Main Street Italian Eatery

302 Main St, Farmingdale
(516) 777-3600

Recent Reviews

Sort by
N-dricks Saint Louis

Walk in there, waiting for some to help me with my order, they just walking around made eye contact with me say nothing to me then they go and help people that walk in after me.

Craig Kearns

Place was great when the old restaurant manager John was there. He recently left and the place went to garbage. I won’t be going back.

Failbaddon The Armless

Excellent calzone. Crust was great and they don't skimp on the filling.

Kayla Moore

Came and got a slice to go didn’t give me napkins and didn’t ask if I wanted any seasonings . Kinda rude …

Diana Lopez

Pizza is delish, friendly. This week they have Pumpkin Cheesecake..yummy ?

Alison Abeles

Consistently delicious food! Dinners and pizza are fantastic! Our whole family loves them.

rob castaldo

I wanted to like this place , but they have cancelled 2 orders on me in a matter of a couple of months. Both times nowhere near closing. Other times trying to get some of there special pies they could not make them cause they didn't have certain ingredients, but they call you back over a hour later to tell you.Food actually is good but I have been getting poor service.

Ryan Grella

The Alice in Wonderland experience was top notch and so was the food and drinks! The actors, and staff were all fantastic and we had a great time! Can't wait to see what they do for Halloween!

Tom Kelly

Friendly, good pizza. Not many selections of pizza when only grabbing a slice. Restaurant seems to have parties frequently, a good sign of business health.

Phil W

Great experience at their pop-up restaurant. The wonder. Kids really loved it and entertainment was great. Highly recommend as the food as well was excellent

nick santangelo

Absolutely amazing ? perfect food drinks great friendly staff Tyler out did himself the Grinch made my night excellent experience as a pop of Christmas event definitely recommended

pj l

the risotto balls with vodka sauce are ridiculously good!!! wow we are def coming back. also got the chicken cutlet mozz stick vodka sauce heroes and they were amazing too. love this place

julia grygoruk

really bad experience. hocus pocus pop up event was really bad. too expensive for what it was worth. way overpriced. too bland of food. drinks were good. but nothing of a show. their wasn’t any performance that showed anything.

Aron Polyak

Went here for a pop up. It was horrible, they clearly use the illusion of influencers to make their garbage food and garbage venue look good. Don't give this place any piece of mind as you will leave disappointed. You will find better food at an applebees.

jenna aenlle

The staff was great and the show was fun but I just think it was way too overpriced for what you got. The food wasn’t great either. The $25 fee for entry and on top of that insanely expensive food

Loading...