are going to heaven, because there is no way that this food isn’t in heaven! We tried here recently and it immediately became our favorite spot. I can’t believe I lived my life without this food in it! Very unassuming place, that seriously delivers classic, real Italian! You won’t regret it!
I haven't been here in a while because they changed the owners. The food is pretty decent but it's still kind of pricey.
First visit here. My husband and I enjoyed the calamari appeltizer. The entrees lasagna and chicken parm.
The service was excellent. The staff worked as a team with all the tables which was noticeable and shows a great team effort there. We would definitely recommend and come back again. Sorry no pictures this time. We were hungry😆.
Loading...