Went in for brunch with my husband and another couple. There were literally only three other tables occupied. Our cocktails were very good, but were brought out piecemeal. It would've been nice if we all had our drinks at the same time. We ordered appetizers, boneless wings and spinach and artichoke dip that were both mediocre. We specifically asked when we ordered the appetizers that there was ample time between getting the appetizers and getting our meal and of course that did not happen. We didn't have our appetizers for more than two minutes went out, came our meals. We told them to take it back to which the waitress told us that they were just going to sit in the back and we told them then we would not be paying for our meal. She wound up accommodating us. My burger was very good, cooked the way I wanted it, medium rare. Although there were only other three other occupied tables, our waiter never came over to check on us or to refill our water which we had to ask for multiple times. We did sit in the front in open air, which was very nice. We live in Farmingdale so we've been there several times and I will probably go back because the burgers are good, but they need to really improve the service. Honestly, the burgers are just as good at The Villager down the block so I definitely will think twice before going back.
Opentable Diner
We were a big group, of both kids and adults shared a couple appetizers, had entrees and shakes. Food was good and came out in a reasonable amount of time. Our waiter was awful though, missing drinks, did not check on us once to see if we needed anything when our food came out, my 10 year old flagged down another waiter to get a water and extra napkins. When we asked for our check, the waiter then went on to make drinks for other tables and disappeared in the kitchen. One of us had to go up to the bar to ask again for the check. We had a good time because it was trivia night, which we didn't know, but was a happy accident. However, the service really put a damper on things. Especially when it hit 8:30 and we had tired kiddos, while we waited for the check.
Reid
Great night out. Food and service were both excellent and the brownie sundae was the perfect ending.
robert
Liked the place very much, great service , delicious food. A bit too noisy For me but would def go back
robert
Food was great ) I had their wings and fries with truffle sauce. Very good. Service very good but a little too loud. Would def return
joy
We had a reservation and were seated right away. The burgers were outstanding - perfectly cooked, not greasy. Fries were crisp and delicious! LOVED my smoked old fashioned and all the fan fare that went along with it. Really attentive and very nice staff. Great date night!
robert
Loved the food and service but a bit too loud and was not given the table I requested with my reservation so was right under the speaker .. food good
Robert
Been here a few times and really could not take the music level. It used to be so loud you couldn't have a conversation at the table. This time the music level was normal. You could have a conversation at the table and you could think normally. Keep it like this and I'd come back. To loud, I will leave. thanks
Jennifer
Food service and atmosphere was great! 🫶🏼 🥳🫶🏼🫶🏼🫶🏼🥳🫶🏼🫶🏼🥳🫶🏼
Johnny Neutron
John the owner personally took care of our order. It was great and we will be coming back for more delicious food! Thank you!
Recommended dishes: Edison Burger, Atomic Burger and Fries, Truffle Mac and Cheese, Rainbow Cookie
Nelly S. (NBS)
Host was a little lost , she looked at us and didn’t know what to do , she was talking to the other staff at the bar while customers waiting at the door ! Waitress did better but overall not the best experience. Burgers were ok , 1 dessert can feed 4 people easy !
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Jamie Preziosa
Me and my boyfriend enjoyed an early Sunday dinner here and it was good. We were seated right away and the service was quick which was convenient because we were starving. He got the Genius burger with the short rib on top, medium and it was exactly cooked medium, he was happy with his burger. I got the Nashville hot chicken sandwich, I was not a fan, it was kind of bland/fried tasting, I didn’t eat the sandwich at all, however this place is called Burgerology so I should have got a burger. The fries were ok, the plating was cute. The Atmosphere was fun and our waitress was nice, I cant remember her name but she made us really good raspberry ice teas. I give this place a 4 out of 5, we will be coming back and I will try their burgers instead.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Tyler the Game Master
PLACE SUCKS!!! Takes forever to get your food! DO NOT GO! DEFINETELY DONT COME ON BINGO NIGHT!!! MUSIC IS WAYYY TO LOUD! I MIGHT END UP LEAVING HERE WIRH HEARING PROBLEMS!!! IVE WAITED A HALF HOUR JUST FOR A
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Michael Mccormack
Stopped in midweek and the place was empty. Took a while for the waitress to take our drink order then 20-30 minutes for the bartender to make them ( did I mention the place was empty?) After our drinks arrived the waitress walked away without asking for our food order so I needed to call her over while she was distracted on her phone. Noticed the menu has changed and the lamb burger was no longer on the menu, disappointed 8 ordered another burger. Our food arrived about 20 minutes later and all of the fries were cold. The manager overheard me and immediately swapped them for fresh fries. While still eating the waitress took my drink which I had yet to finish. I then needed to wait for a drink replacement. We finished out meals and while the dishes were still on the table the waitress asked if we wanted dessert. We ordered dessert and patiently waited for the table to be cleared. Again the waitress was distracted on her phone. I have always enjoyed Burgerolgy but I will say this is the last time I am dining here.
Went in for brunch with my husband and another couple. There were literally only three other tables occupied. Our cocktails were very good, but were brought out piecemeal. It would've been nice if we all had our drinks at the same time. We ordered appetizers, boneless wings and spinach and artichoke dip that were both mediocre. We specifically asked when we ordered the appetizers that there was ample time between getting the appetizers and getting our meal and of course that did not happen. We didn't have our appetizers for more than two minutes went out, came our meals. We told them to take it back to which the waitress told us that they were just going to sit in the back and we told them then we would not be paying for our meal. She wound up accommodating us. My burger was very good, cooked the way I wanted it, medium rare. Although there were only other three other occupied tables, our waiter never came over to check on us or to refill our water which we had to ask for multiple times. We did sit in the front in open air, which was very nice. We live in Farmingdale so we've been there several times and I will probably go back because the burgers are good, but they need to really improve the service. Honestly, the burgers are just as good at The Villager down the block so I definitely will think twice before going back.
We were a big group, of both kids and adults shared a couple appetizers, had entrees and shakes. Food was good and came out in a reasonable amount of time. Our waiter was awful though, missing drinks, did not check on us once to see if we needed anything when our food came out, my 10 year old flagged down another waiter to get a water and extra napkins. When we asked for our check, the waiter then went on to make drinks for other tables and disappeared in the kitchen. One of us had to go up to the bar to ask again for the check. We had a good time because it was trivia night, which we didn't know, but was a happy accident. However, the service really put a damper on things. Especially when it hit 8:30 and we had tired kiddos, while we waited for the check.
Great night out. Food and service were both excellent and the brownie sundae was the perfect ending.
Liked the place very much, great service , delicious food. A bit too noisy For me but would def go back
Food was great ) I had their wings and fries with truffle sauce. Very good. Service very good but a little too loud. Would def return
We had a reservation and were seated right away. The burgers were outstanding - perfectly cooked, not greasy. Fries were crisp and delicious! LOVED my smoked old fashioned and all the fan fare that went along with it. Really attentive and very nice staff. Great date night!
Loved the food and service but a bit too loud and was not given the table I requested with my reservation so was right under the speaker .. food good
Been here a few times and really could not take the music level. It used to be so loud you couldn't have a conversation at the table. This time the music level was normal. You could have a conversation at the table and you could think normally. Keep it like this and I'd come back. To loud, I will leave. thanks
Food service and atmosphere was great! 🫶🏼 🥳🫶🏼🫶🏼🫶🏼🥳🫶🏼🫶🏼🥳🫶🏼
John the owner personally took care of our order. It was great and we will be coming back for more delicious food! Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
The food was amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Edison Burger, Atomic Burger and Fries, Truffle Mac and Cheese, Rainbow Cookie
Host was a little lost , she looked at us and didn’t know what to do , she was talking to the other staff at the bar while customers waiting at the door ! Waitress did better but overall not the best experience.
Burgers were ok , 1 dessert can feed 4 people easy !
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Me and my boyfriend enjoyed an early Sunday dinner here and it was good. We were seated right away and the service was quick which was convenient because we were starving. He got the Genius burger with the short rib on top, medium and it was exactly cooked medium, he was happy with his burger. I got the Nashville hot chicken sandwich, I was not a fan, it was kind of bland/fried tasting, I didn’t eat the sandwich at all, however this place is called Burgerology so I should have got a burger. The fries were ok, the plating was cute. The Atmosphere was fun and our waitress was nice, I cant remember her name but she made us really good raspberry ice teas. I give this place a 4 out of 5, we will be coming back and I will try their burgers instead.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
PLACE SUCKS!!! Takes forever to get your food! DO NOT GO! DEFINETELY DONT COME ON BINGO NIGHT!!! MUSIC IS WAYYY TO LOUD! I MIGHT END UP LEAVING HERE WIRH HEARING PROBLEMS!!! IVE WAITED A HALF HOUR JUST FOR A
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Stopped in midweek and the place was empty. Took a while for the waitress to take our drink order then 20-30 minutes for the bartender to make them ( did I mention the place was empty?) After our drinks arrived the waitress walked away without asking for our food order so I needed to call her over while she was distracted on her phone. Noticed the menu has changed and the lamb burger was no longer on the menu, disappointed 8 ordered another burger. Our food arrived about 20 minutes later and all of the fries were cold. The manager overheard me and immediately swapped them for fresh fries. While still eating the waitress took my drink which I had yet to finish. I then needed to wait for a drink replacement. We finished out meals and while the dishes were still on the table the waitress asked if we wanted dessert. We ordered dessert and patiently waited for the table to be cleared. Again the waitress was distracted on her phone. I have always enjoyed Burgerolgy but I will say this is the last time I am dining here.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Loading...