50 cent wings are really good. Great deal on a monday
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Samantha C.
Bring back the mussels!!!! A quick stop at Croxley's for wings before heading home from the Harry Potter pop up and my old stomping grounds, Farmingdale. As long as they keep Hoegaarden in house (I believe it's actually on tap), I will always be a fan. Their wings have stayed pretty consistent and trying the medium honey sauce for the first time did not disappoint. My only critique is I wish the wings were slightly bigger. They are super crispy and delicious, but on the small side. I guess I'll just eat more of them. Unknowingly, or outing was on the same day as the Farmingdale St. Patrick's day parade. And even though all spot on Main Street were hopping, we were able to be seated quickly with our wing, fries and beer brought out to us shortly after we were brought to our table. Always love coming back here and it's a great anchor for Main Street. Yay, Croxleys!
Doreen L.
Beware their serving sizes! They mark certain beers as 33cl or 25cl. When you look at the ounce conversion, a 33cl beer should be just a smidge over 11 ounces. However, they are serving almost $10 sour beers in these Bourbon County glasses (and not filling them to the top) and they're technically 10 ounce glasses (just search these same glasses online). So that means that you (and me) are paying full price for a beer that should be 11 ounces but you're really getting about 9 ounces. Just another example of how businesses like this one think you're a fool who doesn't know basic math. Edit: To answer the manager's comments, we ordered the Volcano Sauce sour which was a 33cl on the menu. So, unfortunately, it was poured in the wrong glass. Next time I'll be sure to bring it to the bartender's attention. Glad to hear it wasn't intentional.
Fred “Trigger” Truglio
I don't know cause it was a closed b-day present &I hate my family mostly
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Croxley's Burger
Renee B.
Chicken wings and sweet potato fries were yummy. I will be back to try other things on
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Classic Wings
Darren P.
I am so upset. Been a regular not just a customer since long before farmingdale opened and Rockville center I was there on opening day and before that we went to the new Hyde park location. To see that they are ok with management igorning a guest. Even on a busy day like Super Bowl just is sad. I chose them when I could have chosen so many other places. But I have a history with them and had high hopes. They let us down. I made clear when I called (2xs) to make RSVPS as well typed it in when I bought tickets for their superbowl online in where we wanted and always sit in a specific end spot at the bar "facing the TV's" as we did for many years. Instead when we walked in, we saw people sitting in our spots I told the hostess our deal. She said I will bring the manager over and she never did. We had to sit in the corner facing the back of the restaurant with a bad side view of the one TV! After sitting there the whole game I come to realize that we were pushed out of the seats we asked for as the bartenders (that I've never met before) put their friends in our seats. I called the manger kim (who I spoke to the 2 times before prior of purchasing tickets) the next day and told her what happened. She didn't seem to care or do anything about trying to make it right. I actually had to ask if there was anything they can do and give us our money back. She said I'll get back to you. A few days later she called me and she said she spoke with the owners and all they can do is have a $20 gift card for me and I have to come in and get it. (No thank you) Lastly the add stated food would be out at 6:30 till end of game. They cleared the food out around the end of 3rd quarter just to put out "2 desserts" never again. I know they are so big now and don't really care no more, but I remember when the 2 owners cared for us customers. Now you lost us !
The chicken wings used to be good here. Not sure what happened but they tasted awful and obviously like frozen. The sauces for the wings were just bad. Trust me we tried a few and it kept getting worse
MrZippo
Great food. Nice place to go for a date or just hang with old friends.
Try the wings with some sauce sauce... I almost licked the plate lol... Chubby girl here knows what's up .. you won't
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
steven mattocks
This is a GREAT place to watch any sporting event. Definitely the home of Islander fans. They're very accommodating on putting on games for you, you just need to speak up and ask. Of course the wings are the star of the show here. But their other dishes like Burgers (Beef or Turkey). I've had their Skirt steak which is just as good as a Steak house. And though prices have jumped Post-Covid, this place has reasonable prices.Parking: This area has a lot of restaurants, so there is Paid parking on the street and parking lot. They start charging between 5pm - 1AM. So if there's a 1PM game, you won't have to worry about paying.
Beer selection - AWings - ABurger - B+4 star rating because they seemed be short staffed.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Wings, Croxley's Burger
Mel T.
the best bone-in buffalo wings i've ever had!! the tots were good too. sangria was solid. clean restaurant and honestly pretty spacious and big. it was clean, esp the bathrooms which is nice. kinda weird they checked our IDs and scanned them before we could sit at a table and eat on a dead monday night at 8. waitress was great good service
Dave the manager is amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Wings, Irish Nachos
Ribs were not fall off the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
50 cent wings are really good. Great deal on a monday
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Bring back the mussels!!!! A quick stop at Croxley's for wings before heading home from the Harry Potter pop up and my old stomping grounds, Farmingdale. As long as they keep Hoegaarden in house (I believe it's actually on tap), I will always be a fan. Their wings have stayed pretty consistent and trying the medium honey sauce for the first time did not disappoint. My only critique is I wish the wings were slightly bigger. They are super crispy and delicious, but on the small side. I guess I'll just eat more of them. Unknowingly, or outing was on the same day as the Farmingdale St. Patrick's day parade. And even though all spot on Main Street were hopping, we were able to be seated quickly with our wing, fries and beer brought out to us shortly after we were brought to our table. Always love coming back here and it's a great anchor for Main Street. Yay, Croxleys!
Beware their serving sizes! They mark certain beers as 33cl or 25cl. When you look at the ounce conversion, a 33cl beer should be just a smidge over 11 ounces. However, they are serving almost $10 sour beers in these Bourbon County glasses (and not filling them to the top) and they're technically 10 ounce glasses (just search these same glasses online). So that means that you (and me) are paying full price for a beer that should be 11 ounces but you're really getting about 9 ounces. Just another example of how businesses like this one think you're a fool who doesn't know basic math. Edit: To answer the manager's comments, we ordered the Volcano Sauce sour which was a 33cl on the menu. So, unfortunately, it was poured in the wrong glass. Next time I'll be sure to bring it to the bartender's attention. Glad to hear it wasn't intentional.
I don't know cause it was a closed b-day present &I hate my family mostly
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Croxley's Burger
Chicken wings and sweet potato fries were yummy. I will be back to try other things on
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Classic Wings
I am so upset. Been a regular not just a customer since long before farmingdale opened and Rockville center I was there on opening day and before that we went to the new Hyde park location. To see that they are ok with management igorning a guest. Even on a busy day like Super Bowl just is sad. I chose them when I could have chosen so many other places. But I have a history with them and had high hopes. They let us down. I made clear when I called (2xs) to make RSVPS as well typed it in when I bought tickets for their superbowl online in where we wanted and always sit in a specific end spot at the bar "facing the TV's" as we did for many years. Instead when we walked in, we saw people sitting in our spots I told the hostess our deal. She said I will bring the manager over and she never did. We had to sit in the corner facing the back of the restaurant with a bad side view of the one TV! After sitting there the whole game I come to realize that we were pushed out of the seats we asked for as the bartenders (that I've never met before) put their friends in our seats. I called the manger kim (who I spoke to the 2 times before prior of purchasing tickets) the next day and told her what happened. She didn't seem to care or do anything about trying to make it right. I actually had to ask if there was anything they can do and give us our money back. She said I'll get back to you. A few days later she called me and she said she spoke with the owners and all they can do is have a $20 gift card for me and I have to come in and get it. (No thank you) Lastly the add stated food would be out at 6:30 till end of game. They cleared the food out around the end of 3rd quarter just to put out "2 desserts" never again. I know they are so big now and don't really care no more, but I remember when the 2 owners cared for us customers. Now you lost us !
The chicken wings used to be good here. Not sure what happened but they tasted awful and obviously like frozen. The sauces for the wings were just bad. Trust me we tried a few and it kept getting worse
Great food. Nice place to go for a date or just hang with old friends.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Try the wings with some sauce sauce... I almost licked the plate lol... Chubby girl here knows what's up .. you won't
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is a GREAT place to watch any sporting event. Definitely the home of Islander fans. They're very accommodating on putting on games for you, you just need to speak up and ask. Of course the wings are the star of the show here. But their other dishes like Burgers (Beef or Turkey). I've had their Skirt steak which is just as good as a Steak house. And though prices have jumped Post-Covid, this place has reasonable prices.Parking: This area has a lot of restaurants, so there is Paid parking on the street and parking lot. They start charging between 5pm - 1AM. So if there's a 1PM game, you won't have to worry about paying.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Wings, Jumbo Bavarian Pretzel, Croxley's Burger
Very welcoming vibes, great selection on
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Beer selection - AWings - ABurger - B+4 star rating because they seemed be short staffed.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Wings, Croxley's Burger
the best bone-in buffalo wings i've ever had!! the tots were good too. sangria was solid. clean restaurant and honestly pretty spacious and big. it was clean, esp the bathrooms which is nice. kinda weird they checked our IDs and scanned them before we could sit at a table and eat on a dead monday night at 8. waitress was great good service