Goodfellas Pizzeria & Deli

55 Central Ave # Q, Farmingdale
(631) 293-7533

Recent Reviews

Serena Woods

All the Soups of the day are my favorite. Nice variety of food.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

beth bedics

Excellent heroes . Potato salad was delicious.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: The Bogey

el grone ny

Really good deli , they have everything you need for your breakfast lunch or dinner ???

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

ERNEST ISIP

I ordered a breakfast sandwich egg, ham, on a roll with ketchup and pepper. It took them ten minutes to get my meal. I had to ask what is taking so long...I have to go to work. Finally got it. I'm not going back there again.

ROBERT GREENE

There is a great variety of food at this restaurant.Parking: It can be difficult if your driving a large vehicle.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Balkaran Singh

I went around 2:30pm and they didn’t have much, it almost seemed like they were about to close

Mindy M.

Goodfellas Pizza and Deli 3 1/2 stars. Ok so I did not get Pizza so I cant say for more though they looked good. They had a few hot dishes in trays at front as well , one with chicken and tomatoes that the customer next to me had decided upon. I stopped here looking for a business. I ordered a sandwich that was set up on behind the counter and looked yummy with toasted bread and meats. The Deli man was good and asked what and how I'd like it adding onion, lettuce and mayo. The location is in what I want to say is a business district area with many trucks and allotted buildings. It is near Farmingdale College and also their school of Aviation as I saw small planes flying over head. It does have (see pix) out door seating which consist of 2 round tables and chairs of where on this sunny day I sat to eat my food. There is an outside sign in front noting coffee. The prices seem fair and they do take credit and debit cards - with no extra fee attached. I lady behind the counter got me upon request, what turned out to be a fresh chocolate chip muffin. I also bought a small rice pudding that looks delicious. Its actually a spot kinda on the side lines spot that I think is worth stopping at for food.

Money M.

Came here for pizza left with a lasting impression of the finest food establishments on Long Island. Everything was fire and valid prices . Papi in the back was chefing up. Amel and Angie were very diligent . Got the margherita slice with hot sauce. Plus they have plethora of hot food options as soon as doors open. Come here and say Money sent you. They will hook you up regardless though.

Sebastian G.

Amel and angie were absolute dolls! Great service smile on their face! Great recommendations. 10/10 recommend the chicken quesadillas and the margarita pizza. Will deff be returning. Key eye for details and cute center pieces at each table.

Warda Ahmed

I thought it was a pizzeria, but they have pizza and a buffet almost inside. The pizza was ok but I felt uncomfortable eating it bc they asked if I wanted marinara with my knots, ofc I said yes, but they gave me the sauce their buffet meatballs were sitting in. I only eat halal and it made me wonder if the marinara on the pizza had meat in it. Will not be returning.

Scar Scar (Scar)

Good food, terrible customer service/delivery.I work in the area and I usually order a couple of times per week but lately the delivery time is terrible.More than 2 hours or the delivery guy goes to the wrong address.If you call for a pick up it’s never ready when you get there.Food taste is really good but the service must improve.Whoever is in charge should take care of this.

Thomas M.

Don't go here. Incompetent staff, they constantly forget orders and by the time they get it right, your food is cold.

JOJO PETERS

Fresh pizza ?, numerous drink selections, clean establishment

Susana Fernandez

Delicious food and breakfast.

radamex velasquez

Great sandwiches

Load More