Pontillo's Pizzeria Cortland

So im giving 5 stars because I order from here AT LEAST once a week mainly more with my work schedule and its always been fantastic I mean I literally crave it tonight i waited at work for almost an hr and a half just for a pizza which is fine but it was 30 after tip my pizza wasnt even slightly warm and didnt have the extra sauce. Took a bite and it doesnt even taste luke it came from the same place im mega disappointed dude to the past experiences I may try again at some point but right now not a happy customer.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Was told 15 min when I walked in to order pizza and wings, but waited 45 and was told a couple times it would be right out. It was phenomenal, but didn't like that I had to wait so long.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

The food pricing was on par with the quality. It’s an overall very casual restaurant with enough standard pizzeria options to satisfy everyone. My only negative… the bathroom was extremely dirty.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

I’m from closer to the city and may have high expectations of pizza/italian food. I ordered a chicken parm sub. It was clearly a frozen chicken patty of some kind. You can always tell by that compacted gross texture. It tasted as if you bought some banquet frozen chicken patties, used ragu jar sauce and put it on a soft sub roll. I have never eaten chicken parm from a pizza place that didn’t make their own chicken cutlets. Unfortunately, I ended up throwing it away.

Food: 1

Pizza tasted good. However, I might not specifically order the pepperoni pizza again because the amount of grease makes it into a sloppy mess.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Long time customer, live an hour away now but always order when im going through cortland. Today i get home, looking forward to my spaghetti and meatballs, i soon as i open it up i smell burnt sauce and can see burnt meatballs, 4 dinners, all burnt and ruined, 70 bucks. I call the restaurant, they offer me a partial credit. Or, i can drive the hour all the way back there and they will remake it for me. You lost a customer forever.

Grew up coming here. It's a family staple. Sitting in the restaurant brought back great memories. Great family owned restaurant.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great food but web site completely wrong on prices!
Better triple the prices showen.

Everyone had something different and everything war wonderful.

Good pizza and cold beer. Chelsea was a good waitress.

We did not get what we ordered

Great place!

Pontillo's was welcoming of our large group and the food and service was fantastic! The manager and servers were great!

Nice place to dine in!