5 De Mayo Steakhouse

2120 Broadhollow Rd, Farmingdale
(631) 557-2970

Recent Reviews

Debby Voorneveld

Everything about this restaurant is amazing! The food was so fresh and delicious! The service was outstanding!!!Vegetarian options: A lot of choicesParking: Big lot to park

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Nachos Deluxe, Steak and Shrimp Tacos, Rice and Beans, Chips and Salsa

James Ruggiero

Food was very good but food and dessert took a long time to arrive. Surprised at this because at the time we dined the restaurant wasn't crowded.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Jason Green

Excellent food. Great staff. Slightly over-priced, but for a special occasion go for it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Nora Andersen

The tacos were fantastic and the service was so

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Steak and Shrimp Tacos

aneta sadowski

Delish food,margaritas were delish too!!Steaks and shrimp ceviche was also very good . We also had creme brûlée for dessert ,amazing. We also loved the band that was playing. We will be back. Highly recommended!! we had a great experience!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rosemary Ruggiero

The Food was excellent but the service was very slow and it was not a busy evening. On Thursdays there is live music and a price fixe menu. It is well worth the price but unfortunately the slow service detracted from the experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Nachos Deluxe

StevenD

First time here with a group of 12 people for a birthday celebration. Surprisingly very slow for a Friday night! There were only 5 tables all night, including ours. We started off with table side guacamole, fundido and calamari. All portions were pretty small for the price. Guac was absolutely delicious, fundido was very good as well and the calamari was very bland and not prepared as the menu stated. It was supposed to come with sweet chili sauce, but it came with marinara sauce. Entrees were very good! My NY strip was cooked perfectly, but was lacking a little seasoning. The fried egg was way over fried and the Chorizo sausage was very dry. All other entrees on the table were very good and satisfying. Service was attentive and polite even though they seemed a little on the Novice side of the business. I brought a cake for dessert. They didn't charge me a cutting fee which was very nice and they made a big deal about the birthday girl, which was also very nice!!! Birthday drinks were on the house, which was a very generous gesture. The staff and owner were a lot of fun and very upbeat!! I really hope they do well here!! I will definitely be back and would highly recommend giving them a try.

Krys

This restaurant was beautifully inside & out. Live in house musican playing good ‘ol’ classic Spanish music. Service however was a bit slow. Don’t know if it was due to short staff, which is completely understandable, however, try to find a way to communicate that with your table. Anywho our waitress, Monica, was very warmhearted & sweet just felt like were kinda left alone for a while without ordering (45mins) w only chips & salsa & then waiting for the food to come took even longer & it was just 2 of us. Other tables of more were being served before us which was frustrating but nonetheless the Shrimp self crabmeat was AMAZING, the NY Steak would’ve been better if there was less fat but cooked to perfection. Overall, I would return, just communicate with customers if there’s a long wait.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Brandon

Great food and great service. Everyone was so friendly and kind. The food was terrific and the spicy margaritas were delicious. Can't recommend this restaurant enough. Will definitely be back.

Angela Godwin

GO INSIDE! Great food, awesome service, beautiful interior. I’ll admit- from the outside I was questionable. So glad we went! Can’t wait to go again. Don’t judge a book by its cover.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Flan, Skirt Steak, Table Side Guacamole, Paella

Marta Perez

Excellent service and food. Slightly overpriced but well worth.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Flan, Skirt Steak, Table Side Guacamole

Sarah Gyimah

The food at this place is good but takes so long to come out that you’re not really hungry by that time. The service was rlly slow for some reason, all tables around us seemed irritated in waiting for their food. They did not play about refilling the water though, they did that rly well!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 1

Mamam

Was looking forward to a wonderful brunch. The service was wonderful and attentive. The food was lacking. While the seafood was plenty, the rest on display was sad, cold and stale. Will go back for dinner, which was good, but not for the brunch.

J, DAVID ABREU

Excellent food and service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Skirt Steak

DanaB

Food was average but over priced. Drinks were good. Service was friendly BUT... not coordinated. 3 different servers kept coming to the table all night. After we paid, the C manager asked if we wanted dessert. A little annoying.

Load More