Rude service called regarding where parking is and he gave me one sentence than hung up
Adrian Gasowski
Cinelli's is a gem! Anyone rating this joint less than 5 stars is buggin.Parking: Plenty
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grandma, Pepperoni Pinwheels
jspeelma
The lasagna meatballs were amazing! The chicken Franchese was very flavorful with tender and juicy chicken. My friend had the Sunday Sauce, which was incredible. The service was friendly and attentive.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lisa Moldovan
Disappointed in the pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Robert Whittick
The pizza wasn’t bad. But I had a large pie half pepperoni delivered to my house. My house is less than a half a mile from Cinelli. They charge me 350 delivery fee plus I had to tip the driver three dollars. So that’s 650 just to get the pizza delivered. The pizza was $24. With delivery and tip? It came out to 30 bucks. I decided to look at some of the reviews. Owner states that the 350 delivery charge is to pay for gas and insurance for his oven trucks? The guy who delivered the pizza? Came in a little four-door Nissan. It was not an oven truck. It wasn’t a Cinelli’s vehicle. $30 to have a pizza delivered what amounted to about 10 blocks? Sorry. We won’t be doing that again.UPDATE: thank you for your response back and clarifying what I obviously made a mistake about. I’m just curious to know? Are you hiring? Because if you got 10 deliveries in an hour and the driver gets $3.50 for each delivery? That’s $35.00 an hour! That’s not even counting tips. Your guys must be making $50 - $60 an hour? That sounds like a great deal. Let me know. I’d be interested.
Kelia Hope
Cinelli's is my favorite pizza spot in NYC. I travel 20 minutes once per week to grab our favorite cheese pizza for me and my children. I even introduced my boss to there years ago after visiting others we didn't enjoy, and now he too won't eat any other pizza lol. Joey and the crew are so friendly, kind and courteous. My whole family is hooked on them, even the ones who visit me from other countries around the world. Best pizza and Italian food in New York. Period ????Parking: Free Parking available on restaurant grounds.Kid-friendliness: What can I say, the owners know my kids by name. That's friendly to me lol.Wheelchair accessibility: There's a ramp where persons in wheelchair can access facilities and there's accessible bathroom on the main floor for such, extra bathrooms available downstairs for all others.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Grandma, House Salad, Pizza Slices
Emil V Parrinello
Always a treat, great food and service. Another great event 1/26/24
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Evelyn Valentin
I went there with a Groupon and ask for Chicken Marsala. What they gave me was chicken breast just plain and they threw some sauce on top. I know that the chicken should be lightly coated with flour and the sauce was water down. I also had a few more dollars to make the amount of the Groupon and I had to bring that to their attention. I got some garlic knots to complete my order. Very disappointing and I will not go back.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Melanie C.
Cinelli's it's just Amazing! We love everything about it. From the food to the service. We have dine in couple of times, and order take out. It never disappoints I work not too far from it, and it's one of my number 1 spots to stop by for lunch for any pizza day at work, I always recommend to order from here ! Ohhhh the garlic knots are just to die for
Sotirios Ted Katsamakis
Delicious food & plenty. Sparse diners, so the service was solid & intimate. Value exceptional with a Groupon. Would definitely return.
Cinelli's pizza is amazing! We ordered a few pies for my son's birthday party and they added some delicious garlic knots on the house. The Grandma pizza is especially delicious and our favorite. This is my go to pizza place for either a slice or pie. My wife and I also love their pasta Wednesdays
Natalee ayala
It is so good my dad works there
Moe Sd
Food was so good. Ordered the shrimp scampi, grandma pizza, and house salad. The place is nice and spacious. They have on site parking which is very convenient. Definitely recommended.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grandma Pizza, Grandma, House Salad
Robby Zitarosa
Best buffalo slice in town hands
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alan Melgarejo
Very competent pizzeria restaurant with good flavors and plentiful food
Rude service called regarding where parking is and he gave me one sentence than hung up
Cinelli's is a gem! Anyone rating this joint less than 5 stars is buggin.Parking: Plenty
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grandma, Pepperoni Pinwheels
The lasagna meatballs were amazing! The chicken Franchese was very flavorful with tender and juicy chicken. My friend had the Sunday Sauce, which was incredible. The service was friendly and attentive.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Disappointed in the pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
The pizza wasn’t bad. But I had a large pie half pepperoni delivered to my house. My house is less than a half a mile from Cinelli. They charge me 350 delivery fee plus I had to tip the driver three dollars. So that’s 650 just to get the pizza delivered. The pizza was $24. With delivery and tip? It came out to 30 bucks. I decided to look at some of the reviews. Owner states that the 350 delivery charge is to pay for gas and insurance for his oven trucks? The guy who delivered the pizza? Came in a little four-door Nissan. It was not an oven truck. It wasn’t a Cinelli’s vehicle. $30 to have a pizza delivered what amounted to about 10 blocks? Sorry. We won’t be doing that again.UPDATE: thank you for your response back and clarifying what I obviously made a mistake about. I’m just curious to know? Are you hiring? Because if you got 10 deliveries in an hour and the driver gets $3.50 for each delivery? That’s $35.00 an hour! That’s not even counting tips. Your guys must be making $50 - $60 an hour? That sounds like a great deal. Let me know. I’d be interested.
Cinelli's is my favorite pizza spot in NYC. I travel 20 minutes once per week to grab our favorite cheese pizza for me and my children. I even introduced my boss to there years ago after visiting others we didn't enjoy, and now he too won't eat any other pizza lol. Joey and the crew are so friendly, kind and courteous. My whole family is hooked on them, even the ones who visit me from other countries around the world. Best pizza and Italian food in New York. Period ????Parking: Free Parking available on restaurant grounds.Kid-friendliness: What can I say, the owners know my kids by name. That's friendly to me lol.Wheelchair accessibility: There's a ramp where persons in wheelchair can access facilities and there's accessible bathroom on the main floor for such, extra bathrooms available downstairs for all others.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Grandma, House Salad, Pizza Slices
Always a treat, great food and service. Another great event 1/26/24
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I went there with a Groupon and ask for Chicken Marsala. What they gave me was chicken breast just plain and they threw some sauce on top. I know that the chicken should be lightly coated with flour and the sauce was water down. I also had a few more dollars to make the amount of the Groupon and I had to bring that to their attention. I got some garlic knots to complete my order. Very disappointing and I will not go back.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Cinelli's it's just Amazing! We love everything about it. From the food to the service. We have dine in couple of times, and order take out. It never disappoints I work not too far from it, and it's one of my number 1 spots to stop by for lunch for any pizza day at work, I always recommend to order from here ! Ohhhh the garlic knots are just to die for
Delicious food & plenty. Sparse diners, so the service was solid & intimate. Value exceptional with a Groupon. Would definitely return.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Cinelli's pizza is amazing! We ordered a few pies for my son's birthday party and they added some delicious garlic knots on the house. The Grandma pizza is especially delicious and our favorite. This is my go to pizza place for either a slice or pie. My wife and I also love their pasta Wednesdays
It is so good my dad works there
Food was so good. Ordered the shrimp scampi, grandma pizza, and house salad. The place is nice and spacious. They have on site parking which is very convenient. Definitely recommended.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grandma Pizza, Grandma, House Salad
Best buffalo slice in town hands
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very competent pizzeria restaurant with good flavors and plentiful food
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4