Sad to say I've been a customer for yearrrssssssss...... Poor customer service over the phone today when I called to let them know about how there was extra cheese on my order when I asked for none. And the hostess/order taker stated she clarified and wrote down lite cheese. Lite cheese is not NO CHEESE. To the point they call you back and put the owner on the phone..... What a hot mess this place is
Service: 1
Paul Pietrzak
Fast take out service and friendly employees. Excellent Fish Fry, Fries, side of Pasta, and other co-side items plus the Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken and Shrimp was excellent and two meals for meal which includes 2 pieces of bread and butter. Will come back again and recommended!
fire wire
Great little place in Depew amazing Italian food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristin Haines
The place is clean and bright and they were quite busy. They have some gluten free options which the waitress double checked to make sure they had the pasta. The staff is friendly although a bit slow. The drinks are very good and all in all I would say a very good experience. I wish that if they have gluten free options that they wouldnt have to check and make sure they had in........if you offer gluten free your should have plenty in stock. Just saying. I am glad they have it so I can eat there. Go and enjoy. The portions are big and everyone around us was raving abojt the food too.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Sara Elizabeth
I cannot stress enough how awful my experience at 57 Ninety was. This place is hands down one of the most disrespectful and deceptive establishments I’ve ever been to.
First off, the manager Kim was completely unprofessional. When I questioned the charges on my bill, she actually swore at me, saying “I don’t need your f*ing attitude.” I was shocked — what kind of manager thinks that’s acceptable customer service?
On top of that, they overcharged me and then added gratuity without clearly stating it. So I added gratuity on top of the 20% that was already charged. Absolutely dishonest.
Their advertising is misleading too. They claim they are always open for the 1pm and 4pm games, but then told me it was my responsibility to bring enough people or they wouldn’t open. How is that my problem when you’re publicly advertising otherwise?
Even their “specials” are a scam. Nowhere did they explain that the so-called $5 cocktails are only for wells, or that the $15 beer buckets are only for domestics. That’s false advertising and a complete bait-and-switch.
Overall, this business is rude, dishonest, and unprofessional. Between the manager’s profanity, the hidden charges, and the deceptive specials, I would never recommend 57 Ninety to anyone. Save yourself the money and the headache — there are plenty of places nearby that actually treat their customers with respect.
Cheryl Krygier
Went there for my father’s 84th Birthday , EVERYTHING was spot on , from our wonderful server , to our drinks , and incredible dinner !! wish We could give them 10 stars ❤️
Nikki Lyn (Lyn0208)
$17 for a tiny portion of pasta. What a rip off!! We’ll stick with Ilio’s.
Still Hopeful
Walking in recently for our first visit, they had a strong fall air freshener in the lobby. Passing into the dining room, I didn’t smell food cooking but the scent of mold/mildew hit my nose. We were seated towards the back where I didn’t notice it. The server was nice. A little rough around the edges but she was nice. She took our orders and the food was ready fairly quickly. The bread was stale and the oil on the table didn’t help. She didn’t come back too often to check on us. I had asked for extra napkins and my husband had to go find them himself. It didn’t look that busy, but it is what it is. I was disappointed when we were done because we wanted 2 separate checks as we were with other people. She had to take the receipt back to go split it up correctly. Then we realized the incredibly overpriced $15 cannoli our friends ordered was put on our bill. We reluctantly paid for it as we didn’t want to go through this all again. One of our meals was a bit overpriced for the small portion and my husband got quite the bout of heartburn that night from the pasta sauce. I’m not sure if I would return.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
James Westgate
Consistently impressed with my orders from here. Nice selection of dinners you can order online and be ready for pickup in 20 mins.
I ordered take out and was very pleased with my order. I got an eggplant Parmesan dinner and a large cheese and pepperoni pizza. The eggplant dinner was crispy and had layers of ricotta in between. The pizza was cooked to perfection! Highly recommend ordering take out or dinning in.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
andrew schlegel
Had a pizza as it was said to be reminiscent of an older pizzeria that doesn't exist anymore. It was close. But it was good nonetheless. The young girl that brought me my pizza was very friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sandra Brandl
Excellent pizza plenty of cheese , and the sauce is delicious, got there new sauce it’s great, love there specials on different nights
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
M. Klein
I recently visited 57 Ninety Restaurant, a spot we frequented previously but had also been curious about, since they opened and took over the space that was formerly La Costa Verde. Since they're celebrating their first anniversary, it felt like the perfect time to give them a try.
On this visit I went specifically for their Tuesday Pizza special and was happy I did. The pizza was so tasty, I'll absolutely get it again.
The menu has a lot of variety, so I'm already looking forward to my next visit to try some of their other dishes, perhaps for a sit-down meal. One thing I love is that they offer two different sauces: a sweet one reminiscent of the previous restaurant's sauce, and a more seasoned option.
The staff was wonderful, delightful and incredibly helpful. They made placing my order a seamless and efficient process. Inside, the restaurant has a much more modern and comfortable feel than before. Everything was very clean and organized, though I did notice a persistent, slightly off smell that was also present with the previous owners (so it may be building related).
For a local, non-chain meal, 57 Ninety is certainly worth checking out!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Megan Plevniak
I had a terrible experience during the anniversary event for 5790. It all started with the service or lack thereof. I never wrote bad reviews so this is very troubling. I was here with my partner on Thursday during the event and it was our first time at this restaurant. We had a really bad experience overall. We were excited to try this restaurant and celebrate with the anniversary with samples and prizes. When we first walked in and got seated it took 10 minutes for our waitress to greet us. She was older with blonde hair. She never told us about the specials or the samples and we feel that we missed out on this experience. My partner and I had to ask for the samples, a long with silverware and napkins. Our waitress did not check on us once after we received our food which is very strange. The food was okay, and the break arrived cold. I have never experienced this disappointment of service at any restaurant before. This was my first time here, but I am hesitant to return. I tried reaching out to the business chat on Facebook and it has been two weeks with no response. I decided to then call about my experience and asked politely for a manager. I spoke to a lady about my experience and I asked if there was any way we could reconcile this and as I was speaking, she hung up on me. I am baffled. Let's just say I will never return to this restaurant ever again.
THE PIZZA IS OUT OF THIS WORLD!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sad to say I've been a customer for yearrrssssssss...... Poor customer service over the phone today when I called to let them know about how there was extra cheese on my order when I asked for none. And the hostess/order taker stated she clarified and wrote down lite cheese.
Lite cheese is not NO CHEESE.
To the point they call you back and put the owner on the phone..... What a hot mess this place is
Service: 1
Fast take out service and friendly employees. Excellent Fish Fry, Fries, side of Pasta, and other co-side items plus the Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken and Shrimp was excellent and two meals for meal which includes 2 pieces of bread and butter. Will come back again and recommended!
Great little place in Depew amazing Italian food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The place is clean and bright and they were quite busy. They have some gluten free options which the waitress double checked to make sure they had the pasta. The staff is friendly although a bit slow. The drinks are very good and all in all I would say a very good experience. I wish that if they have gluten free options that they wouldnt have to check and make sure they had in........if you offer gluten free your should have plenty in stock. Just saying. I am glad they have it so I can eat there. Go and enjoy. The portions are big and everyone around us was raving abojt the food too.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
I cannot stress enough how awful my experience at 57 Ninety was. This place is hands down one of the most disrespectful and deceptive establishments I’ve ever been to. First off, the manager Kim was completely unprofessional. When I questioned the charges on my bill, she actually swore at me, saying “I don’t need your f*ing attitude.” I was shocked — what kind of manager thinks that’s acceptable customer service? On top of that, they overcharged me and then added gratuity without clearly stating it. So I added gratuity on top of the 20% that was already charged. Absolutely dishonest. Their advertising is misleading too. They claim they are always open for the 1pm and 4pm games, but then told me it was my responsibility to bring enough people or they wouldn’t open. How is that my problem when you’re publicly advertising otherwise? Even their “specials” are a scam. Nowhere did they explain that the so-called $5 cocktails are only for wells, or that the $15 beer buckets are only for domestics. That’s false advertising and a complete bait-and-switch. Overall, this business is rude, dishonest, and unprofessional. Between the manager’s profanity, the hidden charges, and the deceptive specials, I would never recommend 57 Ninety to anyone. Save yourself the money and the headache — there are plenty of places nearby that actually treat their customers with respect.
Went there for my father’s 84th Birthday , EVERYTHING was spot on , from our wonderful server , to our drinks , and incredible dinner !! wish We could give them 10 stars ❤️
$17 for a tiny portion of pasta. What a rip off!! We’ll stick with Ilio’s.
Walking in recently for our first visit, they had a strong fall air freshener in the lobby. Passing into the dining room, I didn’t smell food cooking but the scent of mold/mildew hit my nose. We were seated towards the back where I didn’t notice it. The server was nice. A little rough around the edges but she was nice. She took our orders and the food was ready fairly quickly. The bread was stale and the oil on the table didn’t help. She didn’t come back too often to check on us. I had asked for extra napkins and my husband had to go find them himself. It didn’t look that busy, but it is what it is. I was disappointed when we were done because we wanted 2 separate checks as we were with other people. She had to take the receipt back to go split it up correctly. Then we realized the incredibly overpriced $15 cannoli our friends ordered was put on our bill. We reluctantly paid for it as we didn’t want to go through this all again. One of our meals was a bit overpriced for the small portion and my husband got quite the bout of heartburn that night from the pasta sauce. I’m not sure if I would return.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Consistently impressed with my orders from here. Nice selection of dinners you can order online and be ready for pickup in 20 mins.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I ordered take out and was very pleased with my order. I got an eggplant Parmesan dinner and a large cheese and pepperoni pizza. The eggplant dinner was crispy and had layers of ricotta in between. The pizza was cooked to perfection! Highly recommend ordering take out or dinning in.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had a pizza as it was said to be reminiscent of an older pizzeria that doesn't exist anymore. It was close. But it was good nonetheless. The young girl that brought me my pizza was very friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent pizza plenty of cheese , and the sauce is delicious, got there new sauce it’s great, love there specials on different nights
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I recently visited 57 Ninety Restaurant, a spot we frequented previously but had also been curious about, since they opened and took over the space that was formerly La Costa Verde. Since they're celebrating their first anniversary, it felt like the perfect time to give them a try.
On this visit I went specifically for their Tuesday Pizza special and was happy I did. The pizza was so tasty, I'll absolutely get it again.
The menu has a lot of variety, so I'm already looking forward to my next visit to try some of their other dishes, perhaps for a sit-down meal.
One thing I love is that they offer two different sauces: a sweet one reminiscent of the previous restaurant's sauce, and a more seasoned option.
The staff was wonderful, delightful and incredibly helpful. They made placing my order a seamless and efficient process. Inside, the restaurant has a much more modern and comfortable feel than before. Everything was very clean and organized, though I did notice a persistent, slightly off smell that was also present with the previous owners (so it may be building related).
For a local, non-chain meal, 57 Ninety is certainly worth checking out!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
I had a terrible experience during the anniversary event for 5790. It all started with the service or lack thereof. I never wrote bad reviews so this is very troubling. I was here with my partner on Thursday during the event and it was our first time at this restaurant. We had a really bad experience overall. We were excited to try this restaurant and celebrate with the anniversary with samples and prizes. When we first walked in and got seated it took 10 minutes for our waitress to greet us. She was older with blonde hair. She never told us about the specials or the samples and we feel that we missed out on this experience. My partner and I had to ask for the samples, a long with silverware and napkins. Our waitress did not check on us once after we received our food which is very strange. The food was okay, and the break arrived cold. I have never experienced this disappointment of service at any restaurant before. This was my first time here, but I am hesitant to return. I tried reaching out to the business chat on Facebook and it has been two weeks with no response. I decided to then call about my experience and asked politely for a manager. I spoke to a lady about my experience and I asked if there was any way we could reconcile this and as I was speaking, she hung up on me. I am baffled. Let's just say I will never return to this restaurant ever again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Loading...