Farmingdale Pizza & Pasta

We love this place. I'm vegan and my husband is non-vegan and we've been coming here for about 3 years. They mostly serve vegan dishes but have a large selection of meat dishes. We love their peanut butter bomb cake AND the best part is, it's vegan but, like my husband says, "it doesn't taste like it." Also, all the food portions including the dessert & appetizers are not skimpy. However, this last time, my husband was a little disappointed with the food especially when they forgot part of his meal, that is, until we asked about it. ...but, they went out of their way to quickly make it right plus, they're always so very friendly and accommodating. We still rated the food at the highest stars possible because, we've always enjoyed everything we've ever eaten from here AND, this last experience was the first time it was out of the norm. Updated from previous review on 2026-02-19

As of 11/26/25 closed mon and tuesday.

They have a separate vegan menu with many options. The food is delicious. There is a regular menu for non vegans. We were the only ones eating lunch. Many take food out. There was a problem with the electronic paying system which delayed our leaving by at least 10 min. They couldn't get it to work. They suggested we go to an ATM to get cash to pay the bill which didn't make us happy. We ended up pooling our money together. This soured us on going back again.

Great portions and lots of great options. There are not a lot of vegan Italian-American spots in eastern Long Island but this is the closest one besides Pazzo Pizzeria and it really hits. Also prices are decent depending on what you order.

Vegan menu ask for it. Lots of premade pizza choices on display clearly marked. I loved their other sit down location south shore went offline. This one is great folks but the parking here is uggh. Ok appetizers all tasty, love their trio option to pick and choose. Heroes and clone and burger good stuff. All your Italiano entrees made vegan are spectacular. Pizzas lot of menu choices, your call. All awesome. They get the full 5 stars but the cow say only for fully vegan. Hey don't miss this place. The one sister store in Rockville on sunrise hwy is a take out only so co.w to Farmingdale if eating in. Desserts are listed on the counter of what's available. Good options here. Choco bomb it.

 This place has an extensive vegan menu with all of your favorite Italian dishes veganized and ginormous portions. I am in town on business and was looking for a vegan friendly option on Uber eats. This hit all the high marks. The food was delicious.

I visited a few years ago and they had many vegan options. The food we had was delicious.

Delicious

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

One of my favorite vegan places on Long Island. It is so convenient and delicious every time go here every time I’m in Farmingdale had most of the pizza flavors. All good and the brunch menu delicious!!! The portion sizes are great as well. 

Best pizza I have had in a long time. Highly reccomended!

Soggy dough made by transphobes.

absolutely terrible when it comes to accommodating for allergies. Also, transphobes suck.

Ah, 3 Brothers Pizza Cafe! Let me take you on a journey down memory lane, back to the beginnings of my vegan odyssey, where this quirky little pizzeria stood as a beacon of hope in a sea of cheese-covered despair. Picture it: a bustling street corner, the scent of marinara wafting through the air like a siren's call, and there it was, 3 Brothers Pizza Cafe, standing proud and unassuming, like a wise old sage in the world of plant-based delights. From the moment I crossed the threshold, I knew I was in for a treat. The separate vegan menu beckoned like a treasure map, promising culinary delights beyond my wildest dreams. Brunch, lunch, dinner, desserts—no mealtime was left unturned in their quest to satisfy even the most discerning herbivore. And oh, the desserts! Don't even get me started on the heavenly creations sourced straight from Vegan Treats. Each bite was a symphony of flavors, a testament to the power of cruelty-free indulgence. From decadent cakes to tantalizing pastries, it was a dessert lover's paradise. But perhaps what truly set 3 Brothers apart was the personal touch. Despite the passage of time, the owner still recognized me, a testament to the enduring bond forged over countless meals shared in vegan bliss. It was like coming home to family, if your family happened to serve up mouthwatering plant-based fare with a side of nostalgia. Of course, no establishment is without its quirks, and 3 Brothers was no exception. While the menu remained a stalwart bastion of vegan delights, there was a distinct lack of innovation when it came to shaking up one's taste buds. It's like they found the recipe for success and stuck to it like glue, leaving us hungry adventurers yearning for a taste of the unknown. Then there were the whispers, the rumors swirling around like cheese in a calzone. Harassment allegations among the female staff cast a shadow over the otherwise sunny ambiance, a reminder that even the most beloved eateries are not immune to the darker side of human nature. And let's not forget the elephant in the room—or should I say, the appetizer prices. While I'm all for supporting local businesses and sustainable practices, shelling out an arm and a leg for a plate of hummus and veggies felt like highway robbery in broad daylight. A minor gripe, perhaps, but one that left a bitter taste in the mouth nonetheless.

Used to come here all the time. Haven’t been here in probably 5 or so years. Eggplant rollatini dinner was good.

Very tasty food. Good amount of food given. Eggplant rollatini is excellent. Also loved the cauliflower steak. Updated from previous review on 2023-04-27