Caffè Italia

1745 Deer Pk Ave, Deer Park
(631) 667-0201

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Deborah Seeger

One of the best hazelnut gelatos I have ever had

Michael A

Gelato to die for!!!

Nina k

If you have not tried this place yet - I say RUN there ! The Gelato is absolutely out of this world !!! My husband tried their pistachio , I have never tasted anything remotely as good. My decaffeinated Cappuccino was also very good . 5+++ rating on the Gelato !

Fatima

Each time I come here, there is a young female employee who gives me a nasty attitude or looks at me funny. This has happened several times with different employees. It seems they are racist and don't want to serve people of color. Don't bother coming here if you're brown or black. I definitely won't bother spending my money here anymore.

Carol Tatarynowicz

The best Gelato around, great flavor selection 👌

Julibie June

As a local I 100% recommend here the owner is very friendly and all products are fresh! I recommend their lobster tail one of my favorites!!❤️❤️

Sheri Fox

Probably one of the best if not the best gelato place on Long Island

Vito DeMola

This place was worth the drive. We’ve been looking for an authentic gelato spot on the island and after much experimentation, we’ve found it.

A good selection of all the important flavors, a great blend of traditional favorites and some of the new stuff.

Authentic, family owned spot with top notch gelato and espresso.

Will definitely be back to try more flavors soon!

Blows away any ice or ice cream spot in the area.

Elizabeth Lipski

The best gelato I have ever had! Tried the Dubai chocolate flavor and it was absolutely delicious.

Jill Berggren

Love this little place. The BEST lobster tails ever, gelato is fantastic too.

Mi O

The gelatto and coffee are delicious. The best dubai chocolate gelatto around.

Kaitlyn Asencio

Amazing gelato. I had mint and tiramisu and the flavor passed my expectations. Would DEFINITELY come again!

Ariah H

Amazing coffee and homemade gelato. They have seasonal flavors and a lot of italian goods. Family owned. Place is small, they have a couple of tables, gets busy saturday nights. I love this place !

Thomas Vinciguerra

The Gelato was very refreshing tastes great not too sweet at all just right. Had a slice of red velvet cake that the frosting also was perfect not sweet but fresh & cake was delicious! My sister in law lives in aérea promise me she will go there every time she thinks about lol I’m her favorite Brother in law. By the way lol

Valery Leo

Favorite cafe in town. Best gelato, great coffee, and delightful dessert.

Loading...