Worst Sicilian I ever had. Soggy and raw dough. No flavor at all and cost more than other places. Definitely will not he back here.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Katie M.
We've tried just about every pizza place in the Patchogue/Medford area and Carlito's is by far our favorite. Now we order from here almost every week. Perfect crust - not too doughy, not too thin. The sauce is rich and flavorful. Fast delivery. And most importantly the pizza is consistently fresh and delicious. Highly recommend!
Joseph Putre
Garbage, soggy pizza and all slices taste the same ?
Just ordered a plain cheese pie from here, best in the area in my opinion! Will be ordering from them from now on!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mr Williams
Ordered 2 good 2 go. Every pizzeria gives you a healthy amount of food. This store gave use 2 small burnt slices and a burnt pizza roll. Never again!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
joan napolitano
Love the pies. Ordered online and they delivered FAST. Will be ordering again. Really crispy pie.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lindsey Caggiano
This was my first time ordering from here and it certainly won’t be my last. This was the best eggplant Parmesan I’ve had in a long time! The sauce has such a great flavor.
Food: 5
Jeannette Mistler
The owner is a scammer. His website shows a combo for $29.95 and he insisted on charging me $34.95. He didn’t care what his website shows. When I told him I’m contacting consumer affairs for false advertisement he said ok and hung up on me. There’s plenty of other pizzerias in the area who don’t try to rip their customers off and treat them with respect. Never again!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Gary L DiClementi
The young man behind the counter was very polite and had a great sense of humor. He greeted us with a smile. We went in for the Tuesday special, one cheese pie, baked ziti, one hero and a salad. We added a second hero, there were six of us for dinner and there was more than enough food.
Pizza was not bad but garlic knots were terrible and calamari was like processed(not real) and tasted very much so. We threw the entire thing away it was so bad.
Toby Music
Incredible pizza. I'm very amazed. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Theresa S.
Spent $35 for a pizza, garlic knots and greek salad. The pizza was undercooked, the garlic knots were very greasy, the salad..very light on the feta cheese. Not worth it. I am still hungry!! Will not be ordering from them again.
Eleanora Floyd
They refried the chicken so it tastes bad. Garlic knots tasted like bread with garlic on top. That's it. They are underneath new ownership so the recipes are not as good. I wish the old owners never sold the place.Parking: Ample amount of parking.
Zulma Zelayandia
excellent food, I give you a 100, thanks Carlitos pizzeria
Worst Sicilian I ever had. Soggy and raw dough. No flavor at all and cost more than other places. Definitely will not he back here.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
We've tried just about every pizza place in the Patchogue/Medford area and Carlito's is by far our favorite. Now we order from here almost every week. Perfect crust - not too doughy, not too thin. The sauce is rich and flavorful. Fast delivery. And most importantly the pizza is consistently fresh and delicious. Highly recommend!
Garbage, soggy pizza and all slices taste the same ?
Food: 1
Pizza is delicious. I love the garlic knots.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Specialty Slices, Garlic Knots
Just ordered a plain cheese pie from here, best in the area in my opinion! Will be ordering from them from now on!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered 2 good 2 go. Every pizzeria gives you a healthy amount of food. This store gave use 2 small burnt slices and a burnt pizza roll. Never again!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Love the pies. Ordered online and they delivered FAST. Will be ordering again. Really crispy pie.
Food: 5
Service: 5
This was my first time ordering from here and it certainly won’t be my last. This was the best eggplant Parmesan I’ve had in a long time! The sauce has such a great flavor.
Food: 5
The owner is a scammer. His website shows a combo for $29.95 and he insisted on charging me $34.95. He didn’t care what his website shows. When I told him I’m contacting consumer affairs for false advertisement he said ok and hung up on me. There’s plenty of other pizzerias in the area who don’t try to rip their customers off and treat them with respect. Never again!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The young man behind the counter was very polite and had a great sense of humor. He greeted us with a smile. We went in for the Tuesday special, one cheese pie, baked ziti, one hero and a salad. We added a second hero, there were six of us for dinner and there was more than enough food.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gluten Free Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza was not bad but garlic knots were terrible and calamari was like processed(not real) and tasted very much so. We threw the entire thing away it was so bad.
Incredible pizza. I'm very amazed. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Spent $35 for a pizza, garlic knots and greek salad. The pizza was undercooked, the garlic knots were very greasy, the salad..very light on the feta cheese. Not worth it. I am still hungry!! Will not be ordering from them again.
They refried the chicken so it tastes bad. Garlic knots tasted like bread with garlic on top. That's it. They are underneath new ownership so the recipes are not as good. I wish the old owners never sold the place.Parking: Ample amount of parking.
excellent food, I give you a 100, thanks Carlitos pizzeria