Held a pseudo-surprise dinner for a friend and the staff was very accommodating. The food was tasty and drinks were superb. You must order the Calamari Fritti because I am *still* dreaming about the basil aioli dipping sauce.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Eileen Gallagher
We travel from several towns away to eat here, it is that good! I very much appreciate being welcomed like old friends whenever we dine here, as well as the professional and friendly staff, delicious food, and my personal favorite, the chocolate martini! Freshly baked bread for the table, exquisite salads and appetizers followed by an array of entrees such as chicken fratelli (my favorite) or several seafood and pasta dishes. While there is usually a crowd, the acoustics are such that you can have a pleasant conversation at your table. There is a lovely seating area with floor to ceiling windows which feels like you are almost eating outdoors, as well as outdoor seating in season.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Darla H.
I had my Birthday Dinner there last Thursday!! and I was so amazed how clean it was first of all and then the Food was out of this world!!! Service was great also! The entire experience was wonderful!! Ambiance beautiful!! 5 Stars for this place and I will definitely be back soon!!
ThomasP
The food was delicious - the best Italian restaurant in this area. The portions were just right - not overwhelming, but were plenty enough. The service is always top rate. Fratelli's could easily compete with some of the better restaurants in New York City.
Anthony CIOPPA
We were a party of 9. Everyone loved their meal. Desserts were great. Very attentive service. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pollo Alla Parmigiana, Roasted Potatoes, Eggplant Rollatini, Eggplant Parmesan, Cheese Cake, Ragatoni Alla Bolognese Pasta
LaurenA
Neighborhood gem, decorated so nicely for the holidays. Nice place for a family occasion or a romantic dinner for two. Excellent service and food. My only complaint is that like so many old-school Italian restaurants in the US, too much garlic. Next time, I'll just ask for no garlic. We will be back.
Nikki
Very impressed with our most recent meal at Fratelli's. The cocktails were great, and the food was delicious and well-executed. The eggplant rollatini appetizer was excellent, and we also got grilled oysters which were simple but delectable. I had a seafood special with clams, shrimp, and 1/2 baby lobster over homemade spinach tagliatelle with fresh tomato and white wine sauce... delicious, ate every bite, no notes. Lovely ambiance, great service... will return.
John L.
Food was fair, service below fair. Will not return. Had to return my food, something I've never done before. Was looking forward to a good meal with my friends.
nyfoodie
Overall great experience. We were a loud party of 9. My gf's birthday dinner. Everyone loved what they ordered. The owner and staff were accommodating every step of the way. Very impressed with the experience. Looking forward to going back.
Great service, great food. Atmosphere was very comfortable. Definitely recommend. We'll be back for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael DeGori
Food was Awsome a bit pricey. Service was good but the wait time for your food to table was longer then expected. I'd go back again..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Christie B
I think there's a new Chef here!!!!!Monthly meet up with friends in Croton, we come to Fratelli's often-but there is a change..... and it's defiently for the better....The food is OUTSTANDING!Stuffed mushrooms special for appetizer, Pistachio crusted Halibut special for entree.WOW!!How did I forget to take pictures?I was too busy eating!!!10 ? ? ? ? ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ducky
Fratelli's is a wonderful neighborhood place to go to. The food is very consistent and always flavorful and delicious. The attentive staff is very informative and friendly. They serve generous portions, even during restaurant week. The quality of the dishes are always consistent. There is a nice variety of beverages to choose from also.
KayJ
The food was disappointing. The Bolognese was not the usual. The sauce was too thick, salty, and the noodles were overcooked. The food tasted as if it had been prepared too far ahead of time and allowed to wait. The ambience was as usual, very pleasant, but the corner window was drafty.
Very good food awesome staff and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Held a pseudo-surprise dinner for a friend and the staff was very accommodating. The food was tasty and drinks were superb. You must order the Calamari Fritti because I am *still* dreaming about the basil aioli dipping sauce.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
We travel from several towns away to eat here, it is that good! I very much appreciate being welcomed like old friends whenever we dine here, as well as the professional and friendly staff, delicious food, and my personal favorite, the chocolate martini! Freshly baked bread for the table, exquisite salads and appetizers followed by an array of entrees such as chicken fratelli (my favorite) or several seafood and pasta dishes. While there is usually a crowd, the acoustics are such that you can have a pleasant conversation at your table. There is a lovely seating area with floor to ceiling windows which feels like you are almost eating outdoors, as well as outdoor seating in season.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I had my Birthday Dinner there last Thursday!! and I was so amazed how clean it was first of all and then the Food was out of this world!!! Service was great also! The entire experience was wonderful!! Ambiance beautiful!! 5 Stars for this place and I will definitely be back soon!!
The food was delicious - the best Italian restaurant in this area. The portions were just right - not overwhelming, but were plenty enough. The service is always top rate. Fratelli's could easily compete with some of the better restaurants in New York City.
We were a party of 9. Everyone loved their meal. Desserts were great. Very attentive service. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pollo Alla Parmigiana, Roasted Potatoes, Eggplant Rollatini, Eggplant Parmesan, Cheese Cake, Ragatoni Alla Bolognese Pasta
Neighborhood gem, decorated so nicely for the holidays. Nice place for a family occasion or a romantic dinner for two. Excellent service and food. My only complaint is that like so many old-school Italian restaurants in the US, too much garlic. Next time, I'll just ask for no garlic. We will be back.
Very impressed with our most recent meal at Fratelli's. The cocktails were great, and the food was delicious and well-executed. The eggplant rollatini appetizer was excellent, and we also got grilled oysters which were simple but delectable. I had a seafood special with clams, shrimp, and 1/2 baby lobster over homemade spinach tagliatelle with fresh tomato and white wine sauce... delicious, ate every bite, no notes. Lovely ambiance, great service... will return.
Food was fair, service below fair. Will not return. Had to return my food, something I've never done before. Was looking forward to a good meal with my friends.
Overall great experience. We were a loud party of 9. My gf's birthday dinner. Everyone loved what they ordered. The owner and staff were accommodating every step of the way. Very impressed with the experience. Looking forward to going back.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great service, great food. Atmosphere was very comfortable. Definitely recommend. We'll be back for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was Awsome a bit pricey. Service was good but the wait time for your food to table was longer then expected. I'd go back again..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
I think there's a new Chef here!!!!!Monthly meet up with friends in Croton, we come to Fratelli's often-but there is a change..... and it's defiently for the better....The food is OUTSTANDING!Stuffed mushrooms special for appetizer, Pistachio crusted Halibut special for entree.WOW!!How did I forget to take pictures?I was too busy eating!!!10 ? ? ? ? ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fratelli's is a wonderful neighborhood place to go to. The food is very consistent and always flavorful and delicious. The attentive staff is very informative and friendly. They serve generous portions, even during restaurant week. The quality of the dishes are always consistent. There is a nice variety of beverages to choose from also.
The food was disappointing. The Bolognese was not the usual. The sauce was too thick, salty, and the noodles were overcooked. The food tasted as if it had been prepared too far ahead of time and allowed to wait. The ambience was as usual, very pleasant, but the corner window was drafty.