The Tavern

5520 NY-28, Eagle Bay
(315) 357-4305

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Keith M

My group of 9 came here on a Friday in October around 230pm. There were maybe 15 others in the bar. As time went on, more people trickled in. The music was just a tad too loud for me, but that's ok. I could still hear my friends at the table.

The waitress/bartender was a rock star. She was very attentive and friendly. One time she heard us talk about a drink and when I got to the bar to order it, it just appeared. Ha. I was amazed.

Other people in the bar were friendly. One in my group just had a birthday and someone else came over and began to chat with us about it.

We were only there for an hour, but it was such a nice day drinking experience. We didn't have any food. I'll definitely visit again if I'm in the area.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Duncan Flamino

Had a delicious hamburger !

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Heather DeVito

I just moved here and wanted to find a place to have dinner. Outdoor seating is always a draw for me, and I enjoyed the scenery and watching people going about their business. The server was very friendly and pleasantly helpful. She recommended the Wagyu burger because multiple people had said it melted in their mouth. I was sold, and melt in my mouth it did! I ordered with no truffle oil and she offered to put it in the side so I could taste it. Great idea because I really enjoyed it. The fries were really good but would have been even more enjoyable if salted a bit less. They had great flavor but definitely over salted. I forgot the name of my cocktail but it was delicious and the server said it was a popular choice. The bread was fresh and chewy, but I'd skip the Caesar salad next time. It was very, very basic and not worth it. It would have been nice if the other salad options came in a smaller size. The delicious lemon blueberry dessert I took to go was well worth it! I was too full after stuffing that entire, perfectly cooked med-rare burger down my gullet to have dessert while there, and I'm glad I didn't pass up taking one to go. Perfect midnight nosh. I would definitely go back, and if given the same option to sit anywhere, will choose a more secluded spot so as to not be subjected to a patron at the next table spouting off the ENTIRE time about politics, making sure anyone within earshot could hear. Overall, I really enjoyed myself. I stopped at the bar afterwards to finish my cocktail and the bartender and another patron were very friendly. We all chatted and the evening was exactly what I was looking for.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

brendan doherty

Great staff, great drinks! Lovely place !!!!

Martin Dybas

Great place for locals, friendly with decent food and beverages. Only issue was the strong cooking smell from the kitchen was inescapable.

Mike

Great bartender. One of the best burgers around

William B Kean

The tavern is my favorite place in the area ! Awesome service, excellent drinks and the food always hits the spot. I would recommend lunch or a drink at the Tavern to anyone !

Patrick DeBono

Nice “dive bar” place. Small restaurant and bar with lots of Adirondack type decor.

Burgers are really good. Great value, too.

Good food, good service, nice bar service and draft beers as well.

It’s dated, but gets the job done for a decent lunch.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Michael McEvoy

Good food with family. Excellent service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Heather Ammon

The Tavern was a nice neighborhood place, but they advertise being handicap accessible and they definitely are not. Also, be prepared, they are cash only. And there is no a/c. The food was not bad, although a little well done.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Wally Morabito

Nice little bar. Has a pool table. All the locals hang out here. Friendly people great service

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Asad Butt

Best Grilled Cheese ever.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

AMB

Best Grilled Cheese ever.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Daniel Wenck

Reheated hockey puck burgers last two visits. Good bar service, food has been better in the past.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Michelle Chase

Great little place with good food and

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hamburger

Loading...