Harleys American Grille

283 Main St, Farmingdale
(516) 586-8000

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Dr. Adam

Excellent in every way, the hostess and manager went out of their way to accommodate us when we arrived, and everything was amazing!

Barbara

Unfortunately it is extremely noisy so it's difficult to have a conversation. We were sitting in the back next to the door which was better than up front. I have to say that the DJ was very good! The staff were very attentive. The noise level was a big distraction. My steak sandwich was delicious!

Jamie

Extremely loud, poor service was there 3 hours. And had to send back food that was too well done

Judy

Food, drinks amd service was excellent! Our server waaJesse and he made the dining experience just wonderful!

Steven

Not sure if I went to Harley's Grille or Harley's Studio 54. Not the place to bring your family for a nice steak. Can't hear a word. Music blaring. People dancing over your table. Vaping. Cursing. Funny to read the previous comment about the manager not caring. We've experienced that on a previous visit. Why bother asking a question if you're not going to stick around for an answer. Just a terrible dining experience all around.

Sal

Have eaten at Harleys including New Yesrs Eve. Food has not only become more expensive but quality hasn't been as good. A simple wind by the glass was terrible. At these prices a better than $6 dollar bottle selling half glasses at $14 should be better quality. Just average food, maybe a new chef. Service was OK, training was going on as usual. When the wine wasn't to my wife's past experiences I got up from our table and brought it back to the bar tender, our waitress wasn't around. The manager came by with the obligatory how us everything and didn't wait for our response. Maybe a bad night.

Chris

It's average restaurant, I have better expectations but it was nothing special with food and it pricey as well.

Kelly

Harley's is a regular for my fiancée and I. This was the first time we went for brunch and food was amazing and portions great as well. Service is always top tier.

Richard

We have eaten here in the past and thought we would give it another try even though we weren't that impressed the first time. The noise level was so loud my wife and I could hardly hear each other from across the table and surprisingly it wasn't totally booked at the time. I ordered the short rib which was very good although a bit pricey for what you received but reasonable. My wife ordered the steak frites which was $44 and the steak was very fatty and had gristle and was a small portion for the price. Drinks were well made but mine was forgotten and had to ask the server who had to go to the bar and ask for them to make it. We are locals but with all the options on Main St. you can be sure we will not be back for the third try.

Lauren

When looking for a great Friday night spot to celebrate my birthday my friends asked the bad moms group on Facebook and Harleys came up multiple times. It did not disappoint. Food was delicious, we had spinach dip appetizer with fresh chips, bang bang shrimp, braised short ribs, one of the chicken dishes & steak sandwich. No one had any complaints. It was perfect. Our waiter was awesome. Super friendly and fun. I called him the mayor of Harleys. The DJ played the best music. Dancing was a little tight and not so courteous people on it so we ended up outside but it was a beautiful night. Convenient parking with back entrance too. Lovely wall for photo ops in back.

Kathy

We had the best steak (prime bone in ribeye) prepared to perfection. Ty our waiter was awesome. Informative and gave us good advice on what he thought would make us happy. Great bottle of wine to with our lovely steak meal.. Colleen Clemons 21 pinot noir out of OR. DELISH It was very loud, but it was a Friday night of the Ryder Cup so pretty much expected. I would return to have another deliciously prepared prime steak anytime 👍 Kudos to the kitchen staff.

Inga

Love coming to Harley's. Always consistent, amazing food, drinks and vibes. Cant wait to go back

Patti

We really enjoyed our dinner at Harleys. The food, service and atmosphere was great. Looking forward to the next time.

Dukens

Overall, this place was awesome. From the entryway from the parking lot, there's a nice selfie backdrop with the Harley Glow. That was a nice touch. Then, we we proceeded to check in. Having a reservation, we were seated immediately. The place is clean. Visually appealing, a very beautiful setting overall. Our service was outstanding. The drinks were great. The food was amazing. Great portion size for the price. Appetizers were on point. I love the fact that the live Dj was hitting all the nice oldies. I think it's a genius idea the way the restaurant is partitioned. I selected the standard dining. From our table, we got to enjoy all the good music (privately). Meanwhile, if you're seated on the other side by the bar, there's disco lights. Guests dancing and vibing on the side. Therefore, depending on where you're seated, two parties could be at Harleys at the same time while completely having a different experience. I truly like that aspect of the setting. In conclusion, we had a wonderful family time there. My wife and I are hopeful to return on a date night. Just be mindful that the municipal parking in the back is not free. The meters are 0.75 cents per Hr FYI.

Donna

The food tonight was spectacular! There were 6 of us and everyone loved their meals!! The smash burger was the best our friends every had, the Philillie French Dip Sandwich was delicious tender, perfectly cooked and the dipping sauce was perfect. The Lobster pasta dish other friends had they loved. The truffle fries are the best - crispy and the sauce drizzled on top was so good. It was Music on Main night so we ate outside and it was great. Service was excellent!! I will have to give a half a minus because they did not have Drambuie. So I couldn't get my Rusty Nail - since it has such a nice bar that we love I find it strange that if you run out of a liquor there are no back ups!!! That they could do better with but their food is amazing and I love this menu!

Loading...