Original Fireside Caterers

4097 Jericho Turnpike, East Northport
(631) 462-0900

Recent Reviews

fourth laxer

CLOSED!!! What a shame!!! George McCallion , you did an amazing job running that place. Everything was always excellent on your watch. I wish good fortune to you,. If it's your wish, I hope you start up another business again. My father installed your merlin system. now you know who this is!

Keith B.

Website says they are no longer in business as of May 31, 2020. Phone has a permanent busy signal. Sad to see them go. They were a favorite.

Evangeline Reyes

Great hot sandwiches. Glad we went today unfortunately due to current life we are living in we saw they are closing down as of May 31, 2020. Get while you can. Support local businesses.

Elisabeth Hanington

Ive been going there for more than eight years. Always friendly orifessional people. And the food is delicious. I will certsinly miss all these great people. George, michael. Clare and Jose.

sean ryan

Great food. Been going there for years.

Vanessa A

Three times I came to order food from here, I was ignored in line by all the workers. They kept taking other people’s order while I was standing there trying to call them. It’s always very hard to get them to take my order. And when they do they are rude about it. Not worth the wait

Krys K

A long time Long Island staple with several locations. Great sandwiches, amazing rotisserie and top notch catering.

Enrrique Chinchilla

I asked to make my own salad and one guy there told me that They had pre-made ones, but I told him that I wanted my own salad in a specific way and he refused and he was acting like He didn’t know what I was talking about. He was just being vague because I asked another guy at the same place before and he actually made my salad the way I wanted it. Please next time if you just don’t want to do it for XYZ reason just say it and don’t waste your time and mine.

nichol bodden

I dont like the cash dicount policy. The price should be the same however you make payment. I've visited there over the years to find my last visit that the price would be higher by 3+%. I choose to go elsewhere.

Sean Cortes

Great food. Freshly made. A better option then fast food as its ready to take out fast but its like homemade. Friendly staff. Clean.

Leo U.

Catered a meal for 25 this holiday season. We ordered chicken and ribs with all there sides. We were so disappointed with 90 percent of what they did. The rotisserie chicken was dry. The fried chicken did not hold up even though they told us how to keep it warm. The ribs were actually disgusting and fatty with the worst sauce ever. Lesson learned fireside does not travel or stay well. Stick to a sandwich.

Shannon Sha

This is a convenient, friendly neighborhood place to pick up food. I like the fried chicken. The rotisserie chicken wasn't as good. The sides are standard, decent.

Achmed Davidian

Your deli is nowhere near real NY deli standard and your catering food is sub-par. I think what keeps this business standing is a clientele with a sub-par palate.

Richard Honoski

Outstanding Food & Service!

Joseph DeRosa

Love there ribs and chicken. Cucumber salad is great. I also love the mac and cheese. If your a sausage and pepper fan you will not be disappointed. Staff is friendly and helpful.

Load More