Food was very good. I have gone to Croxley's many times for brunch and brunch is always good. I now wanted to try dinner and didn't disappoint. Definitely going back again.
Kristina
Servers were very attentive to our party of 7. The food was delicious. Everyone was very happy with their meal choice. Definitely recommend going on taco Tuesday. We tried all three tacos and they were amazing. Will definitely be going back again.
Marilyn
We were a family group with 3 young children and 3 adults. Everyone enjoyed their meal - mostly burgers. Our server was very good and attentive. We were there at 2 pm on a Thursday and there was a pretty good crowd. Overall we had a very good experience.
went here for father's day at my husband's request. Service was great and food did not take long to come out. The wings were great. The waffle fries were not all that. They provided crayons and coloring menus for my kids which I appreciated.
Good food. Great service. 8 people seated comfortably indoors for a noon reservation. Loved having walls openers up for fresh air from adjacent small outdoor seating area. Not too crowded at noon, which was nice.
E Mister
We had my daughter’s bridal party in the Garden Room. It was such a beautiful venue. Everyone raved about how nice it was. The food and service was great. I cannot say enough. There are private bathrooms. The room is spacious. We had 50 people with plenty of room to walk around. The sound system was great and party packages affordable. I would recommend 100%.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
ERIN Mc
We had my daughter’s bridal party in the Garden Room. It was such a beautiful venue. Everyone raved about how nice it was. The food and service was great. I cannot say enough. There are private bathrooms. The room is spacious. We had 50 people with plenty of room to walk around. The sound system was great and party packages affordable. I would recommend 100%.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pro DJ Productions & Photo Booths
A super cool room to have a party in. Clean and well decorated. Really cool retractable roof. Amazing wings. Great food!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The chicken wings used to be good here. Not sure what happened but they tasted awful and obviously like frozen. The sauces for the wings were just bad. Trust me we tried a few and it kept getting worse
DccBPJJ
Food was terrible. The French onion soup was cold. The veggie burger was not even edible. It was not cooked right and the cheese was burnt. They replaced it with nachos but the queso on the nachos was literally lukewarm and flavorless. Overall you don't go there for the food Hard to talk because the noise level is so unbearable that you're shouting over each other 
First they wanted to put us in a corner where you can't see the tv's. They didn't want to move us! We had a reservation for 6 men at 7:00. What the heck did they think we wanted to do???? But the TV did t even have the local hockey game. Instead they had 2 teams from another area! We ordered wings. The main portion was supposed to be put under crisper and the other smaller order regular. They can put opposite of what we ordered. I had to ask 3x for a frosted mug! We had to ask multiple times for napkins and water! The food was nothing special by far. Your basic burgers or French dip. My dip was dry and not very good. They can do a lot better!
George Andriopoulos
Not my typical scene but I’ve never really been disappointed here. Good drinks, good food. A little crowded at times but that’s probably the old man in me talking. A definite win for Farmingdale.
How do you run out of a craft beer on a Thursday? The food and decor are mediocre at best and the menu hasn't changed since it opened. The only positives are beer and outdoor seating.
Two of Us Event Planners
Our clients love the private event space “The Garden” A stand alone venue with natural light ceiling & an additional loft area. GREAT for ALL occasions!
Addison
Good place to hang if you don’t mind noisy and congestion.
Food was very good. I have gone to Croxley's many times for brunch and brunch is always good. I now wanted to try dinner and didn't disappoint. Definitely going back again.
Servers were very attentive to our party of 7. The food was delicious. Everyone was very happy with their meal choice. Definitely recommend going on taco Tuesday. We tried all three tacos and they were amazing. Will definitely be going back again.
We were a family group with 3 young children and 3 adults. Everyone enjoyed their meal - mostly burgers. Our server was very good and attentive. We were there at 2 pm on a Thursday and there was a pretty good crowd. Overall we had a very good experience.
went here for father's day at my husband's request. Service was great and food did not take long to come out. The wings were great. The waffle fries were not all that. They provided crayons and coloring menus for my kids which I appreciated.
Good food. Great service. 8 people seated comfortably indoors for a noon reservation. Loved having walls openers up for fresh air from adjacent small outdoor seating area. Not too crowded at noon, which was nice.
We had my daughter’s bridal party in the Garden Room. It was such a beautiful venue. Everyone raved about how nice it was. The food and service was great. I cannot say enough. There are private bathrooms. The room is spacious. We had 50 people with plenty of room to walk around. The sound system was great and party packages affordable. I would recommend 100%.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had my daughter’s bridal party in the Garden Room. It was such a beautiful venue. Everyone raved about how nice it was. The food and service was great. I cannot say enough. There are private bathrooms. The room is spacious. We had 50 people with plenty of room to walk around. The sound system was great and party packages affordable. I would recommend 100%.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A super cool room to have a party in. Clean and well decorated. Really cool retractable roof. Amazing wings. Great food!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The chicken wings used to be good here. Not sure what happened but they tasted awful and obviously like frozen. The sauces for the wings were just bad. Trust me we tried a few and it kept getting worse
Food was terrible. The French onion soup was cold. The veggie burger was not even edible. It was not cooked right and the cheese was burnt. They replaced it with nachos but the queso on the nachos was literally lukewarm and flavorless. Overall you don't go there for the food Hard to talk because the noise level is so unbearable that you're shouting over each other 
Restaurantji Recommends
First they wanted to put us in a corner where you can't see the tv's. They didn't want to move us! We had a reservation for 6 men at 7:00. What the heck did they think we wanted to do???? But the TV did t even have the local hockey game. Instead they had 2 teams from another area! We ordered wings. The main portion was supposed to be put under crisper and the other smaller order regular. They can put opposite of what we ordered. I had to ask 3x for a frosted mug! We had to ask multiple times for napkins and water! The food was nothing special by far. Your basic burgers or French dip. My dip was dry and not very good. They can do a lot better!
Not my typical scene but I’ve never really been disappointed here. Good drinks, good food. A little crowded at times but that’s probably the old man in me talking. A definite win for Farmingdale.
How do you run out of a craft beer on a Thursday? The food and decor are mediocre at best and the menu hasn't changed since it opened. The only positives are beer and outdoor seating.
Our clients love the private event space “The Garden” A stand alone venue with natural light ceiling & an additional loft area. GREAT for ALL occasions!
Good place to hang if you don’t mind noisy and congestion.
Loading...