Customer Service above and beyond thanks to Teddy Lunch was delicious we will see you again Cheers
Marty Purchick
Red Tomato is back! New owners are fantastic. Food is once again wonderful.
John M.
There is a new owner and the improvements are obvious. Just had dinner and it was delicious. The chicken parmigiana was excellent as was the eggplant rollatini, meatballs, Caesar salad and Mediterranean salad. Teddy, our waiter, was friendly and professional.
Charlotte Brennan
new owner is so nice and generous!! pizza is great as always
Andrea Kalogeras
Awesome food and service. The new owners are friendly and the service is great. Store was clean. Will definitely go back.
Kyle Ponsiek
Awesome food, very clean looking now. Before it was just a mess. John the new owner is doing a fantastic job, Keep up the good work!
Andrea K.
Excellent food and service. Since the new owners have taken over the restaurant is clean, staff is friendly and the food is delish. Try it
Jim Tamburino
A hidden upscale gem under new ownership with the best pizza on Long Island. Great staff & service! Great food! Our new spot!
Allen Michael
They ruined our large order for a party. We were very specific what we wanted and repeated our order to ensure it was correct when placing order in advance. They got the order wrong - when confronted they did not offer to make it right in fact refused to, would of been a larger sale for them & we would of had the right order. New owners ruined this place. AVOID AVOID AVOID
Sara Hulse
Love Red Tomato - nice relaxing night out with the family enjoying great pizza with a glass of wine! Don’t leave without trying the dessert pizza!!
Really enjoyed the special attention and quality of our entrees tonight! Pizza was super Neapolitan authentic and the staff was really nice to our table. (awesome salads too! ?)
Peter Silverman
The owner sat in the corner near me and talked on the phone the whole time, even after I expressed my displeasure. That ruined the meal. I don't plan to go back.
sammi pinto
used to love coming here with my family & friends. i visited today & i personally had an unpleasant experience with the service. the waitress was very abrupt, slamming drinks, food down on table. never checked on us once. forgot to give us our iced teas & when we reminded her, she took another 5 minutes to get them for us (they were bottled beverages). she charged me for the wrong table & as i was about to tell her she reached across my arm that was noticeably in a sling because i had just gotten surgery & she ripped the check out of my hand. it was very rude & to say the least i won’t be coming back. i’ve been dining here since i was in high school & used to recommend it to everyone. my friend who was with me came for the first time, and she was equally irritated with the service given to us today.
Ben k
Heard good things, got mediocre pizza. Dough was old, dry and chewy, clearly cooked in an oven that was not hot enough. Really expensive and extremely subpar. So much better pizza in the area, dont waste your money or time...
Scott Rubinstein
We used to go all the time and had fantastic meals. Before the owners changed.The service was great the food Was delicious. I went there the other night the food was too disgusting to describe it is hard to believe that these people call themselves restaurant people. The mozzarella was supposed to be fresh and it tasted like it just came out of a freezer bag from Sam’s Club. and the chicken Parm tasted like it came out of The Stop & Shop freezer down the street. It’s insulting to sell Products that are advertised as homemade and r totally Bogus. I usually don’t write reviews on anything but I just couldn’t help myself on this one. And don’t even get me started on the Canned clam pizza.
Customer Service above and beyond thanks to Teddy Lunch was delicious we will see you again Cheers
Red Tomato is back! New owners are fantastic. Food is once again wonderful.
There is a new owner and the improvements are obvious. Just had dinner and it was delicious. The chicken parmigiana was excellent as was the eggplant rollatini, meatballs, Caesar salad and Mediterranean salad. Teddy, our waiter, was friendly and professional.
new owner is so nice and generous!! pizza is great as always
Awesome food and service. The new owners are friendly and the service is great. Store was clean. Will definitely go back.
Awesome food, very clean looking now. Before it was just a mess. John the new owner is doing a fantastic job, Keep up the good work!
Excellent food and service. Since the new owners have taken over the restaurant is clean, staff is friendly and the food is delish. Try it
A hidden upscale gem under new ownership with the best pizza on Long Island. Great staff & service! Great food! Our new spot!
They ruined our large order for a party. We were very specific what we wanted and repeated our order to ensure it was correct when placing order in advance. They got the order wrong - when confronted they did not offer to make it right in fact refused to, would of been a larger sale for them & we would of had the right order. New owners ruined this place. AVOID AVOID AVOID
Love Red Tomato - nice relaxing night out with the family enjoying great pizza with a glass of wine! Don’t leave without trying the dessert pizza!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Really enjoyed the special attention and quality of our entrees tonight! Pizza was super Neapolitan authentic and the staff was really nice to our table. (awesome salads too! ?)
The owner sat in the corner near me and talked on the phone the whole time, even after I expressed my displeasure. That ruined the meal. I don't plan to go back.
used to love coming here with my family & friends. i visited today & i personally had an unpleasant experience with the service. the waitress was very abrupt, slamming drinks, food down on table. never checked on us once. forgot to give us our iced teas & when we reminded her, she took another 5 minutes to get them for us (they were bottled beverages). she charged me for the wrong table & as i was about to tell her she reached across my arm that was noticeably in a sling because i had just gotten surgery & she ripped the check out of my hand. it was very rude & to say the least i won’t be coming back. i’ve been dining here since i was in high school & used to recommend it to everyone. my friend who was with me came for the first time, and she was equally irritated with the service given to us today.
Heard good things, got mediocre pizza. Dough was old, dry and chewy, clearly cooked in an oven that was not hot enough. Really expensive and extremely subpar. So much better pizza in the area, dont waste your money or time...
We used to go all the time and had fantastic meals. Before the owners changed.The service was great the food Was delicious. I went there the other night the food was too disgusting to describe it is hard to believe that these people call themselves restaurant people. The mozzarella was supposed to be fresh and it tasted like it just came out of a freezer bag from Sam’s Club. and the chicken Parm tasted like it came out of The Stop & Shop freezer down the street. It’s insulting to sell Products that are advertised as homemade and r totally Bogus. I usually don’t write reviews on anything but I just couldn’t help myself on this one. And don’t even get me started on the Canned clam pizza.