Hilltop Bagel Cafe

623 Horseblock Road, Farmingville
(631) 846-1828

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

French Toast Bites with Nutella Banana & Strawberries
Best of Long Island 2021 Winning Acai Bowl
Fruity Pebble French Toast Bites
Small Fresh Chopped Salad
Breakfast Wrap
Macaroni Salad
Chicken Salad
Egg Sandwich
Dozen Bagels
Home Fries

Menu

Bagels and Rolls
Bagels and Add Ons
Dozen Bagels
12 - Variety subject to availability.
Dozen Kaiser Rolls
1/2 Dozen Bagels
6 - Variety subject to availability.
1/2 Dozen Kaiser Rolls

Bagel Sampler
Bagel Sampler
Freshly sliced assorted bagel thins with choice of 2 different cream cheeses.

Cream Cheese
Breakstone's Butter
8 oz.
1 LB Cream Cheese

Egg Sandwiches
2 Eggs on a Bagel/Roll
The Hungry Man
3 eggs on a hero with ham, sausage, bacon, choice of cheese.
Breakfast Wrap
3 eggs on a wrap with your choice of meat and cheese.

Specialty Egg Sandwiches
Philly Cheese Steak and Egg Hero
Steak, cheese, and caramelized onion sandwich.
Sausage, Egg & Cheese Hash Brown Slider
Egg, sausage and american cheese sandwiched between 2 crispy hash brown patties.
The Breakfast BLT
Your choice of egg scrambled, fried, over easy, over medium on Texas toast with bacon, lettuce and tomato.
The Breakfast Club
3 eggs served on a club roll with your choice of meat and cheese.
The Iron Man
2 eggs any style on a toasted garlic buttered roll, roast beef, caramelized onions and mozzarella cheese.
The Sweet and Savory
Your choice of meat and cheese on a donut.

Pancakes and French Toast and Bites
Berry Supreme Pancakes
Comes with 2 pancakes loaded with berries.
Chocolate Supreme Pancakes
Comes with 2 pancakes loaded with chocolate.
French Toast Bites
Choose your topping: granulated sugar, cinnamon sugar or confectionery sugar.
French Toast Bites with Nutella, Banana and Strawberries
French toast bites with nutella, banana and strawberries!
Fruity Pebble French Toast Bites
Your favorite french toast bites with confectionary sugar and fruity pebbles.
Pancakes
Comes with 2 pancakes.
French Toast
Comes with 2 thick slices of french toast.

Build Your Own Omelette
Build Your Own Omelette
Choose any 3 toppings. Comes with small OJ.

Breakfast Quesadilla
Breakfast Quesadilla
Comes with small OJ.
Western Breakfast Quesadilla
Comes with small OJ

Breakfast Tacos
Breakfast Taco
Pancake tortilla with your choice of ham, bacon or sausage omelet, lettuce, tomato and cheddar.
Dessert Taco
Pancake tortilla stuffed with bananas, strawberries, nutella and powdered sugar.

Oatmeal Bar
Oatmeal Bar
16 oz.

Coffee
Box of Joe
Includes cups, stir sticks, sweeteners and milk.
Hot Coffee
Iced Coffee

Breakfast Sides
Bacon
Ham
Home Fries
Loaded Home Fries
Sausage
Seasoned ground meat that has been wrapped in a casing.
Honey Sriracha Bacon

Fruits, Puddings and Parfaits
Banana
Berries and Berries
Mixed blueberries and strawberries.
Yogurt Parfait
Low-fat vanilla yogurt, granola, strawberries and blueberries.

Everything But The Bagel Seeds
Everything But The Bagel Seeds
1 lb. Choose from pretzel salt, natural sesame, fancy poppy, minced onion and everything seeds.

Specialty Heroes
Italian
Salami, pepperoni, ham, provolone, roasted peppers, onion, lettuce and tomato with oil and vinegar.
American
Ham, turkey, roast beef, American, Swiss, lettuce and tomato.
Montauk
Turkey, bacon, American, lettuce and tomato.
Philly Cheese Steak
Roast beef, sauteed onions and peppers with your choice of cheese.
Reuben
Hot corned beef, sauerkraut, melted Swiss with Russian dressing on grilled rye.
Reuben's Brother
Hot pastrami, sauerkraut, melted Swiss with Russian on grilled rye.
A la Richie
Ham, turkey, bacon, fresh mozzarella, lettuce and tomato with Russian dressing.
The Cordon Bleu
Chicken cutlet, ham, melted Swiss with honey mustard.
Mama's Meatballs
Homemade meatballs with marinara sauce and melted mozzarella.
The Hilltop
Grilled marinated chicken, fresh mozzarella, spinach and red roasted peppers with balsamic vinaigrette.

Lunch Sandwiches
BLT Lunch Sandwich
Bacon, lettuce and tomato on your choice of bread.
Chicken Salad Lunch Sandwich
Egg Salad Lunch Sandwich
A cold creamy sandwich made with chopped eggs, mayo, and seasoning.
Pizza Bagel
Boiled and baked round bread roll.
Tuna Salad Lunch Sandwich
Chilled creamy mild fish sandwich.

Hot Soup
Chicken Noodle Soup
16 oz. Includes your choice of buttered bagel
Chicken Rice Soup
16 oz. Includes your choice of buttered bagel.
Soup of the Day
Call 631-846-1828 to find out today's soup & put your choice in the special instructions box! 16 oz. Includes your choice of buttered bagel.

French Fries
Cheese Shoestring Fries
Loaded Shoestring Fries
Shoestring Fries

Boars Head Cold Cuts 1/2 lb.
1/2 lb. Boars Head Cheese
1/2 lb. Boars Head Meat

Boars Head Cold Cuts 1 lb.
1 lb. Boars Head Cheese
1 lb. Boars Head Meat

Side Salads By The 1 lb.
Chicken Salad
1 lb.
Egg Salad
1 lb.
Macaroni Salad
1 lb.
Potato Salad
1 lb.
Tuna Salad
1 lb.

Fresh Chopped Salads
Fresh Chopped Salads
Choose 3 toppings.

Acai Bowls
BEST OF LONG ISLAND 2021 WINNING ACAI BOWL
Delicious acai with granola, banana, strawberry, blueberry, coconut, and honey.

Bakery
Black and White Cookie
Croissant
Crumb Cake
Large Chocolate Chip Cookie
Muffin
Choose your muffin.

Desserts
Cheesecake
Chocolate Layer Cake
Strawberry Cheesecake

Eggs and Dairy
1 Dozen Eggs
International Delight Hazelnut Creamer
32 oz.
Paper Towel Roll
Toilet Paper Roll
Whole Milk 1/2 Gallon
International Delight French Vanilla Creamer
32 oz.

Beverages
Homemade Iced Tea
Pink Lemonade
Freshly Squeezed OJ
Small Orange Juice
Tropicana Cranberry Juice
15 oz.
Tropicana Apple Juice
15 oz.
Tropicana Orange Juice
12 oz.
Montauk Iced Tea
Snapple
Red Bull
8.4 oz. Choose your flavor.
Coke
20 oz.
Sprite
20 oz.
Diet Coke
20 oz.
Dr Brown Can
12 oz. Choose your flavor.
Yoohoo
Nesquik Chocolate Milk
Vita Coco Coconut Water
16.9 fl oz.
Hals Seltzer Original
Hals Seltzer Black Cherry
Poland Spring Small
Poland Spring Sport

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: facebook
+41 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+40 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I'm lucky enough to have Hilltop Bagel Cafe within minutes from my home but that's not I am giving it five stars. The food is excellent. Service is superior. Friendliest staff . They have so many options don't just stick with breakfast use them for lunch as well! The chopped salads are delicious. ? I have never been disappointed going to Hilltop. Nor will you.
July 2024
1st time to Long Island and we picked the perfect spot first try. Bagel sandwich (sausage, egg, cheese, home fries on everything bagel) was the best I have ever had. Kids loved their French toast bites with Nutella, strawberries and bananas. We all liked it so much we didn't even try another place the next morning, we just went right back!
July 2024
Love this place!!!We wanted to get some assorted bagels.We got a dozen and the gent behind the counter gave us 2 green bagels for the day!!They're also a full serve deli.It's no wonder they get voted the Best Of Long Island in so many categories!!
March 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Ralph's Italian Ices - 623 Horseblock Road
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Ice Cream
Chubs Burgers Burritos and Heroes - 625 Horseblock Road
Wraps, Burgers
Dunkin' - 628 Horseblock Road
Coffee Shops, Donuts, Coffee & Tea, Coffee

Hilltop Bagel Cafe

623 Horseblock Road, Farmingville, NY 11738
(631) 846-1828