Lickety Split Ice Cream Shoppe

215 Water St, Dexter
(315) 804-8008

Recent Reviews

Eric Kelley

Parking: It Was Good.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Custard

John L.

Rather have Jodi's up the road I feel like you get better quality products and larger portions for much cheaper prices

Caitlin V.

Best ice cream around, hands down. It's custard, so it's extra thick and creamy. Peanut butter soft serve is really excellent, but their basic chocolate and vanilla is tasty as well. Really nice outdoor seating area by the water, take a short walk across the little foot bridge for an almost always empty pavilion, or the village dock with ample parking is just down the road for some different scenery. Service is always friendly and quick. The only thing I don't care for is their chocolate sprinkles. They're the hard crunchy ones that don't taste like chocolate. Not a dealbreaker since the ice cream is so good on its own, but a switch back to the better ones would be much appreciated. Regardless, this is the best ice cream you will find in the area and I will always bring visiting friends here over anywhere else.

Richard Haynes

We really like this place! Good variety of things to try, REALLY like the custard-style soft serve, and they have GENUINE Slush Puppies! A little pricey, but generally worth it!

Fake Name

Food was amazing but the person had a attitude and threw the ice cream at my face

Jordan Wilson

Awesome that they have non-dairy choices!

Mike May

I am impressed with the quality of the soft serve ice cream. The portions are very large,

Brittany Walker

Always love coming here! I bring my pup and my family and it's always delicious!

Kim Breneman

We visit this ice cream place whenever we are in Dexter. The Maine Blueberry is my favorite.

Kieran

Love the ice cream. Generous portions, and the staff are really nice. Five stars!

Stephanie Gates

The soft serve is really good! Did not love the flurry but that is just personal opinion. The location is great right next to lake/river. My husband thought the prices were high but I thought they were comparable to nearby locations.

Keila M

Peanut butter soft is the best of all!

Eddie

Staff is always great here. Big selection and great products. Always big portions.

Mark Gayne

Amazing ice cream, better than all the rest! Peanut Butter soft serve is the absolute best!

Keith Baxter

Great place for an ice cream, friendly staff, beautiful view of the Black River.

Load More

Lickety Split Ice Cream Shoppe

215 Water St, Dexter, NY 13634
(315) 804-8008