Rusty Nail Tavern Restaurant
Menu
Photos
Recent Reviews
Excellent!!!! We stopped in today for a late lunch early dinner. What a great place. The atmosphere the staff the food the decor everything was excellent. Our waitress was Excellent very friendly and attentive. This is what you want when you go out to eat to be taken care of and you want to feel like you’re welcome and they did that and they don’t even know us. We had a great time and felt very welcomed. We will definitely be back!! 💯 5 Stars+
We have been going to the Rusty Nail since it's (pre)opening. The food is wonderful, the staff super, the salads are great ... They Make The Dressings From Scratch!!! Green Goddess to Die For. Fish Fry is awesome, portions are generous across the board. The bar area has a nice happy hour too.
Super friendly place with a rustic country vibe. The decor is the perfect mix of farmhouse/pub/diner with a heavy emphasis on local sports, especially the Buffalo Bills. Exceedingly clean! Even the restroom. We ate at the bar. The food was delicious and the service was great. For my first time there, I was treated like a regular. We’ll be making the drive from Buffalo as often as we can. It’s THAT worth it.
You May Also Like
Coffee Crate - 1018 N Main St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee, Coffee & Tea
Scoops - 11634 NY-16
![]()
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream
Roadside Bar & Grill - 10924 NY-16
![]()
Bar & Grill