Athens Square Cafe

517 Larkfield Rd, East Northport
(631) 368-6098

Recent Reviews

Paul Lawrence

Good gyroDamn good customer serviceReasonable prices.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Andrews Martinez

I went to this place with my friends and we loved it! Good is amazing, service is great and the prices are not bad!!! (Very good portion btw)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: 9 25 Chicken Gyro Sandwich, Greek Salad with Chicken Gyro Meat, Large Greek Salad

Brooke Mannino

best greek food love it here everything is

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Yvellise V.

Surprusef to see such a low rating because this is our go to greek takeout choice! Consistently great and reasonably priced compared to others in the area. Most often we order lamb or chicken gyros and their mozz sticks. French fries always are a bit soggy by arrival but we pop em in the air fryer and theyre grrrreat

Phil T B

Great food! The owner is a great person! Service is always fast.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mary F.

I used to love this place. It has gone downhill majorly. The owner has always been a jerk. Everyone knows that. But the food was at least awesome. Now the food is awful. The portions are so small. And the owner has somehow gotten worse. I saw a woman two weeks ago question the size of the giro asking if it was lunch size or something. She was so polite about it. And the owner SCREAMED at her. It was awful. She said she was a customer for 20 years. This place used to be a nice neighborhood spot for a gyro. And the owner has become his own energy. Don't go here. Plus I know a few people who swear it got them sick. Don't risk it. Their service and standards are done for.

Joe G.

There I was hungry but not the normal kind of hungry...that kind of hunger that only a chicken soovlacki can satisfy...I enter...I am greeted by what can only be described as the most Greek person I've ever laid eyes on (very hairy)... nonetheless I order my chiken soovlacki but oh my!! Suddenly the feeling hits a feeling we all know too well...I need a bev I gaze past the man at the soda fountain...we lock eyes ISLAND. ORANGE. RUSH. Now if you know anything about me I love anything orange flavored I'm what you would call a slut for citrus nonetheless I order the IOR (Island orange rush) oh my what's this 5$!!!!!! FOR A SMALL SODA?!?!?? A cup like the ones you get on a plane like a tiny ass cup like soo fuckin small like think of a small cup...imagine it in your mind...yeah pretty small huh nope...make it smaller yep now you've got it...nonetheless I did not protest (I am a timid man by nature) I drink my newly purchased tablespoon worth of IOR (Island orange rush) and it was.......not great the soovlacki was pretty good tho Alyssa did not spit in my food (I asked her to) (terrable)?

Linda Dickman

Beautiful presentation, great food as always. We had a small Greek salad with chicken gyro meat on top.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Margaux H.

Best Greek salad I've ever had, everything was chopped so small! Service was excellent and efficient! Definitely recommend

Sue S.

Let's start with the kids answering the phone. We asked for taramasalta (on their menu), her response was "what's that?". Should have skipped ordering it because we spent $9.00 on a dollop of dip. The Greek salad with grilled chicken was underwhelming. Very little lettuce and oily dressing. Husband ordered a gyro (despite menu saying it comes with onions) there were none. There is a lot of competition around for Greek food. I'd skip this place.

Denise E.

My entire order was wrong! I ordered chicken souvlaki with fries for myself and my daughter. They made them souvlaki gyros. NOT what I ordered. And my fiancés gyro was plain! I didn't order it plain! Avgalemeno soup - poor. I love Aegean grill. Should've stuck with that!

CPNY

I had takeout from there the other night and I enjoyed it. Fresh ingredients and friendly service. Price is average.

Billy C.

Just look at the sad picture for an chicken gyro dinner. Enough said. Pass on this $20 plate

Tim Sullivan

BEST falafel and Greek salads on the Island, hands down!!!!! Good, quality FRESH food prepared quickly. Bonus since it's literally across the street from my job.

N Maza

Excellent food definitely my favorite in the area to get Greek food

Load More