Stuff A Bagel University

1253 Melville Rd, Farmingdale
(631) 249-4981

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Lucy Sow

I ordered breakfast sandwiches and a juice i asked for a cup the old guy wanted to charge me 1.00 for a cup unbelievable i also noticed college students ordering and he was very rude to them NOT OK get it together

Food: 2

Service: 2

Kenny

The lox portions are laughable. This is supposed to be a lox bagel. Barely any fish.

They do not have capers which is a disappointment.

But! The actual bagel is soft and fresh.

The cream cheese is a bit bland.

They have a “make your own iced coffee bar” which I despise.

Won’t be back.

Biggie Azalea

i usually get a turkey bacon egg and cheese with extra mayo, i would get exactly what i ordered but after a while i would get less mayo but last time i got it there wasn't any mayo and the turkey bacon wasn't proper cooked resulting in me getting sick.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Spillit ent

Stuffed omlette is amazing

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Juhi Gurtata

This establishment has gone downhill. I support local businesses but the prices and rudeness from the staff is not justified for me to come here any longer. I bought 6 bagels with a side of cream cheese for the family and paid $24. I asked for the receipt to be put in the bag but they never did. I called back the following day asking for the itemized prices just to know how much I was being charged and they refused to tell me over the phone. They hung up the phone on me THREE TIMES? On the fourth call, she says I'm not telling you the prices. Is this how you treat your local customers that support you to keep you in business? Very disheartened and will never spend another dollar here.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Christopher Wieman

Slowest service ever !

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Alex Novis

Love this place, I'm there any chance I can. Great prices, great staff, calm atmosphere. Definitely recommend if you go to FSC.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pancakes, Bagel with Butter, Mushroom Sausage Egg and Cheese, Pancakes 3 with Sausage

Nancy Cypser

This used to be a great bagel shop but the quality has dropped a lot. Buttered bagel was at least a day old with almost no butter. Coffee from the urn was lukewarm. Very few bagels to choose from. It seems like they are trying to sell the stale ones before baking any more. Seems to be new management and they are very confused getting rhe orders ready. Go to Stuff a bagel in town instead.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 2

Ricky Ricardo

I ordered 1 susauge egg and cheese and the 2 people that ordered after i did (at least 4 bacon egg and cheeses) got their food before i

Service: 1

Andy B

Wrong order constantly , going to another bagel

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Brian Cahill

I go here every Friday morning for a #5. An everything bagel with sausage, scrambled 5 American cheese. Always ?.

Kenneth Liao

Awesome little bagel cafe across from the college. They have a huge selection of stuff, but I always get a bacon, egg, and cheese. Sometimes the popular bagel flavors run out by the afternoon.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kelly B.

What is there to say about this place that you don't already know? They have awesome bagels and have had awesome bagels for the past bajillion years. I recommend their egg everything bagel, and their bacon egg and cheese sandwich of course.If you're in a rush, I would recommend calling ahead to place your order that way you could just pick it up when you get there. I can't speak for any other lunch items since I always only get breakfast here, but I'm sure it's awesome. The cream cheese is always fresh as well from my experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bagel with Butter

Kyle Krauss

The owners are incompetent, they gave me all the wrong food, and the prices are outrageous. Will never step back in that establishment for as long as i live.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Renz Nikka De Gula

I love this place! Their breakfast sandwiches are great, and the muffins are my favorite thing to get there. The only negative thing I experienced was that I had placed a pickup order and they didn't see it until I came in 20 minutes later so I had to wait a bit more until they made it.

Loading...