The Preston Barn

196 E Duncan Hill Rd, Dover Plains
(845) 442-3053

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jason Frazer

As a DJ, I play at numeros places. This was the first venue that brought me water without asking on a hot day. Then, Helene brought over some apps to ensure I ate despite working hard on a hot day. It says a lot when the staff takes care of vendors. I'd get marry here!

Lauren Testani

Rustic elegance. Attentive staff. Delicious food.

Lauren Gray

The Preston Barn at Old Drovers Inn had everything we wanted in a venue. If you want everything in one spot it is the perfect option. We, along with family and friends, stayed at the Old Drovers Inn, Carriage House, and Preston House (just 2 min down the road) and it was so special having everyone together for the whole weekend. Friday night we had a bonfire with smores and an open bar for all our wedding guests and were able to enjoy a leisurely brunch with the guests who stayed on property Sunday morning which was a great end to the weekend.

The venue also has a lot of historic charm and a rustic feel while also being very well kept up and accessible for older family members and guests with mobility challenges. The wedding weekend package also includes a lot of the services you need to run an event reducing the burden of having to coordinate with a lot of external vendors for basic things like tables, linens, catering, etc.

The real differentiator with Preston Barn is the staff. Helene was our coordinator for the day and was so incredibly helpful in the months leading up to the wedding and during the whole weekend. She went above and beyond by doing things like coming to check on me while I was getting my hair and makeup done to show me a picture of the welcome table and cheating chart display to make sure it looked like I had imagined it would. She was present during the first look and family photos and took "back up" photos as the photographer was shooting to make sure we had some images available to show family, friends, and coworkers in the days immediately following the wedding. The rest of the staff was also wonderful. The kindest gentleman was with us the whole afternoon while we were taking pictures before the ceremony and made sure we had water and were comfortable. I also learned afterwards that during the reception he offered to heat up one of my maids of honors meals for her as it had gotten cold while she was pulled in a 100 directions for various things. It was overall a wonderful experience and I would recommend Preston Bard to anyone looking for a venue that brings thoughtfulness, a personal touch, and great care into the whole experience.

Emily Finan

My husband Greg and I got married at this truly amazing venue this past November and we cannot emphasize how much we loved every aspect of the entire weekend; we're really hoping friends get married here so we can experience it all over again as guests!

From our very first meeting with Helene, we felt we were in great hands. She walked us through every step of the overwhelming process and made everything so totally seamless. It was like talking to a family member from the start. She made everyone feel so comfortable and at ease throughout the whole weekend--even looking after our flower girl and holding her up to the barn window to see guests start arriving while we were all hidden away pre-ceremony!

Between the amazing staff who helped us throughout the whole weekend, and the truly one of a kind venue, we had the absolute best possible wedding we could have ever hoped for! It was so special to stay onsite at this historic inn throughout the entire weekend with our friends and family. Everyone is still raving about the incredible quality of the brunches included and the kind innkeeper Jeff who waited on us hand and foot and made us all feel so at home. Speaking of the food quality, we had countless guests tell us that it was the best food they've ever had at a wedding and we agree wholeheartedly.

This venue and staff are truly such a hidden gem that any couple would be lucky to experience!

Sally Wahlers

This was the perfect venue! Our event was Labor Day weekend, so the weather was perfect!! Not only do you get the barn, but there is an outside patio, a fire pit, an outside tented area and even lawn games. We brought a DJ in and we used their large screen TV for a video. We also had several speakers. Helene helped us from our first inquiry, very professional, personable, accommodating, flexible all the way up until the event. We had the event catered and there was a large selection of choices. We had 150 people attend the event and people are still talking about it. I personally stayed at the inn next-door, which was perfect and there is a restaurant on site as well. The staff were very accommodating, hard-working, and kept the event going throughout the night. I loved that there were different areas that everyone could enjoy. This is the perfect venue for any event. I would highly recommend this for a wedding, especially! Dance under the stars! #perfectvenue

jane arena

What a lovely venue for my niece’s autumn wedding! The ceremony was outside , drinks on the patio and then we headed into the barn ( fancy barn!) for the best reception! The food was exceptional, and they were able to accommodate a separate area of the buffet for gluten free foods. We rented the farmhouse ( a beautifully restored 4 bedroom home), which was great for pre and post- wedding gatherings. It really couldn’t have been better!

Thomas Wallace

The accommodations and amenities added to a really nice and joyous weekend. I also leased the Preston house with family members. Its convenient location and comfort allowed for us to visit, socialize, play cards etc. The house is both spacious and comfortable with private bedrooms, nooks and a large round dining room table perfect for gathering. The inn keeper at the main inn ensured we had everything we needed.

Emily DiLaura

My husband and I both would get married at Preston Barn ten times over. It was the perfect venue for our 116-guest (semi)unconventional wedding. The space is beautiful. It's clean, cozy, and customizable. The food was delicious and working with the Chef on new ideas was so fun. We did a nacho bar and candy apples!

But the event staff alone is something of dreams and why you should book this venue.

I've done events for work for years. I know how wild it can be behind the scenes. Helene and her team were the most professional, thoughtful, and organized event managers/staff I've ever experienced. We had some major curveballs leading up to the day and a few smaller ones during, and they met each with grace.

If you're on the fence, trust me. Book this venue. Helene is the most incredible person you'll ever work with.

Lauren Meldon

We had our wedding this past September at the old drovers inn / Preston barn and it was a 10/10! My family and friends are still ranting and raving about how amazing eveything was. My sister is getting married next month and her and her future husband are very nervous as to whether they will be able to top ours! I am confident when I say, they won’t be able to!! Helene and the whole crew were incredible! Everyone was so friendly and accommodating to all mine, my friends, and families needs. Everything exceeded our expectations! Helene was so responsive whether it was via phone, email, text she always responded right away! Even the day of the wedding she was always right there when you needed her ! The ceremony was in the back of the barn in a very quiet, nice, rustic, wooded area, cocktail hour on the patio, reception in the barn, after party at the restaurant that was on site, followed by s’mores at the bon fire that kept everyone going into the wee hours of the night / morning! I honestly can’t think of one thing that could have gone better then it did.
Following the event the next day everyone continued to be so kind, patient and helpful when trying to gather all wedding day supplies /decor. It was all sensational ! It’s the perfect spot if you’re looking to have eveything in one area. And whether you are local or from out of town there were plenty of housing accommodations for all! Both on site, and close by!
Highly recommend booking your once in a lifetime
Day at the old drovers inn ! You will not regret it! From the service, to the apps, meals, desserts , it was all amazing! We did a walk up sundae bar for dessert that was a huge hit!
We had a short engagement so when we decided to book the venue Helene hooked us up with the pricing and even threw in some freebies. She was so generous and had everything printed out in the contracts , as far as cost go so there weren’t any surprises !
Definitely reach out to take a look for yourself! You’ll fall in love instantly if you’re looking for that rustic boho chic kind of vibe!!

Julie Ann Herbert

The staff at this venue goes above and beyond. Helene was simply amazing to work with. She always answered our questions and treated us like her own family. Jeff the inn keeper, was also such a delight. He was so polite, inviting, and welcoming. We stayed the night along with a few of our guests and we were served breakfast which was delicious! Price was very affordable for this all-inclusive wedding package. Not to mention the views! Rustic, gorgeous fall foliage. Overall, the experience at Preston Barn was stress-free and worth every penny. If we could get married again, we would choose this place again.

Leighann Kowalsky

Elegant and Charming - This team was easy breezy to work with and had so much experience and professionalism! Excellent value, beautiful, beautiful, beautiful!

Hanne Hochheim

We highly recommend Old Drovers Inn if you are planning a small dinner party of 30 guests or less. The Federal Room is a beautiful room with a lot of ambiance and history. Helene made the planning process very easy, and Donna + crew made sure that everything went smoothly the night of the event. The food was delicious, with four choices for our guests to choose from. We could not have had a better experience. We look forward to going back soon.

Jimmy Dolan

Excellent food and atmosphere!

Lauren S

The Preston Barn exceeded my husband and I’s expectations for our wedding day! I cannot thank Helene and the staff enough for making it so easy for us to enjoy each moment of our day! Our wedding was gorgeous and so much fun thanks to the venue and staff here!

Lydia Raulo

Great service and lovely facility.

Loading...