The Homestead Restaurant + Lounge at The Eldred Preserve
1040 State Rte 55, Eldred
(845) 557-8316
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Our family went to dinner last night for my husband 's birthday. I had the trout and strongly recommend. Staff went over and above to meet our dinning experience enjoyable. Definitely go back in the summer.
Parking: Beautiful venue
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak, Smoked Trout, Shrimp Stuffed Mushrooms
It was another great experience there..the food, the atmosphere, the service
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
My wife and I like to go here for special occasions. The food has always been good, the service is phenomenal, the grounds and restaurant are beautiful. Seriously some of the best bathrooms around.
But a loaf of the cinnamon bread and have the wildest breakfast of your life the next day.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lordbarky like. From the moment you walk in you feel special. Great lounge while waiting for table , descent downstairs to an extraordinary dining room with exceptional architectural accents lights and wall sculpture designed from tree branches. Service quick and informed. For starters butternut squash soup with apple shavings beautifully presented and full of flavor. For dinner my party had maple glazed pork chop well seasoned and moist, others had steaks. One note although the blueberry chipotle sauce was very tasty, it was served with the steak but I would suggest offering with a chop. Creamy Spinach side was full leaves and not chopped which allows one to savor the spinach. Dessert was pumpkin cheese cake creamy texture and not too sweet. Well done - a must in the Eldred bethel area so Lordbarky likes
This was my second time coming here and was truly blown away by the surrounding preserve that envelops you thru the floor to second story windows. In March the dining room was not open for the season, so ate at the upstairs bar area. Both spaces are absolutely beautiful and the food was superb as it was in March, just elevated all the more spending time in the dining room. Are waiter Matt was on point and the whole operation of kitchen to table and every thing in between was perfect!!! Worth the trip each and every time!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We went a couple months prior and had the best meal !!!!!! This time, there wasn't anything that tasted the same, and they tasted worse. They told us the chef had left. I hope they find a new chef. The meat was tough as well.
We had a great night at the Eldrid Preserve. Took our very picky brother in law. Was amazed he loved the food. Doesn't happen too often. Our waiter was new to the restaurant and was a little soft spoken but was able to have others at the table relay the specials to me . The dishes were all cooked to perfection. Would definitely recommend giving it a try.
We had a fantastic anniversary celebration. This is the second time we've been to the Eldred Preserve for our anniversary and it's becoming an annual tradition. Thank you so much!
We were a party of six. Jackie, our server had great recommendations. She and the other staff were friendly and accommodating, especially with the family's 101 year old mother and grandmother with us. . The trout, ceviche, spicy tuna, shrimp and scalloped stuffed mushrooms,pork chop and sides all outstanding.
As usual, we had a wonderful time. We brought my mother-in-law and she was overwhelmed. The experience was great. Sarah was our server and she was also fantastic. Our new favorite place.
Restaurantji Recommends
Went with a group of 6 friends for a proposal dinner. Once we arrived the ambiance struck are eyes as we all proceed to look all around and take pictures. As we began to walk in we all were excited to order some cocktails and have a great time. Our waitress greeted us and offered us three types of water. A couple mins later she came back with our water and took our drink orders. The drinks were really good it just took about 20/30 minutes to come out. After our drinks came out our food order was taking. We ordered the spicy tuna and honey pepper chicken for apps which was delicious. For dinner my group ordered 3 chicken Parmesan which was lacking sauce on both the chicken and pasta. The French grilled pork chop, braised short ribs and the duck dish that were really and would order again. Overall I would come back just would like service to be a bit faster
I was a little unsure after reading unfavorable posts about this restaurant but my experience was among the best I've had recently. The hostess was welcoming, our waiter Matt was friendly and very efficient as well as knowledgeable about the varied menu, specials, and the wine, of which we had a recommended Unshackled Napa red. Fantastic. My husband has the salmon plated with seaweed salad. I had the special gazpacho to start, then brook trout with farro. All tasty! We shared a huge plain baked potato. We were both stuffed and had to pass on the tantalizing dessert offerings. The ambiance, with floor to (over 20 ft) ceiling windows framed the wooded preserve and pond beyond. The modern wood plank and stone interiors is meticulously designed. The complimentary bread basket included their “famous” cinnamon raisin bread. Memorable, savory experience all the way around.
I’m done. This was my sixth or seventh time there and my last. There is nobody here who knows how to run a restaurant. Poor service dirty glasses, stale bread and a waitress with a shirt that didn’t fit. The land is beautiful, the restaurant is horrible
The outdoor dining and atmosphere was beautiful. Apps were delicious but unfortunately our three steaks that we ordered medium rare came out medium well. Desserts were great! Service was very poor and we sat for 40 minutes waiting to be cleared after dinner to order dessert. Not the best 1st experience but will try it again as it may have been an off day.
From cocktails in the upstairs lounge, to the most amazing service and food- cannot wait to go again! Beautiful atmosphere, impeccable service and that bread!!! My husband had fantastic duck breast and I had the delicious halibut special. Wonderful night!
Loading...