Rinaldo's Pizzeria & Catering

The best pizza in the county! I highly recommend the 'Grandma's Pie'. Everything we've ordered has been amazing, from subs to pasta meals. I look forward to trying the rest of the menu.

It was a very short visit but the cashier was very pleasant. I got the Grandma's Sicilian slice which was excellent and reasonably priced for the size. The puffed up cookies near the register are closer to muffins than cookies. Good enough but nothing special

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Love the chicken riggies got it for take out and when i got home it was great.keep up the good work!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Pizza was burned and way too salty. Not impressed one bit. Will never go here again. And it was way too expensive... $15 for a medium cheese??? Really?? Never again!! Horrible. Pizza is better at Byrne Dairy down the road.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

This is the best pizza in the area!

They're closed on Tuesdays for a well deserved day off and I had to get pizza somewhere else and it's just not as good :/

Just moved into the neighborhood and discovered this gem. Great pizza and wings, and the riggies were amazing! You can tell Wayne is cooking with fresh ingredients and cooking with love!

Food: 5

I just recently started ordering pizza from here, as my job brought me into the Village of Elbridge.
I had never tried it but heard really good things from a colleague.

The atmosphere inside is charming, it’s extremely clean- the staff and owners are welcoming and friendly.

I’ve been ordering the Buffalo Style Chicken Pizza… I have to say I really can’t get enough of it and it’s honestly the best one I’ve had.

Just enough kick to be fabulously tasty, not overwhelming, but a really good balance of spicy - cheesy - and lots of tender chicken!

At other establishments , I always have to order extra hot sauce. I did with this one initially as well, but it didn’t need it. It’s been perfect.

Kudos! Definitely recommend it - I will be back next week!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great place to snag a slice or two. Their Mushroom Pizza and their Grandma's Pizza are fantastic.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

We make it a point to come here every time we come into town. The food is phenomenal and the people are so welcoming. The entire family loves it here!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Really good dill pickle pizza!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

At 22$ for a small pepperoni mushroom pizza, 16$ for wings. Tell me how they're charging almost a dollar for blue cheese, you get home to eat your wings and check out how much they give you. Absurd. I'm appalled at their service lately. I used too speak highly of them, yet now Rinaldos isn't worth the extra money whatsoever. Check out the sloppy pizza too boot. Literally looks like just the corners were cut with incredibly uneven cheese. Towpath has a medium with wings for 24$ and they come out better than this every time, and Valentine's Pizza. Both are cheaper and far better quality than this establishment. Very disappointed. Had I known it would be like this I wouldn't have ordered from Rinaldos.

Service: 1

Best pizza in the area, period. They do thin crust right, the perfect combination of crunch and chew. The sauce and cheese are in the right proportions so one doesn't overpower the other, and both have excellent flavor. No one in Auburn is doing it this well, so it's worth the drive. I'm looking forward to exploring more of their menu.

Excellent catering service! The food was outstanding! Everything was perfectly cooked and very nicely prepared. As always it was a fantastic experience and the food tasted great!

Good food, fair prices

Small pizza shop but it's a great place to stop for lunch. Nice crispy thin crust.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5