Mattingly's Tavern
16 N Main St, Florida
(845) 508-6675
Customers' Favorites
Jack Daniels Honey Bourbon Four-Cheese Bacon Burger w Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
The Triple Crown Burger with Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
Fried Oreos with Fluff Closer
Half Order of Wings 6
Menu
Photos
+34 photos
+33 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I have been to Mattingly's several times now. I live on Long Island, but stop off here on the way up to Sullivan County. The owner, Tom, is always super polite and welcoming. The bartenders are also extremely friendly, no matter when I go. They have a flawless upgraded Golden Tee '26 cabinet, which is extremely tough to find in the Hudson Valley. If I lived closer, I would live at this bar! 😁 Cheers!!
The perfect tavern wrapped in baseball history! The grilled chicken sandwich with bacon and cheddar on a pretzel bun was great but the fries were the best I’ve had in my life - seriously! Good beers and bourbon.
Kentucky Derby is always a fun day out! Everything you would expect from your local sports bar from quick bites to burgers, an array of thirst quenchers, music, sports and of course friends! Be sure to grab yourself some potato flats with the special seasoning ;)
You May Also Like
Cork - 24 N Main St
![]()
Wine Bar
Barrel 28 - 28 N Main St
![]()
Bar, Pizza, Salad, Bar & Grill
Pizza Bella - Florida NY - 8 S Main St
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Seafood, Vegetarian, Burgers