Topper’s Ice Cream
643 Equestrian Ave, Fishers Island
(631) 788-7833
Recent Reviews
Sort by
643 Equestrian Ave, Fishers Island
(631) 788-7833
All the ice here is so good
$11 for a chocolate milkshake and it was made with all milk so it was basically a cold chocolate milk
It's ice cream! On a beautiful island ! With nice people serving it. Did I mention it's ice cream?
Great ice cream. Many choices. They even give samples to help you make up your mind. We will go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The ice cream is incredible!
Great place for a top dog!
Haven't ever been there but have a very good friend that lives on Fishers Island & LOVES the icecream ~ thanx to Johnio, the owner, I am able to give my friend gift certificate for "special occasions"❣️
Best spot for ice cream on the island. Great selection and amazing quality
Great place
Friendly family style ice cream shop on Fishers Island. A wonderful array of delicious ice cream flavors to choose from to take the edge off of any day!
Restaurantji Recommends
But way too many ice-cream-eating dogs in this place.
Ice cream??
i can say safely that toppers is amazing! truly a fishers classic!! Everyone there is so kind + caring!
(Translated by Google) Very. Well.(Original)Muy. Bueno.
Great ice cream for a good price.
Loading...