Fredonia Buddy Brewster’s Ale House

A decent spot for a meal!

I'd say nothing was quite outstanding but we left fairly satisfied.

The pretzel was okay. Warm, fluffy, and salted. The cheese sauce had a nice consistency but was pretty bland.

The wings were okay too. I liked the sauce and juicy meat, but they didn't have that crisp that we all know and love.

Service was good and restaurant was clean and spacious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Honestly the worst services we've ever had. Got seated and was sitting at the table for 10 minutes, nobody came and took a drink order but multiple staff walked to the table behind us. We didn't even order food. We left because it wasnt busy at all and that kind of services is absolutely ridiculous.

Service: 1

i’ve been here a couple times. service isn’t terrible but the food is kind of crap. their burgers are a bit dry and their chicken is way too salty. tator tots/fries are always cold. they got rid of the buffalo chicken tator tots which was the only thing saving the cold tots… you guys should bring them back and maybe i’ll return, who knows 🤷‍♀️

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

We were camping not far away & came here on Father's Day as a last minute decision. We had been running out of good dining options in the area & found this place. We noticed many cars in the lot & took it as a good sign. Table nearby told us to order the tots as a side & they were excellent. My Philly Cheesesteak was excellent as was my husbands beef on weck with garlic wings. We will most definitely be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I was never here before because I always thought it was just like a ale place but it's way more than that it is a wonderful restaurant with wonderful staff and some of the best food around this area.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Beef on Weck, Wings, Alehouse Mac \u0026 Cheese

Stopped in by chance looking for somewhere on a Sunday. The roast beef sandwich special was good. A little salty for my taste but still got devoured. The blueberry wheat ale, good. Our server made the place great...Devin was friendly, not overbearing and patient. She had to put up with me, that says a LOT. She always had a smile and great attitud. Do I recommend this place to anyone in the area? Definitely. Nice place, good food, great staff at a decent price.

Great food, easy place to get in and out of.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

In town for a long weekend at our cottage, this was our first time eating here. I was so excited they have an entire Gluten Free menu since I can’t eat gluten. Our drinks were excellent and strong, which was a nice surprise.
We each got an appetizer and meal. Spinach Artichoke dip was great, my BLT + cheese with fries was good, it was on a GF bun. I don’t like under ripe pink tomatoes so I took those off, kinda disappointed.
My fiancé got loaded tots, they were delicious and a black & blue burger with chips, he said it was really good. Definitely will be back next time we are in town!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Stopped in and had dinner with a friend at Buddy Brewster's. It was an unfortunate experience as both the food and service were dreadful. The overall taste and quality left a lot to be desired and I can't imagine ever returning to the restaurant nor would I ever recommend anyone else go.

Today my boyfriend and I wanted to try something new. So we did!! I will say it was amazing. The food was great and you get so much for the price. We are in love and will be back for sure. Already told all my friends and now planning a group outting to have dinner here. Can't say enough positive things.

Kid-friendliness: Sit down family place. Did have kids menu, but didn't look at it cause we didn't have children with us at the time.

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Alehouse Mac & Cheese

this is the 2nd time i’ve RAN to the bathroom after eating here, once was after chicken wing dip, another was after the artichoke & spinach dip. i don’t recommend there stuff is so greasy it runs thru u, and our waitress was not the best after asking for utensils not once but twice, slow with bringing us new drinks and did not take our old dishes away and left them on the table which led to us being a bit cluttered. also i have a stomach ache and bearly got to eat because my stomach started hurting before my dinner came out due to appetizer. never again going.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

terrible service. none of our dishes were taken, had to ask for silverware twice. by the time we got forks our appetizers were cold. when our meals came up my pasta was room temperature at best. a few bites reminded me of a ice cream sunday. anything from the fryer tasted like the oil hasn’t been changed since last year. terrible service. food was less then okay. would rather of dined in at mcdonald’s. not to mention the bathroom warfare afterwards. can’t believe i spent $78 for 2 there.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 1

The Buffalo chips are absolutely amazing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pickle Fries, Hamburger, Tater Tots

Overall great place. My husband and I decided to stop in, since we were in the area. This was a first time for us both as we have never been in before.
Got seats right away (3:30pm) and got drinks right away too. The food was decent, got a sampler to share. My only complaints; were that the, cheese curds tasted a little burnt... Maybe the oil in the fryers needed some changing?( I was a cook) The buffalo logs were ok, but the insides were more like a pate, instead of shredded chicken?(Which wasn't bad..just a little off putting) My husband got a prime rib pot roast which we absolutely loved! And I got a apple, chicken walnut salad! Which was amazing 😍. My husband also got a beer, which he enjoyed. Overall our food wasn't bad. The server was friendly and very helpful. We will be back, in the future.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Lips