Great location- food is always served fresh and hot. The prices are super affordable and staff is always attentive and kind. Parking in the rear makes this place super convenient for dinner and lunch!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Meatball Parmigiana, Pizza's, Salad with Ranch Dressing
Tom C
I tried Nick's pizza for the first time on November 8th. I got a plain cheese pizza and the Bianca Rosa. The Bianca Rosa is an immediate favorite with white garlic and fresh sliced tomatoes. It had a nice taste, not overwhelmed by the garlic. The cheese pizza had a good taste also. Both were thin crust. I returned on November 11th for lunch. I tried the chicken cutlet sub. The chicken had a good taste and a nice crunch. I just wished the sub would have had something on it, lettuce, tomato, maybe some kind of dressing. I also tried a canoli. The filling on the canoli had a wonderful taste, the chocolate drizzle was a nice, along with the cream on the side. I will return to try dinner, as they have many delicious dishes. I can definitely recommend the pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza's
dan hawe
One of the best and still original Italian restaurants in Endicott
Wendy
I ordered a Antipasto Salad, which I've ordered here multiple times before & it was NOT the same. All iceberg lettuce, 3 small slices of pepperoni, no cheese, no olives, 2 cherry tomatoes that was it. A big plate of mostly iceberg lettuce. So disappointed.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
Isa Mak
Pizza in one of the best around
K1078RKannc
I’d rate it 3/5 for local Italian food and 3/5 for the NY-style pizza — both were decent, but nothing particularly memorable. Service was solid at 5/5, friendly and attentive. Disappointed that gnocchi was the only homemade pasta option — a letdown if you're expecting traditional Italian fare. The side salad was underwhelming, just plain iceberg leaves, though the homemade dressing was a nice touch. On the upside, the lunch specials are a good value and make it worth checking out if you're nearby and looking for a deal.
oneupstatenewyorker
So simple, but always delicious, Nick's is well managed & has been producing consistently positive eating out experiences for the people of the Southern Tier for many years. They have all the staples, & more, & the prices remain well within reason. The staff is always friendly & service is quick. Nick himself often walks among the tables. We keep going for good reason. I'd be lost without it!
Marie-Therese W
Best pizza outside of Italy I’ve had in along time. If you are traveling in the area, highly recommend. And Great service.
Jerry Corrente
the pizza is always delicious and the sauce is great and the owner and workers are very nice and polite
WavesandBeaches
We have been to Nick's a number of times as our group is used to it. We find everything we try to be fair to poor. The pizza was oily and had a brackish taste. Tried spaghetti and meatballs and could not eat the meatballs. Sad business.
Great location- food is always served fresh and hot. The prices are super affordable and staff is always attentive and kind. Parking in the rear makes this place super convenient for dinner and lunch!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Meatball Parmigiana, Pizza's, Salad with Ranch Dressing
I tried Nick's pizza for the first time on November 8th.
I got a plain cheese pizza and the Bianca Rosa.
The Bianca Rosa is an immediate favorite with white garlic and fresh sliced tomatoes. It had a nice taste, not overwhelmed by the garlic.
The cheese pizza had a good taste also. Both were thin crust.
I returned on November 11th for lunch.
I tried the chicken cutlet sub. The chicken had a good taste and a nice crunch. I just wished the sub would have had something on it, lettuce, tomato, maybe some kind of dressing.
I also tried a canoli. The filling on the canoli had a wonderful taste, the chocolate drizzle was a nice, along with the cream on the side.
I will return to try dinner, as they have many delicious dishes.
I can definitely recommend the pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza's
One of the best and still original Italian restaurants in Endicott
I ordered a Antipasto Salad, which I've ordered here multiple times before & it was NOT the same. All iceberg lettuce, 3 small slices of pepperoni, no cheese, no olives, 2 cherry tomatoes that was it. A big plate of mostly iceberg lettuce. So disappointed.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
Pizza in one of the best around
I’d rate it 3/5 for local Italian food and 3/5 for the NY-style pizza — both were decent, but nothing particularly memorable. Service was solid at 5/5, friendly and attentive. Disappointed that gnocchi was the only homemade pasta option — a letdown if you're expecting traditional Italian fare. The side salad was underwhelming, just plain iceberg leaves, though the homemade dressing was a nice touch. On the upside, the lunch specials are a good value and make it worth checking out if you're nearby and looking for a deal.
So simple, but always delicious, Nick's is well managed & has been producing consistently positive eating out experiences for the people of the Southern Tier for many years. They have all the staples, & more, & the prices remain well within reason. The staff is always friendly & service is quick. Nick himself often walks among the tables. We keep going for good reason. I'd be lost without it!
Best pizza outside of Italy I’ve had in along time. If you are traveling in the area, highly recommend. And Great service.
the pizza is always delicious and the sauce is great and the owner and workers are very nice and polite
We have been to Nick's a number of times as our group is used to it. We find everything we try to be fair to poor. The pizza was oily and had a brackish taste. Tried spaghetti and meatballs and could not eat the meatballs. Sad business.
Restaurantji Recommends
The absolute best. I judge all other pizza based on Nick's.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent dinner the other night. Nick's is always top notch, their service is amazing and the food delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Too much cheese to hide and average lasagna
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
The house ranch and salads are the reason I love this place. Cheese pizza is spot on.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Stuffed Shells and Meatballs, Salad with Ranch Dressing, Cheese Pizza
Parking: Free Parking lot behind Restaurant. One can get there thru Nanticoke Ave. also.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...