Uncle Bacala's

2370 Jericho Turnpike, Garden City Park
(516) 739-0505

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Brian

The problem with this place is that it is so good that everyone wants to eat there. They are good with reservations so when I know that I need to get my fix, I make sure that I made my reservations. The Food the Service are the best.

Elizabeth

Our favorite restaurant. Always welcoming, staff is excellent. Ellianna is our favorite. Best server around.

Robert

Great dining experience. Delicious food, great service--Barbara's the best. We love to come to Uncle Bacala's.

JoAnnDAmico

I made reservations for a party of 7 for Thanksgiving day in Sept .I know that a hectic time for restaurants and a huge money maker. We were seated outside with the wind chill 31 degrees they did have a heat lamp. the wind blew so strong it caused the lights on the frame of the tent to disconnect. I asked if we could move to another table I was told they would come back with an answer never did we were the only people in this tent with at least 4 EMPTY table .they did place a heater outside the tent which was ok for 2 people sitting near it. I the zipper remained open wind blowing making our 1st family dinner together very unpleasant. I guess they are concerned about making money not being thoughtful of their customers. If they want to seat people outside they could make a more stationery tent with a door that closes. I would not rate this restaurant for holiday's they can't make proper accommodations

Michael

Celebrating my wife and my birthday with our 4 kids and had another great experience as always. Started with calamari that was perfectly fried and tender and delicious arancini. Cocktails were slow from the bar but mixed perfectly. My son and I had our favorite Cioppino and my wife had the grilled chicken Milanese. My daughter had a huge perfectly grilled piece of salmon, y other son's rigatoni a la vodka was al debate and delicious and my youngest son loved his favorite chicken parm. For desert the wafflini was huge and enjoyed by all. Another great meal at our favorite place.

Christa Garbin

First time visit. Invited by friends that love the place. Service was really on point. Which says a lot with how busy they were. It was a packed house, yet staff was very attentive. The food was fantastic. My husband said his veal was the best he has had in a long time. I wish we had thought about taking pictures. We were just enjoying ourselves to much. Will definitely return

Debbie

Monday night is a good time to go-to Uncle Bacala to avoid the incessant noise and inability to talk with your dining companions. Food is what you would expect from a restaurant on par with Uncle Bacala. Very pedestrian quality Italian food and nothing very special. Very large portions of average food. Tuscan onion soup was enjoyed by our friend. Two huge chicken cutlets covered in diced onion and tomato was my choice. No side dish was included with this entree. My guy had the rigatoni with prosciutto and crushed tomatoes and onions. We shared sweet strawberries served with canned whipped cream and a very good pumpkin cheesecake. Overall, a good, but certainly not great, dinner!

Paolo Pelizzoli

Great Bartender!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Odelia

Cozy atmosphere and genuinely warm service. The owners clearly care about their guests and made us feel truly welcomed. The food was delicious and the whole experience was lovely. Definitely a spot I'm excited to return to.

Jeff Laperuta

Came in from Brooklyn for lunch and decided to stop here. Everything was great. Our server Eliana was very professional. In the area don’t pass this place up.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

MEGHAN ROSE

I went there for a work related lunch. Valet parking was nice and the food was great. Nice establishment.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Alane

My mixed green salad was fresh. The salmon was fresh, moist and was cooked to my specifications. And the waitress Barbara tipped off the great experience

Dr. Dennis

Great food and waitress but check to see that menu prices do not match online prices. Not impressed with front staff. I asked for a special birthday table and the hostess tried to seat me near the noisy kitchen. Front manager was not the friendliest . I won't be back. Sad since the chef is great

Allison

Always the best. My son's 14th birthday celebration!! He loves uncle Baccala as much as we do! !

Sylvia

This place never disappoints. Delicious baked clams, lobster ravioli and chicken with eggplant....Bacala sundae hit the spot.

Loading...