The Melting Pot

2377 Broadhollow Rd, Farmingdale
(631) 752-4242

Recent Reviews

Sort by
samantha

The ambiance was perfect for a date & celebration for a couple of. The food was delicious. The service was excellent, attentive, and friendly. Our server was perfect. The manager greeted us and checked in to see if there was anything we needed and he was just outstanding, also. Another great night out at one of our favorite restaurants that is designated for special occasions.

Miriam

We had a wonderful night. The staff was friendly and very accommodating. Manager Kevin made a few appearances to make sure we were having a great time. Ty for trying so hard to make my daughters celebration special!

michael

Excellent food, excellent service.....Tyler, our waiter came to our table many times to make sure everything was ok and if we needed anything. Andre, the manager, also checked on us at least two times

Juliana

Couple rough patches, initially they forgot that we had reserved for Thursdate, however they told us the hostess was new so we were understanding and they set up a new table for us that was very nice. My boyfriend found a fruit fly in his wine, but they gave him a new over poured glass and gave us a $25 off discount for all the troubles. Great experience overall and our waitress was extremely nice and understanding!

Jessica

One of our favorite restaurants. The food is delicious. Drinks are fantastic. Experience is amazing. Service is outstanding. Kids and parents are all happy. And safe for celiacs is a bonus.

David

Another wonderful evening at The Melting Pot. As devoted fans of the Fiesta Cheddar fondue, we tried a new cheese- the Hot Honey Alpine fondue, which is now our new favorite! The steak lovers fondue was awesome as always and the 24K Chocolate fondue was every bit as good as it sounds.

Marilyn

Our waitress Marie M. Was so amazing, she was so personable and very enthusiastic... she explained everything in great detail and made our visit so rememberable.. Me and my date definitely look forward to coming back and requesting her as our server 😊. Thank you Marie for a wonderful night ❤️

Maureen

Excellent experience all around! Our server was phenomenal and all courses were thoroughly enjoyed. Our table was a curved booth, which was exceptionally comfortable, but did make it difficult for all parties to reach both burners without standing up at times, particularly for the cheese and chocolate courses. The portions of the main course were adequate and all trimmings (vegetables, breads, dessert dunking items) were unlimited for the asking. My only complaint was the volume of cheeses and chocolates - for 4 people I think they could've been more generous and have been in the past. Absolutely delicious but definitely could have used more and these were not the expensive items like the main entrees. I'd go back in a heartbeat and highly recommend them - just would like a bit more cheese and chocolate next time.

Oscar

This was my first time at a fondue restaurant, and I had high hopes. We did the two-course experience (appetizer, salad, entrée, and dessert). The food tasted good, and the service was excellent—the staff was friendly and the place looked great. Unfortunately, the portion sizes were very small, and there were no sides like rice or fries to help make it a full meal. We left still feeling hungry. If the quantity of food had been just a bit more generous, I would have given five stars. Nice experience overall, but probably won't return due to the lack of food for the price. $184 for two people.

Jenn

We had a wonderful experience for my daughter's 11th birthday. She absolutely loves cooking her own food on the little grill and especially the chocolate at the end - I think they licked the pots clean lol. Great restaurant for a special occasion!

Gail

Food is still good, but overpriced. Husband and son got the 4 course meal. I did an add on of cheese and main course. Main course was $42. Very overpriced.

Anthony Pirrone

Awful drinks. Awful food. And u get to make it urself. I always like to go to dinner and have to cook my food myself. Ugh.

AdrieAnne Ragoonath

Always a nice time here!

Margie Cambian

Unbelievable!!!
Michael was professional in every way.
My daughter's birthday was an incredible experience.
Thank you so much!!!!
MCM

Hannah Brooke

Let’s start off with our waiter Marvin. He has the most amazing Customer Service skills and knows everything that you can know about this place. The food was nothing short of amazing and we got super full. Let’s talk about how good the cheese fondue was. also don’t forget Marvin is also the bartender and he makes amazing drinks. We got the passion Paloma and the lemon berry mojito. Please just take your time and come here. Me and my boyfriend are celebrating his graduation 💕💕💕💕💕From College and this really put the cherry on the top.

Loading...