Mattingly's Tavern

16 N Main St, Florida
(845) 508-6675

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Javier Castellote

I stopped by on a week day for lunch and it was great. Real potato fries with my chicken sandwich uuuummh. Soo good. Loved it

Stephanie Barba

Kentucky Derby is always a fun day out! Everything you would expect from your local sports bar from quick bites to burgers, an array of thirst quenchers, music, sports and of course friends! Be sure to grab yourself some potato flats with the special seasoning ;)

Richard Citelli

I love Mattingly’s Tavern in Florida NY.
This is fun place with great people and food, lots of fun. On special days there are special drinks to match. It’s Derby Day and theres a Derby drink to match. Also many sporting events. Go Bills!!!
The Owner Tom Mattingly is a great person who really does care for the patrons.
They also have a Wine bar next door “Cork” stop in there to enjoy a variety of great wines. See ya there. RJC.

Jason Feinman

The owner and bartenders are great. Great wing specials, live music and more. Good food and drinks and a good price. Family atmosphere.

javi

Service is great

B E

Went here last night with my Wife for their Wing Night. Wings where terrific, came out fresh hot and just ight every time. The bartender (Jim?) was friendly and attentive. Everything was fantastic.

Derek Hadden

First time here, absolutely amazing food, and amazing service. The owner and the bartender are fantastic!

FulltimeRVers

Was traveling through the area and looking for a good burger. I definitely found one! Their Four Cheese Jack Daniel's burger is to die for!! Their potato flats are a great change from the usual fry. I would definitely stop here again if in the area.

Brian van houten

Went for lunch after I saw the specials on Facebook and was not disappointed and Brianna the bar person was great Will be back

Ike Potts

My friend was annoyed that Jenna took our pitcher and cups away before it was empty and did not offer another round. Also she seemed to think we weren't going to pay. We felt unwelcome because She made a big deal about getting our card before bringing more drinks.

Daniel Sgambati

Very disappointed with my order. Ordered the Colossal Pretzel and it was hard as a rock and the side of cheese was frozen. The description says “it’s a pretzel that King Kong couldn’t finish” which makes perfect sense, after the first bite, he wouldn’t take another. Ordered a hot dog with sauerkraut and got a plain hot dog. Hot dog was the smallest hot dog I’ve ever seen, it looked like a #2 pencil on hot dog bun. The seasoned potato flats were so soggy my 8 month old son without teeth could’ve eaten them. I’ve never had issues with them in the past and ordered from them regularly. This will be the last time I order from them

Food: 1

Service: 1

Lisa DeMol

Bartender couldn’t be bothered - beer was flat - foo was so so

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

핻알런

Great food, great music, friendly service. Nice burgers and potato flats with magic dust for the win. I like the different spaces. And it was great to see Uncle Shoehorn shred it funky style.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Timothy Mitts

My kind of place. A very social environment.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ryan Karchner

wings, burgers, beer and bourbon - favorite bar in all of orange county. live music, horse racing, sports on every tv always. owners and staff are wonderful.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...